Saturday, February 09, 2013

Missouri Republican Representative wants to alter the definitions of scientific terms in order to make Creationism seem like science. Which it's not!

Courtesy of Mother Jones:

Late last month, Rick Brattin, a Republican state representative in Missouri, introduced a bill that would require that intelligent design and "destiny" get the same educational treatment and textbook space in Missouri schools as the theory of evolution. Brattin insists that his bill has nothing to do with religion—it's all in the name of science. 

"I'm a science enthusiast...I'm a huge science buff," Brattin tells The Riverfront Times. "This [bill] is about testable data in today's world." But Eric Meikle, education project director at the National Center for Science Education, disagrees. "This bill is very idiosyncratic and strange," he tells Mother Jones. "And there is simply not scientific evidence for intelligence design." 

HB 291, the "Missouri Standard Science Act," redefines a few things you thought you already knew about science. For example, a "hypothesis" is redefined as something that reflects a "minority of scientific opinion and is "philosophically unpopular." A scientific theory is "an inferred explanation...whose components are data, logic and faith-based philosophy." And "destiny" is not something that $5 fortune tellers believe in; Instead, it's "the events and processes that define the future of the universe, galaxies, stars, our solar system, earth, plant life, animal life, and the human race." 

The bill requires that Missouri elementary and secondary schools—and even introductory science classes in public universities—give equal textbook space to both evolution and intelligent design (any other "theories of origin" are allowed to be taught as well, so pick your favorite creation myth—I'm partial to the Russian raven spirit.) "I can't imagine any mainstream textbook publisher would comply with this," Meikle says. "The material doesn't exist."

"I'm a science enthusiast?" Don't you have to have some understanding of a subject BEFORE you can become a fan?

This guy is a fan of science the way a rapist is a fan of women.

You know this may be one of the most devious and  troubling attacks on science yet.

If this asshole is successful in changing the very definitions that science uses in order to differentiate itself from faith or belief, than he will make it that much harder to fight allowing Creationism to be taught in the public school classroom.

I would usually make jokes at this idiot's expense, but this actually sends a chill up my spine. The people of Missouri need to stand up to this ignorance before it takes hold and then spreads to other states as well.

40 comments:

  1. Anonymous10:14 AM

    How to lie creatively so the good kkkristyun folk will think you're being clever but "within the rules" to further advance the kkkristyun Taliban cause.

    People, fire these assholes wasting time on this nonsense.

    ReplyDelete
  2. When I first looked at your picture of him what I saw was the logical culmination of the self-esteem educational movement.

    He knows he's right. He's been told that his entire life. And his love of science is, of course, science fiction.

    He also reminds me of the children touting Goldwater in 1964.

    Certainty rules among the ignorant.

    Thanks for the reporting!

    I lived in MO for several years. The ignorance running rampant there is scary.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. fromthediagonal11:21 AM

      ... Certainty rules among the ignorant... Thank you, Suzan @10:32!!! May I borrow this?

      Delete
  3. Anonymous10:38 AM

    Science for this dolt was making stink bombs with his chemistry set.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous10:51 AM

    I had hoped for more from his generation. I can understand how people over 60 might still be taken in by fanatical religionists and Fox news, but I thought young people his age to be more savvy than that.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey, I'm almost 60, and I will never be taken in by fanatical religion of Fox. I always thught the 700 Club and its copies were creepy cults, not Christian in any way (Jesus never asked for money, did he?) My mom is 82, and she is a faithful MSNBC watcher and questioner. Of course, she is not a Christian and told me recently she is sure there is no afterlife, which scares her to death as she sees friends dying.
      On the other end of the age spectrum, my 50 something sibs are staunch Fox fans..'they do not lie!' they insist. Aaarggh

      Delete
    2. Anonymous2:56 PM

      Never judge a book by its cover. A lot of us 60 somethings were 60's anti-war activists, marched for racial equality, etc.(me included, 62). We've been on the case of these shitwads all along. Will you be there too when you get to our age? I hope so, because all us old farts will be gone. Don't take no mess, EVER.

      Delete
  5. Anonymous11:13 AM

    Wow, that guy is pretty. Seriously, with a blond wig he'd be a gorgeous woman. Just sayin'

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. LMAO! Too bad he's STUPID! But he sure is nice to look at though!

      Delete
    2. Anonymous12:12 PM

      AND.....the real danger.......science does back up the fact that we are engineered to like pretty faces. He will get far even though what he has to say is bully pucky. He is cute as hell, and will have doors swung open wide to let him in.....We need to watch this one, for SURE.

      Delete
  6. They have already re written history, I am not surprised that science was next.

    We all need to fight back against this type of stuff!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous12:06 PM

      They'll stop before they get to math, calculus, differential equations, etc.

      Because it's math. They don't need no stinkin' math. They're idiots.

      Delete
  7. WakeUpAmerica11:21 AM

    Just another theocratic maroon trying to impose his bizarre beliefs on everyone else. Every time I hear one of these idiots, I swear Jesus is doing a facepalm in heaven. The problem isn't in believing in Jesus. The problem is zealots who believe in the infallibility of the Bible and then interpret it to fit their peculiar ideas.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous9:19 PM

      AS I've said before... I believe that "God" looks down and says: "This is NOT what I had in mind"

      VernD

      Delete
  8. Leland11:24 AM

    ANYTHING which postulates an "Intelligence" or "Superior Being" or "God" or whatever you wish to describe it, that is NOT human (or another species of alien life such as "little green men" when/if they show up) falls under the heading of religion or religious theory or even religious philosophy and DOES NOT BELONG IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS!!!!!!!!!!! To allow it, simply flies in the face of this being a secular country.

    While I understand this is the goal of shits like this piece of Xtian crap, I fear that ultimately it will happen because too few of us -ESPECIALLY our elected officials - refuse to refute these fools and call them what they are: IGNORANT!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. WakeUpAmerica4:12 PM

      Absolutely. As a Christian and a teacher in public school, I would NEVER bring religion into my classroom unless I was presenting it from an historical perspective. For one thing, it is disrespectful to people of other religions or no religion. While some of my students in this conservative town are Bible-thumping teenagers, I like to point out to them that whatever path a person takes that makes him/her a better person and the world a better place is a good path. We don't all have to walk down the same road.

      Delete
    2. Maple8:53 PM

      And here I thought Missouri was the "show me" state.

      Delete
  9. Where the f*ck do these idiots keep coming from? Is someone leaving a gate open at the nut house again? What is even more disturbing is they are somehow getting elected to higher office. I am old enough to remember when you had to be smart in order to run for higher offices.

    I have news for pretty boy, you want to have your religious beliefs reflected in your school curriculum? Send your idiot kids to a religious school! Leave the public schools and already established facts alone.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cracklin Charlie1:00 PM

      That's perfect, Rover!

      Delete
  10. WakeUpAmerica11:29 AM

    So basically what dickhead wants is for schools to teach religious theory in public school. I'm sure he doesn't want the school to teach his kids sex ed, but, by golly, he wants the schools to teach his kids religious theory. WTF?

    Here's your head condom, dumbass, so we don't catch your intellectual STD's.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous11:53 AM

      But only HIS religious theory, NOT the Wiccan or Muslim Or Buddhist or Satanic or whatever other religion's theories...

      Delete
  11. Anonymous11:42 AM

    I so dislike the constant downgrading the Republican party continues doing against President Obama. It doesn't matter what he does!

    I hope the Tea Party response and that of the Republican party (aren't they all in the Republican party?) are watched by few nationwide.

    I'd love to be a fly in the living quarters of the White House as it would be a kick hearing what President Obama and First Lady Michelle REALLY say about the assholes' They BOTH remain so calm ALWAYS. I admire them greatly!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Cracklin Charlie12:48 PM

    Believe it or not, most Missourians are not this stupid. And I have to disagree with your analogy, Gryphen...the guy is a fan of science the way I am a fan of automobile mechanics. As in, I know absolutely nothing about automobile mechanics.

    I doubt that his proposal will pass, as the Republican assholes in the state lege would never appropriate the money to publish new teaching materials for every student in schools through early college.

    What really ticks me off about these guys, and I swear to Dog, they do this every year, is the colossal amount of my time and tax dollars that are being wasted in Jefferson City on these ridiculous proposals. We have real problems in this state. Why can't they spend even a little time on the real problems, and take a break from the Christian pseudo-persecution?

    ReplyDelete
  13. our lad12:59 PM

    Ah fuck 'em, fuck 'em all. Chuckleheads like this dipshit just keep draggin the Republican party toward their inevitable destiny. The Whigs, The Know Nothings,soon they'll have company in the dustbin of history. Made their bed, fluff up the pillows and have a nice long fuckin endless sleep, asshats.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. our lad8:30 PM

      I mean "toward their end" Shitty writing from me to ya'll.

      Delete
  14. Anonymous1:01 PM

    That pretty boy looks like he might be a "huge heterosexual!" too. Not that there's anything wrong with that.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous2:29 PM

      A SEVERE heterosexual, I'm sure. .

      My gaydar is erratic at times so I try to err on the side of "What do I know and do I care?" Because, unless someone is professing to be holier-than-thou, I don't care about their sexual orientation.

      But I have a couple of gay friends that KNOW when someone is a closet-case hypocrite. Like me, they hate the hypocrisy, not the hetero guys or gals.

      My own experience tells me that those who preach and pray the loudest do so to compensate for either theelfin self-doubt, self-loathing, or just to be deceptive about their ulterior motives. My perception in recognizing shills and hypocrites is much sharper than my ability to detect teh gays.

      Just my two cents worth....

      BBB

      Delete
    2. Anonymous3:55 PM

      Your gaydar is pinging? Me too.

      Delete
    3. Anonymous6:22 AM

      Beep beep beep...

      Delete
  15. Anonymous1:13 PM

    If they do this, watch how the kids who graduate from Missouri after this is started do NOT get scholarships or admittance into any university.

    ReplyDelete
  16. AKinPA1:41 PM

    OK. I'm a huge elitist. I looked this guy up in Project Vote Smart. Under Education, it says “Graduate, Lees Summit High School, 1999.” So, he has no post-secondary education and he’s defining scientific terms for an entire state. Welcome to Third World Amurika, land of the freedumbs, home of the stupids. Poor Bobby Jindal! His party doesn’t have a chance.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous2:53 PM

      LOL. I know you were saying that tongue-in-cheek about being "elite", but your message is 100% on point. If a person is going to listen to someone else's screech, it's best to to be able to discern if you should be taking notes, or listening carefully for the punch line. Or in this case, ignoring them until you have the opportunity to kick them to the curb along wth the other uninformed demagogues making so much noise.

      Delete
  17. WakeUpAmerica2:17 PM

    That boy needs to back away from the teeth whitener!!
    People with only a high school education have no business proposing education policy for others.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Boscoe8:29 PM

    We need Democrats introducing bills designed to revoke the tax-exempt status of churches unless they spend equal time teaching evolution. Fair is fair.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Anita Winecooler8:43 PM

    I'm a science buff, too! My specialty is neuroscience. Wonder if this guy wants to make an appointment to see me? I read all about frontal lobotomies and just need a little pracbtice!

    See? Problem solved!

    Actually, I'd probably faint at just the sound of the cranial saw.
    Scary stuff! He's got a high school diploma and wants to change science education?

    ReplyDelete
  20. Anonymous9:41 PM

    OMG. Will these people just attempt a geology course? Absolute willful ignorance.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Anonymous9:57 PM

    I recognize those teeth from a glory hole i visited near Elmira.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Anonymous6:31 AM

    I get the same feeling looking at this Rep, as I got from Sarah Palin the first time I saw her.
    Creepy,lying,self loving. He thinks, he is on the gravy train and has many great things in store..Not for the people he represents, only self.
    I don't think he's pretty,he looks devious to me.

    ReplyDelete

Don't feed the trolls!
It just goes directly to their thighs.