Courtesy of USA Today:
A National Security Agency employee resigned from the agency after admitting to federal investigators that he gave former NSA analyst Edward Snowden a digital key that allowed him to gain access to classified materials, the NSA has told Congress. Snowden has previously said he did not steal any passwords.
The unnamed civilian employee who worked with Snowden resigned last month after the government revoked his security clearance, according to a letter that NSA legislative director Ethan L. Bauman sent this week to the House Judiciary Committee. A military employee and a private contractor also lost their access to NSA data as part of the continuing investigation by the FBI, Bauman said.
Bauman's memo, dated Feb. 10, provides some of the first details about what authorities said they have learned about how Snowden retrieved so many classified documents before passing them to news organizations. Top U.S. national security officials have acknowledged they do not know many files Snowden took before he fled the U.S.
Snowden has denied that he stole computer passwords or tricked some co-workers into giving him their passwords. The NSA letter suggested Snowden tricked at least one co-worker and copied the employee's password without his knowledge.
The civilian NSA worker told FBI investigators last June that he allowed Snowden to use an encrypted digital key known as a Public Key Infrastructure certificate to gain access to classified information on NSANet, the agency's computer network. The system connects into many of the NSA's classified databanks. The memo said that previously Snowden had been denied access to the network.
After the co-worker entered his secure PKI password, Snowden "was able to capture the password, allowing him even greater access to classified information," Bauman told lawmakers. He said the civilian NSA employee was not aware that Snowden intended to reveal any classified information. It was not clear from the memo how much classified information Snowden had collected before using the co-worker's password.
Last month, Snowden participated in a public question-and-answer session on the "Free Snowden" website. "I never stole any passwords, nor did I trick an army of co-workers," he asserted.
I know that many Americans are split when it comes to Edward Snowden, but if he is willing to lie about this it kind of makes one wonder what else he is lying about.
Currently Snowden has received eight nominations for the Nobel Peace Prize.
However I would contend that, even though the information about NSA spying tactics was beneficial, there is still a lot we do not know about Snowden's activities at the NSA.
I appreciate your perspective on this, but I do not see that how the article contradicts Snowden. If the employee 'gave' him the key, isn't that consistent with Snowden saying he did not steal a any passwords or 'trick' anyone into giving them?
ReplyDeleteHe tricked them into giving him their password for a reason other than his intended one.
DeleteDid you read the post? the asshole tricked people.
Deleteanytime that you procure another person's security clearance under false pretenses, that is fraudulent and deceitful as it is. but he then utilized a software of some kind, which took a "snapshot" of his co-worker's security clearance data, for the express purpose of using it at a later time - without the co-worker's knowledge or permission - to steal these millions of highly classified government documents.
Deleteso, if he indeed required another co-worker's clearance information in order to access these files, then clearly, snowden DID NOT have the ability to "sit at his desk and wiretap the president", as he claimed. he personally did not have access to any of these capabilities - which makes him a LIAR. he resorted to the use of lies, deceit, betrayal and manipulation in order to obtain these passwords and access codes, and furthermore, the fact that he took all of these documents without anyone's permission and while using someone else's security clearance makes him a THIEF.
so, to all the people who are praising this slime as their holy sacred messiah and rage on about how he's being persecuted and how he's this "victim" and whatnot - where is your compassion for the NSA employees who lost their jobs, their pensions and their livelihoods, AND had their characters, their names and their good standing in their communities brought into shame and disrepute, all on the count of LYING, STEALING SNOWDEN!? they are the truly innocent parties here, and yet they are merely considered as collateral damage for snowden's righteous cause, so to hell with the families they need to support or the decades they've spent trying to make a real difference in their communities and in the world.
edward snowden is a liar, a thief and a traitor - and it seems that people are finally starting to get it now.
This man is a traitor, pure and simple!
ReplyDeleteHe stole classified information and beelines to Russia. I don't by for a minute that he was globetrotting to find a "shelter" from our country. I think in reality he was groomed by the Russian government. I hope once they are done with him, they give him jail time in a truly nasty jail.
He went to China first to give them the goods, too. I'm surprised he didn't go to North Korea as well.
DeleteTraitor plain and simple. If he wanted to fight for Americans' right to privacy then he would have stayed right here in the good ol' USA. He would have faced the consequences head on like a true martyr who believed in his cause. Instead he goes to our ENEMIES and gives them classified information??? Yea, that's not how I would define a hero for the rights of US citizens.
DeleteHere's the original text from the NSA memorandum:
Delete> On 18 June 2013, the NSA civilian admitted to FBI Special Agents that he allowed Mr. Snowden to use his (the NSA civilian's) Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) certificate to access classified information on access that he knew had been denied to Mr. Snowden. Further, at Mr. Snowden's request, the civilian entered his PKI password at Mr. Snowden's computer terminal. Unbeknownst to the civilian, Mr. Snowden was able to capture the password, allowing him even greater access to classified information. The civilian was not aware that Mr. Snowden intended to unlawfully disclose classified information. However, by sharing his PKI certificate, he failed to comply with security obligations.
The first part:
> … he allowed Mr. Snowden to use his (the NSA civilian's) Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) certificate to access classified information on access that he knew had been denied to Mr. Snowden …
says the civilian knew Snowden had been denied access, but allowed Snowden to use his key to access the system. From that it's clear that the civilian willingly, of his own accord, without being 'tricked', gave Snowden access to the system.
… at Mr. Snowden's request, the civilian entered his PKI password at Mr. Snowden's computer terminal.
This second act by the civilian was done on the same basis -- willingly, without being tricked.
The civilian breached security protocol on his own accord, without being tricked. What happened after that is irrelevant to the above.
Love that the NSA has been dragged into the light. But when the Patriot Act was enacted I knew this all was going to be bullshit. But Snowden . . .
ReplyDeleteHe is hand in hand with some pretty odious people and I think he went into the NSA to steal. That is not whistle-blowing. And why not stay and defend your actions? He is too aligned with effing Greenwald who considers Snowden his cash cow. I never trusted motivations--because of Greenwald. But I do think Snowden got fucked by his enablers—Assange because he was bored in the Ecuadorian Embassy in London and Greenwald who saw this as making himself rich and famous.
And as far as a peace prize---uuummmm, not so much.
There are actually people saving and impacting real lives and not aligned with people trying to make fortunes off their "peaceful" acts. Metadata vs someone stopping genocides?
Give me a break.
No telling how many people died or are going to die because of his self-centered "my-encryption-is-foolproof," "I'm-the-best-coder-in-the-world" bullshit. he is jeopardizing many lives giving out our secrets as he sees fit.
Deletegreenwald is the little weasel hanging on to anything or anybody that will get him some type of high award.
So right snowden is a coward and a traitor. he's a punk
How do we even know that what this "employee" says is true. I know I don't trust the NSA or the FBI or the CIA, etc. My dad had a "top secret" clearance in the USAF and the one thing he told me to remember was, "don't trust anyone, even if they show you a badge".
ReplyDeleteOMFG people really believe this snake is a fucking hero. GMAFB! I mean really. Here's a sneaky snaky lying thief who controls what the US should and should not release, what secret and what isn't secret. Who made him Commander-In-Chief? he's like a walking, talking departments of the United States.
ReplyDeletePlease God two minutes with this arrogant nutwad.
These defenders of free speech just allowed a fucked up psycho snowden make decisions for the US. They just joined the gop assdips.
I was on some pro snowden site blah, blah and these idiots had the nerve to say that snowden isn't blackmailing the US. Come on now.
These clowns are like the trolls we have on here ignorant, anonymous and full of shit.
Blackmail requires a payoff. I don't recall Snowden demanding anything.
Delete12:12 Not money but his freedom in the States.
DeleteYes, this is all far more complex than some would have us believe.
ReplyDeleteAlso, too, how else could the feds gather evidence about the Palins, the Trust Scandal, Pimp-daddy and so forth???
I think that Snowden is a traitor. As part of the generation that does not believe that intellectual property does belong to its creators, perhaps he simply does not understand that national security involves keeping secrets. He had to sign confidentiality agreements when he was hired but then he chose, because he didn't like President Obama and wanted to embarrass him and his Administration, to ignore the agreement. With money from who know ???, he went out to peddle his information (or misinformation) to the highest bidder and ended up in Putin's Russia. Oh my. As far as I'm concerned he can stay there. But when the bureaucrats in Putin's Russia begin to worry that he may be trolling their secrets, he'll have some additional problems. Maybe his buddy Greenwald will help him then too.
ReplyDeleteBeaglemom
Would have child sexual abuse covered up? Would you keep those secrets?
DeleteThere are secrets and there are secrets. Spying against innocent small countries for the purpose of financially exploiting them is hardly a secret worth keeping- Snowden is revealing a whole bunch of criminal activity by the US Government. Too bad for you that you think this is fine and dandy as long as the US is committing the crimes and not some other country.
I have no regard for Snowden and think he should be found (I'm sure our government knows exactly where he is!), brought back to America, put on trial, found guilty and executed!
ReplyDeleteA Nobel Prize award? Give me a friggin' break!
You folks are very simpleminded sometimes, just the way the machine likes it. Simpleminded and fearful.
ReplyDeleteOh please enlighten us on how not to be fearful, random internet smart person who warns us to fear the machine.
DeleteEvidently people believe everything the NSA spinmeisters say. They don't have any reason to lie, do they? Having worked for the government for 30 years and have at least a secret security clearance all that time I believe Snowdon. So far everything he has said has been verified. Hayden not so much. The end result of the revelations will be economic and when the corporations that control our politicians get hurt change will happen. Not until then thanks to the stupidity of gutting the 4th amendment.
ReplyDeleteSnowden committed treason! He should have to answer to his evil deeds in America. If he's never brought back, or returns on his own, he is NOT going to have a pleasant life wherever he goes.
ReplyDeleteHe'll ALWAYS be insecure and afraid for his life!
Whenever you read any reporting on Snowden by any US media, you have to examine first who is doing the reporting and whose is the agenda of the news source? You know you don't believe anything on FOX and you know why; that's because FOX is so overt. All other media have their agenda, too. Maybe you don't recognize it because it fits your own agenda, or maybe you don't see it because it's generally cleverly hidden.
ReplyDeleteIf this had happened under the Bush administration, all you folks claiming traitor and treason on Snowden would instead be labelling him a hero. It is so obvious.
ReplyDeleteBullshit. The act was virtuous . . . the person--that is still a question. Everything Snowden did afterwards sucked. And it opened him up to claims he was working with a foreign country or he was working with a man who has used him to get rich and write books. Why is Snowden not here? Why is he in a country that makes no qualms about acts that Snowden seemed appalled that the US perpetuated? Why is Snowden aligned with the biggest media whore on the planet---Greenwald?
DeleteSnowden is a limited hangout. He is not for real. Believe what you want, but it is difficult to trust the mainstream media on things like this. The NSA puts out whatever information it feels it needs to put out for ulterior purposes.
ReplyDeleteRead the stuff below. Wake up.
Journalist Margie Burns asked some good questions back in June that have not yet been answered. She wondered about the 29-year old Snowden who had been a U.S. Army Special Forces recruit, a covert CIA operative, and an NSA employee in various capacities, all in just a few, short years. Burns asked “How, exactly, did Snowden get his series of NSA jobs? Did he apply through regular channels? Was it through someone he knew? Who recommended him? Who were his references for a string of six-figure, high-level security jobs? Are there any safeguards in place so that red flags go up when a subcontractor jumps from job to job, especially in high-level clearance positions?”
http://digwithin.net/2014/01/01/snowden/
http://www.economicpolicyjournal.com/2013/06/are-data-collection-leaks-just-set-up.html
http://potentnews.com/2013/08/09/how-to-identify-cia-limited-hangout-op/
I imagine all the above posters who believe Snowden is a traitor and should be executed also believe Daniel Ellsberg should be executed for the Pentagon Papers. Right?
ReplyDeleteWhat I want to know is how much information he gave or was willing to give to gain asylum? Why did he feel the need to leave the USA if, indeed, he did nothing wrong? He's a liar and traitor, why should anyone believe him? What other lies has he told and why?
ReplyDeleteHe's neither a liar nor a traitor. He is an agent of the NSA, putting forth a fabricated story. A Limited Hangout. Read Webster Tarpley. Limited Hangout operations have been going on for decades. It's part of the "Great Game" of global espionage between nations and their peoples. Do you really think the NSA would have allowed this to happen if it didn't want it to happen? Wake up.
Delete