Wednesday, September 03, 2014

Despite what the Republicans say, bigger government actually increases happiness and life satisfaction. Is that Ronald Reagan I hear spinning in his grave?

Courtesy of Tamu Times:  

Pundits who throw around the words “big government” usually point out the negatives of having too much government involvement in the economy, but a Texas A&M University researcher co-wrote a study that found government intervention – when done correctly – leads to more happiness and satisfaction in the lives of citizens. 

In their study “Assessing the Impact of the Size and Scope of Government on Human Well-Being,” professors of political science Alexander Pacek at Texas A&M, Patrick Flavin of Baylor University and Benjamin Radcliff, University of Notre Dame, studied 21 developed nations – free market, capitalist democracies including the U.S. – from 1981-2007, examining data from nearly 50,000 respondents collected by the World Values Survey. 

The researchers report that citizens of these countries find life more satisfying as the degree of government intervention in the economy increases. And the findings don’t change based on income, meaning that high- and low-income citizens find more “leftist” socioeconomic policies equally conducive to a more satisfying life. 

“We frame an argument that for all the blessings of free market capitalism and democracy, there are negative side effects such as market downturns, inequality and poverty, and these can create insecurities in citizens,” explains Pacek, an expert in how political determinants affect life satisfaction and happiness. “Our argument suggests that government intervention, done correctly, can improve life satisfaction by smoothing out these kinds of negative effects and consequences.”

Oh man is this going to make those on the Right lose their shit. 

However if you think about it, this is clearly accurate. And that is why today there are few Americans, despite their political affiliations, who would seriously suggest doing away with Medicare, Social Security, the FDA, the FAA, or any number of government agencies and programs that keep us safe or provide services that almost all of us will need eventually.

And that does not even include the military, possibly the biggest waste of tax dollars, which has now become as much a part of the image of America as the bald eagle and apple pie.

8 comments:

  1. Jim In Texas12:21 PM

    "there are few Americans, despite their political affiliations, who would seriously suggest doing away with Medicare, Social Security, the FDA, the FAA, or any number of government agencies and programs that keep us safe or provide services that almost all of us will need eventually."

    Except for the Koch's and their hired guns (i.e., the Republican Party)!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Randall1:07 PM

    When Republicans channel Ronald Reagan and say "Government is the problem"
    I wish people would remind them that the United States of America is a government of We The People.

    And We The People govern ourselves just fine, thank you - except for when Republicans get into office.
    THEN and only then, do things get fucked up
    because people who don't believe in government tend to turn out to be really shitty at governing.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anonymous1:22 PM

    Obviously the GOP lies when they blather on about smaller government or sinking it completely. On our primary ballot just a few weeks ago, there were five to eight Republicans fighting for spots in both houses of the state legislature! They sure want to collect the money and the benefits. Less willing to take on the serious tasks.
    Beaglemom

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous4:27 PM

    I know of zero business owners who appreciate govt in their business aside from tax collection. And I and most of my friends have owned businesses since out mid 20s.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Let's see: short cons, long cons, prostitution, pimping, misuse of public funds, tax evasion . . .

      Yeah if I were in those businesses I'd probably be afraid of "government" too!

      Delete
    2. Anonymous6:28 PM

      Same here, I hate being an agent of big government, having to collect THEIR sales tax while visa, master card and discover CHARGE me for allowing people to use their credit cards when buying my hand crocheted, made in America, Doll Toilet Paper covers on ETSY. Do your're own dang job, government!

      Delete
    3. Anonymous11:32 AM

      So how is government responsible for credit card use fees? And if not at point of sale, how do you propose to collect sales taxes ?

      Delete
  5. Anita Winecooler6:34 PM

    So very true. Add the rant about "I ain't got no kids in school anymore, why am I still paying school taxes"? I don't think Saint Ronald Regan has stopped spinning in his grave for years now. McCain is cruising for a bruising with his "Arm them all" and "Boots on the Ground" battlecalls. Something tells me Ronald and Seniletor McCain have something in common.

    ReplyDelete

Don't feed the trolls!
It just goes directly to their thighs.