Courtesy of The Educator's Room:
Truth is, the problem with the American student is the American adult. Deadbeat dads, pushover moms, vulgar celebrities, self-interested politicians, depraved ministers, tax-sheltering CEOs, steroid-injecting athletes, benefit-collecting retirees who vote down school taxes, and yes, incompetent teachers—all take their turns conspiring to neglect the needs of the young in favor of the wants of the old. The line of malefactors stretches out before our children; they take turns dealing them drugs, unhealthy foods, skewed values messages, consumerist pap, emotional and physical and sexual traumas, racist messages of aspersion for their cultures, and countless other strains of vicious disregard. Nevertheless, many pundits and politicians are happy to train their rhetorical fire uniquely on the teachers, and the damnable hive-feast on the souls of our young continues unabated. We’re told not to worry because good teachers will simply overcome this American psychic cannibalism and drag our hurting children across the finish line ahead of the Finnish lions.
Yeah, right.
Today, teachers across the land dutifully cast their seeds on ever-rockier ground. We were all told that a mind is a terrible thing to waste, and we all became adamant about education; but no one told us not to waste kids’ hearts or weaken their spines or soften their guts, and we long ago abandoned our traditional cultural expectations for children’s formation. I’m not calling for picket fences and Leave it to Beaver; I’m calling for childhoods that aren’t dripping with pain and disenchantment and a huge chasm where there should have been character-building experiences from the age of zero to five. That aren’t marked by an empty space where there should have been a disciplinarian. And a gap where there should have been a rocking chair and a soft lap waiting when the child was hurting. I am referring to missing ingredients that I now recognize as the absolute essentials, things I took for granted when I was too young to realize I had won the parent lottery.
Adults—not merely teachers—have caused these little ones to stumble, but journalists and nonprofits and interloping government experts offer not a hand to the young but rather a cat-of-nine-tails across the backs of their teachers. Injustice for teachers is confused with justice for kids.
“Waiting for ‘Superman’” told teachers they were terrible, callous, and incompetent, that only magnanimous charter school operatives could save victimized children from their rapacious clutches.
NCLB told teachers they would only be considered successful if 100% of their students passed 100% of their tests.
Condoleezza Rice told teachers they were so ineffective that they were a national security threat.
Chris Christie told teachers that when two or more of them gather, they are thugs. Suddenly, the apple-themed knit sweater is a symbol of American menace rivaling the leather biker jacket.
“Won’t Back Down” actors Viola Davis, Maggie Gyllenhall, Ving Rhames, and Holly Hunter used their art to communicate that teachers only want union protections so they can lock poor children in closets, and that the only way to protect children from the plague of heartless unionized miscreants mal-educating them across this land is by letting their parents hand over local schools to wholly benevolent charter school operators led by the friendly Mother Teresas behind Parent Revolution.
There is more and I urge you to read the whole article by clicking the link at the top. (Even President Obama doesn't get a pass, and in many ways he shouldn't.)
I don't know about the rest of you but watching teachers get vilified in the media and by various ungrateful politicians is pissing me the hell off!
I have told you before that it was teachers who saved my life when I was on the fast track to a prison cell, and who refused to give up on me well past the time when anybody simply worried about punching a clock or collecting a paycheck would have thrown me out of school without a second thought.
I owe those teachers and school administrators EVERYTHING!
And if most of us really think back to who inspired us I am sure that the majority of you would share that feeling of gratitude
This is all about politics, and the dumbing down of the electorate, and has NOTHING to do with teachers or their job performance. Sadly they are just in the way of the Republican party doing away with one of the Democratic party's biggest campaign donors and most aggressive surrogates, the teacher's unions, and for that reason alone they have found themselves targeted for character assassination and constant attacks on their job performance.
All of this has been orchestrated by the GOP, and everybody who piles on, and yes that includes our President, is simply doing the Republican party's dirty work for them.
It is time for us to stand up for these selfless public servants by refusing to watch any movie that denigrates them, refuse to support any candidate who attacks them, and refuse stand idly by while any member of the media smears them.
I owe them everything, and everything from me is what they can expect in return.
Our national decision to exalt the bankers while looting teachers' retirements will not end well for us.
ReplyDeleteGryphen,
ReplyDeleteI thank you for this post from the bottom of my heart!
The comment in my local paper that had me seeing red: "Teachers don't need to be paid so much because they get paid in job satisfaction."
ReplyDeleteWhen I turned down an engineering job for a community college faculty position that paid 50% less I figured yeah, I'll have fewer hours to work. But that first year I kept track of hours (nights, weekends, no lunch breaks, summer prep) and found I was actually working 10 percent MORE hours teaching than I did as an engineer. I'm still teaching 20 years later- must be that "job satisfaction".
I was once told that by the family I babysat for when I wanted a raise from 50 cents an hour to 50 cents an hour and 75 cents an hour after midnight. I got paid in "love and kindness." That was fifty some years ago and I still remember.
DeleteA bigger problem than teachers is the damn administration and bad principals.
ReplyDeleteTotally true and the main reason they can't get rid of bad teachers. Administrators aren't properly evaluating teachers and creating a paper trail of documentation. All the union can do is guarantee due process for a teacher. They cannot refuse to have a bad teacher fired.
DeleteTony Danza's new book is an excellent description of what teachers do and how no one can replace them.
ReplyDeleteWelcome to the culture war against teachers, coming to a theater near you
ReplyDeletehttp://www.dailykos.com/story/2012/09/30/1130794/-Welcome-to-the-culture-war-against-teachers-coming-to-a-theater-near-you
Anti-teachers union movie sets near-record as box office bomb
"Won't Back Down," the movie that paints teachers unions as the main culprit in low student achievement, has achieved a record of sorts. According to boxofficemojo, it had the second all-time-worst debut of any movie with a wide opening since 1982 (as far back as the site goes).
The only movie to have done worse is a 2008 film called "The Rocker," which opened in 2,784 theaters to a dismal $2,636,048.
"Won't Back Down" made an estimated $2,700,000 in 2,515 theaters.
I guess American audiences were just not that into a movie that lays the blame for the state of education at the feet of hard-working teachers.
Sarah and Todd appreciate teachers.
ReplyDeleteThis has to be sarcasm! I am not sure they have enough experience with teachers to know what they are all about, even though Mr. Heath claims to be one. Come to think of it, maybe that is why they don't see that their kids go to school.
DeleteAnonymous5:49 AM
DeleteNice try! Baldy and the Toad can't even SPELL "teacher" much less "appreciate" them!
Put down the pee pee smelling kool-aid your're drinking...okay! LOL!!!
This must be sarcasm. Sarah and Todd despise teachers. Chuck Heath's brand of "teaching" is grossing out the kids and helping his daughter cheat and lie her way out of her obligations.
DeleteI'd encourage everyone to go to the site via G's link and read the comments to the article, most of which are by teachers and unfortunately includes some former and soon-to-be former teachers.
ReplyDeleteIt's discouraging and alarming but it's also real. From my business background, I know that I would have sleepless nights until I addressed the issue and had a plan in place to fix the system if a significant portion of my sales force or front-line employees were this discouraged, and felt as unappreciated as many teachers do these days.
Here's the link again:
http://theeducatorsroom.com/2012/09/the-exhaustion-of-the-american-teacher/
A very powerful article; as was your response to it, Gryphen. Oh, and as for the movie "Waiting for Superman"...here is another problematic aspect of that movie. It made it seem as if any child who didn't get into the "right" school was doomed to a life of hell and abject failure. Which, for all the yammering from charter school supporters about "parental control and empowerment" basically negates anything a child learns or experiences away from school as all but useless. In short, it says that a parent has very minimal impact on their child's outcome.
ReplyDeletePersonally, I don't object to charter schools if they are honestly there to provide certain alternatives to children who would benefit from a different way of learning, a different curricula, etc. But I absolutely do not support this vicious smear campaign against teachers that some of the most prominent advocates of charter schools are engaging in.
When asked what do teachers "make", the answer is always "a difference"
ReplyDeleteAmen. The only way out of poverty is to get an education. Were it not for the GI bill (I am a Navy vet), student loans and some exceptional teachers all along the way, I am sure I would be asking folks if they want french fries with their order today.
ReplyDeleteTeachers are the most undervalued professionals today. But I hear all the R's these days hating on the teachers. What is their problem?
Thanks G. I started teaching in 1966 in a low income school. Over the years, I worked mostly in low income schools. I don't know when the decline in attitude towards schools started. When I started, teachers were still respected and children were generally well behaved. Classroom management was not the huge issue it is today.
ReplyDeleteThe Reagan Administration was devastating to social services. That was when the schools started worrying about far more than education; more two working families appeared as families tried to make ends meet; children were a lot more stressed. We started seeing the "latch key" kid. Over time, and culminating with NCLB, the schools were under more and more pressure and the kids were less and less prepared for the classroom. (I mostly worked Birth-7 or 8).
Its not that parents don't care. I've only met one I thought didn't care and I'm sure she was clinically depressed and couldn't care. Many parents are so weighed down by trying to keep all the balls in the air, they are unable to be effective in their caring. I believe this country made a huge mistake putting all available adults to work. There is no one to tend the "home fires" and kids are pretty much raising themselves today which explains a lot of behavior. (Of course why we put all available adults to work is another topic and doesn't speak well of the top 1%)
It used to be children were raised by the community, church, parents, and schools. Now, in many places, and in many families, only the teacher is left. And we wonder why that teacher isn't able to cope with it all.
I have the utmost respect for teachers, and the valuable role they play in shaping our society. Our priorities are ass backward in this country, we pay athletes and entertainers huge salaries and ignore the hard work teachers do and the difference they make in our children's (and society as a whole) future.
ReplyDeleteI owe a debt of gratitude to all the teachers who instilled a love of learning, good self esteem, work habits, discipline and support through all the stages of my life.
Along the way, I volunteered as a teacher's aid at my children's schools, and saw for myself the determination, hard work, and personal sacrifice they made to educate kids.
The comments in the article are heartbreaking.