Courtesy of Mediaite:
CNN’s Wolf Blitzer demonstrated why you should never assume someone believes in God while interviewing a survivor of the Oklahoma tornado Tuesday afternoon. Blitzer spoke to a young woman named Rebecca, who escaped with her 19-month-old son just moments before the tornado destroyed their home.
While their narrow escape from harm may have seemed miraculous, Rebecca evidently didn’t see it that way. At the end of the interview, Blitzer told her, “You’re blessed. Brian, your husband is blessed. Anders is blessed… I guess you got to thank the lord, right?” When the woman shrugged off the question, he repeated it, asking, “Do you thank the lord for that split-second decision?”
“I–I’m actually an atheist,” she responded. After the awkward laughter that followed, she added, “We are here and you know, I don’t blame anybody for thanking the lord.”
“Of course not,” Blitzer replied.
Of course I also do not blame anybody for thanking God, regardless of which God it is, for their survival. What these people went through must have frightened them to their very core.
However I cannot help but feel a powerful sense of pride when I see somebody strong enough to go through something like that without the need to seek solace in mythological beings.
And the fact she said it on national television? So awesome!
Amen! For every newscaster who asks about thanking the lord, I would respond, why did God send the tornado in the first place.
ReplyDeletetrue - God creates numerous disasters and never gets the blame.
DeleteI love that this woman had the courage to stand up to the newscaster and speak her thoughts.
Some people don't need to believe in Magic to survive.
Exactly! Why would you THANK god? Why wouldn't you CURSE such an evil deity for traumatizing you, brutally destroying your town, and killing dozens of people?
DeleteBut I guarantee you, it won't be long before the survivors of this catastrophe hold a prayer service to thank their evil god for not making it even worse.
Religion = Stockholm syndrome.
Whatever happened to... "Shit happens"?
DeleteI would of had a good one for him.
I would of said Mother Earth is trying to cleanse herself b/c of all the oil spilling/drilling/fracking/pollution/overpopulation etc.
You know what else bugs me? How come EVERY FLIPPIN' time PBO gives a pressor or speech he HAS to end it with "and god bless the united states of america"?
DeleteIf he doesn't say it, you know what will happen? Newt screaming "They're trying to take god out of the 'square'. (whatever that means) It would be a huge scandal. But it make mes ILL!
What about Goddess?
Or The supreme Mother blesses the USA?
Or the man in the moon?
Why Does he HAVE to say this? Bugs the flip out of me!!!
As a Christian, I totally agree with you, Gryph.
ReplyDeleteKudos to this women for sticking to her principles, especially when under major stress standing in the wreckage of her home.
ReplyDeleteAdmittedly I've never been under that kind of stress but when I'm confronted with a demand to thank "the lord", I try to avoid the whole question of what I believe in. It's nobody's business but mine. My usual tactic is to say "who is this lord your talking about" or "define lord, please". That backs them off without my having to defend my own beliefs.
When absolutely forced, I say "so you think god is a guy". It's a sure conversation stopper.
"When absolutely forced, I say "so you think god is a guy". It's a sure conversation stopper."
DeleteGood one, I will remember that. Thanks.
What even was the point in him pressing her? Does he just have that deep-seated a need to flaunt Christianity?
ReplyDeleteWolf Blitzer continued to press her for an answer because making women submit is part of his "religion".
Delete5:28 a.m. I think you have an interesting point. Religious bullying is a subtle but ever-present aspect in conversations with evangelicals — similar to engaging with a person who suffers obsessive-compulsive disorder, as everything they think is observed through the lens of their imaginary friend.
DeleteToday is Harvey Milk Day.
ReplyDelete“The only thing they have to look forward to is hope. And you have to give them hope. Hope for a better world, hope for a better tomorrow, hope for a better place to come to if the pressures at home are too great. Hope that all will be all right. Without hope, not only gays, but the blacks, the seniors, the handicapped, the us’es, the us’es will give up. And if you help elect to the central committee and other offices, more gay people, that gives a green light to all who feel disenfranchised, a green light to move forward. It means hope to a nation that has given up, because if a gay person makes it, the doors are open to everyone.”
www.queerty.com/giving-them-hope-harvey-milks-top-7-quotes-20130522/
Wolf Blitzer needs to retire.
ReplyDeleteBeaglemom
Well said Beaglemom. Wolf presents some pretty shaky journalistic behavior in this clip. Journalists are told to keep themselves out of the story, but evangelical reporters always ignore this advice and it bites them in the butt. There is no reporting going on the minute religious or political views are introduced.
DeleteAdd in being vegetarian and a non drinker and you pretty much sum up some rather awkward conversations I've had at parties over the years. Good for her and shame on Wolf for trying to insert god into his news report.
ReplyDeleteSince when is something like that a legitimate journalistic question??? I'm sick to death of constantly having god pushed into my face by the media!
ReplyDeleteMy take: she was polite, in spite of everything. Blitzer was pushy and rude, inserting his own values into his public presentation, esp bad for a reporter.
ReplyDeleteJuan Mendez Invokes Carl Sagan While Leading Arizona House Of Representatives Pre-Session Prayer
ReplyDeletehttp://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/05/22/juan-mendez-carl-sagan_n_3316864.html
Since when is a reporter of a major news organization allowed to aak a question like that? Reporters are supposed to be impartial, especially about politics & religion.
ReplyDeleteI never liked him anyway & the way he shifts about during his segments in the newsroom is so distracting, but now I really dislike him.
R in NC
Why would anyone hire god as their general contractor? Fires, floods, earthquakes, sink holes, drought, blizzards, faults, yes faults and more. Has anyone thought to check god's rating on Angie's List?
ReplyDeleteAnd, just how any tribes did god promise the same piece of land? The fight among the heirs of that mess still continues.
RJ in Brownbackistan
My thoughts go out to this lady. I too am an atheist and I know the backlash that can come. People (you know, the good Christian kind) will say that she shouldn't take church donations or any help from any religious organization to help her or her family.
ReplyDeleteThis is Oklahoma, and I'm from Oklahoma (just south of where the Finger of God punished good hearted people and drowned children in a basement) and I know that she will be respected by many but hated and shunned by many more. Bible belt for you.
blowback from the "good" people is inevitable
DeleteI laud her bravery. I believe, though, she is now in for a rough road. From this time forward she is going to be asked: "Are you REALLY an atheist?"
ReplyDeleteAnd once it is established that she is, I would bet AT LEAST 99% of her xtian friends remove her from their "call list". She will not be invited to their parties. She will not be invited to her neighbor's house. Her lovely child will not be allowed to play with the other neighborhood kids. You know, the TYPICAL hatred and fear reactions from those idiots!
She WILL, however, find out who her REAL friends are and probably become a member of one of the best groups of people I have EVER had the pleasure of knowing - other atheists and agnostics.
You GO girl!
Gryphen! Great news! You're redeemed!
ReplyDeletePope Francis Says Atheists Who Do Good Are Redeemed, Not Just Catholics
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/05/22/pope-francis-good-atheists_n_3320757.html
Hey, Wolfie. If someone doesn't respond the way you think they should the first time, why push the issue? Are you a reporter or a recruiter?
ReplyDeleteI loved this lady's reaction AND response. Atheists aren't "Anti God", they simply don't believe in one.
Someone should ask Blitzter if those who lost loved ones in the storm also should thank god.
ReplyDeleteBeck: ‘Forces of spiritual darkness’ at CNN plotted Blitzer’s atheist gaffe
ReplyDeletehttp://www.rawstory.com/rs/2013/05/23/beck-forces-of-spiritual-darkness-at-cnn-plotted-blitzers-atheist-gaffe/