Courtesy of HuffPo:
In 2011 the Army faced public scrutiny after the exposition of once mandatory "Spiritual Fitness" testing which assessed the resiliency of soldiers on such qualitative measures as frequency of prayer or attendance of religious services. When a soldier failed this religious test they were denigrated with the following:
"Spiritual fitness may be an area of difficulty... You may lack a sense of meaning and purpose in your life. At times, it is hard for you to make sense of what is happening to you and to others around you. You may not feel connected to something larger than yourself. You may question your beliefs, principles and values... Improving your spiritual fitness should be an important goal."
Of course, no military organization is content with a tongue lashing as a response to failing a mandatory test. For the test to have been worth anything, Army leadership determined remedial training in the form of training modules and even the requirement to visit with chaplains for religious counseling was appropriate.
Fortunately, after extensive efforts by the Military Religious Freedom Foundation (MRFF), the Military Association of Atheists and Freethinkers (MAAF), and concerned soldiers, the Army decided in February of 2011 that religious testing would cease to be formally mandatory and remedial training for failing such tests would be optional.
Sadly, this was not the end of religious tests being included in formal policy throughout our military. Several days ago it was brought to our attention at MRFF that the United States Marine Corps (USMC) maintains in its doctrine that a "Lack or loss of spiritual faith" is just cause to increase scrutiny of any given Marine. This clause is present in at least two USMC publications, including Marine Corps Base Quantico's Headquarters and Service Battalion Order 5100.29 and Training and Education Command Order 5100.1.
"Lack or loss of spiritual faith" is included as a "Guidance/moral compass issue" in both of these documents under a list of risk indicators for use by "leaders at all levels" to "identify and address risky behavior or events that may lead to risky behavior, as soon as possible." This apparent character flaw is juxtaposed with such things as "lack of courage," "history of psychiatric hospitalizations," "past or current substance abuse history," and being "anti-social." In the simplest terms, it is the current official position of the United States Marine Corps that those who do not profess a religious belief or choose to leave their religion are to be considered a potential hazard to themselves and the Corps and be placed under greater scrutiny than their peers.
The documents go on to include directives on how to convene a "Force Preservation Council" with the mission to evaluate and assist Marines that are identified as high risk through the checklist of undesirable traits (such as lack of religion).
I find it interesting that the military has little trouble opening their minds to the idea of openly gay soldiers within their ranks, and yet this prejudice remains so firmly entrenched that it must be dealt with as if it is a dangerous psychological malady.
I will provide this caveat however. It may well be that the military much prefers those who tend to take things on faith alone, and rarely question the information they are provided. As habitual church goers and Fundamentalists are conditioned to do.
After all if critical thinkers were in positions of importance during the Nazi regime, who would have sent all of those Jews to the gas chambers? (And yes Hitler was closely associated with the Catholic Church and took his inspiration for the genocide from church teachings.)
Maybe it is just me, but I like the idea of those making life and death decisions while representing America to be intellectual inquisitive individuals who carefully think through any command they are given before executing it.
But hey what do I know? After all according to the Marines I might just as well be suffering from psychiatric problems.
1) This is clearly unconstitutional. I hope the ACLU, the MAAF, and others will pursue this.
ReplyDelete2) The three Marines that I've known in my life were disciplined, determined, committed. Not one of them was religious in any way, but they did believe in fighting for their country, which they did, admirably. That's all the "faith in a higher power" they ever needed. They'd laugh heartily at their "condition" being labeled a psychiatric problem.
I agree with you - the Marines as well as Army soldiers I know are good soldiers, buT are NOT religious. Of course, they served their country a few years ago, not NOW. Wondering, if this is just a 'newer' requirement. :/
DeleteNo, 7:07, it isn't just NOW.
DeleteI was in boot camp in 1968 and refused to accept the dog tags they gave me because they did NOT list me as atheist as I stated in my paperwork. They said well, just wear them until we can get new ones stamped. (They had a machine right there and could have done it in 45 seconds!) I said (politely) No!
It took intervention by the base commander to force those idiots to create proper dog tags.
I was called into a chaplain's office and had a royal time from him. Chewed me up one side and down the other for probably 20 minutes. I refused to react (which is what he was looking for) and that really ticked him off. Had not another chaplain come along of higher rank and told me to leave, I probably would have finally told that original chaplain to fuck off, which would have been used in a courts martial.
No. This is NOT a new thing. It might not have been as common then, but it DID go on.
It almost seems as if our military has taken a manual page from Al Quaida and is using "Spiritual Fitness" and its accompanying "Guidance/moral compass issue" as a way to intimidate them into a more personally risky behavior by throwing personal caution to the wind and falling on that grenade. Al Quaida knows that a good Muslim soldier will fly planes into buildings or blow themselves up yelling Allahu Akbar! What will our soldiers yell in honor of their spiritual beliefs which have been enhanced by military brainwashing?
ReplyDeleteYou know, Gryphen, in a perfect world, I would agree that our soldiers and their leaders are all fully rational, thinking, individuals.
ReplyDeleteBut then, IMHO, we would HAVE no military.
Because, who in their right mind would want to go out and kill innocent men, women, and children? Who in their right, rational, mind would want to destroy other countries?
If we had all THINKING personnel in the military, we would have no more wars...
If you had people in the military, who actually CONSIDERED what kind of commands they are being given, we would have a mutiny, and the end of all war activity. Instead, we .might have conversations and conflict solutions, and we might have compromises and... PEACE!
Excuse me, but a question for you.
DeleteWhat color is the sky in your world?
"You may question your beliefs, principles and values..."
ReplyDeleteSomething wrong with that?
A friend of mine posted something on facebook this morning that surprised me. She is a member of a UU church and pretty open minded about most things. Her son became a Marine last year. She shared a picture of a large group of Marines bowing their heads in prayer. This is part of the text that went with the photo:
ReplyDelete"If you look closely at the picture above, you will note that all the Marines pictured are bowing their heads. That's because they're praying. This incident took place at a recent ceremony honoring the birthday of the corps, and it has the ACLU up in arms. "These are federal employees," says Lucius Traveler, a spokesman for the ACLU, "on federal property and on federal time. For them to pray is clearly an establishment of religion, and we must nip this in the bud immediately."
When asked about the ACLU's charges, Colonel Jack Fessender, speaking for the Commandant of the Corps said (cleaned up a bit), "Screw the ACLU."
GOD Bless Our Warriors. Send the ACLU to Afganistan!
Please send this to people you know so everyone will know how stupid the ACLU is getting in trying to remove GOD from everything and every place in America May God Bless America , One Nation Under GOD!
What's wrong with the picture? ABSOLUTELY NOTHING "
I wonder how many of the people who are sharing this post would be so supportive if the person leading the prayer was praying in Hebrew or Hindi or Arabic and EVERYONE in the audience was expected to bow their heads in prayer.
ReplyDeleteI had thought that we were becoming more accepted.....................apparently only in certain circles.
Signed,
A Ten Year Mostly Out of the Closet Atheist
Here's my take.....if you're dumb enough to believe this crap..you're our kinda guy.....
ReplyDelete