Monday, June 01, 2015

For today at least the government has far fewer tools at its disposal for spying on US citizens.

Courtesy of the Daily Dot:

Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.) used the Senate's arcane rules to force government spying powers to expire for the first time since Sept. 11, 2001, blocking a bill to reform and extend those powers in a tense Sunday session. 

The failure of the USA Freedom Act leaves Congress with no options for averting the midnight expiration of the USA Patriot Act's controversial Section 215 and two other surveillance provisions. The reform bill, which the House passed before leaving town for a week-long recess, would end the government's bulk collection of Americans' phone records under Section 215 while leaving the other two provisions intact. 

At first, things seemed to be moving smoothly. The Senate voted overwhelmingly (77-17) to proceed to final passage of the USA Freedom Act, invoking a step known as cloture, after Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) acknowledged that the bill was "now the only realistic way forward." 

But cloture motions must "sit" for 30 hours unless no senator objects to moving forward to a full vote on the bill at hand, and Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.) indicated that he would object. Because of his procedural move, the Senate cannot vote on final passage of the bill until 2am ET Tuesday, at the earliest.

Now before you break out that champagne you should know that it is virtually a given that the USA Freedom Act (Ironic name don't you think?) will easily pass on Tuesday. And when it does it will reinstate the roving wiretap provision which allowed them to wiretap new devices used by a suspect without having to get a new court order for each one, and to track "lone wolf" suspects with no known affiliation with a terror network.

However what will NOT be back is the government's bulk collection of our phone records, and that is no small victory.

And of course Rand Paul awaits your adoration: 

"This is a victory no matter how you look at it," Paul said in a statement. "It might be short lived, but I hope that it provides a road for a robust debate, which will strengthen our intelligence community, while also respecting our Constitution." 

"The expiration of the NSA's sweeping, all-encompassing and ineffectual powers will not relinquish functions necessary for protecting national security," Paul said. "The expiration will instead do what we should have done all along—rely on the Constitution for these powers."

Now I am going to give Paul his due here, if he had not been such a vocal opponent of the Patriot Act we may not have seen the bulk data portion taken out in this new version.

However it should also be noted that once it was removed the act of holding up the passage of the  USA Freedom Act really accomplished very little except to give Senator Paul a little more time in the limelight.

Paul has also politically positioned himself in a place where there are few others that can compete with him. I don't really think that will help him to win the Republican nomination, but it might help him in the years to come.

Time will tell.

13 comments:

  1. Anonymous9:25 AM

    Randy is a smarmy little pissant. No credit is due at all. He is flailing about trying to get some attention for his doomed run for president and is shooting himself in the foot every which way. Listen to him weasel out of accusing people of wishing for a terrorist attack just so they can make HIM suffer the responsibility. HIM? Really? He thinks he is so important? And then when he gets nailed for his grandstanding, he puts his tail between his legs and whines about how he just got a little 'carried away'. I give him no credit, not now, not ever. He's an embarrassment that is cringeworthy.

    http://talkingpointsmemo.com/livewire/rand-paul-quote-secretly-wants-attack

    http://www.politicususa.com/2015/05/31/mitch-mcconnell-humiliated-rand-paul-loses-senate-votes-advance-usa-freedom-act.html

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous10:20 AM

      The White House Reminds Everyone That Obama Crafted A Reformed Patriot Act Over A Year Ago

      http://www.politicususa.com/2015/05/31/white-house-reminds-obama-crafted-reformed-usa-freedom-act-year.html

      Delete
  2. Anonymous10:18 AM

    Eat crow, Mitch McConnell. You earned it.

    http://www.politicususa.com/2015/06/01/obama-laughing-mcconnell-failure.html

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anonymous11:08 AM

    In ten years we will get The Apple Pie Act.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous11:11 AM

    Daily Dot Politics was live tweeting the whole debate last night. Apparently Rand also used his "speech" in a political ad, which is against the rules. I think that is the only reason he has been such an ass on many of these issues.

    ReplyDelete
  5. FrostyAK11:52 AM

    Randy now hopes to jump into the front seat in the clown car. IF he was instrumental in getting the bulk data collection expired, then good on him. Libertarians have a good idea once in a while.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Dwight D12:05 PM

    Please ! Don't be so foolish as to believe that this " Campaign Stunt " stopped or even slowed down the collection one iota, It has been going on since the 1950's and isn't about to stop.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "The alphabet soup will never stop collecting bulk data and profiling, it's their job. Moreover, it will never go away. It's just too cheap and easy" - GOODSTUFF

      "I'm more scared of little brother than big bother" - GOODSTUFF

      "I am in shock that there has been a small victory, but I firmly believe Big Brother in Washington will find ways to keep the spy program going. For example, our allies the British or Japanese will use the Internet to spy on Americans, collect massive info and then "share" that data with the NSA." - The Federalist

      Delete
  7. Anonymous5:21 PM

    Rand Paul is the Republicans’ perpetual teenager-in-rebellion. The brawl between Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) and the junior Senator from Kentucky continued on the Senate floor Monday with McConnell desperately blocking amendments from Paul and Paul finding petulant ways to get back at McConnell by blocking the Senate from speeding up the vote.

    But somehow, teeny bits of reality penetrated the Galtian smog surrounding Paul so that he must have realized that everyone from his own party hated him. This would not do, for all of his talk about liberty, the teenager needs his parents. So he sort of walked back his latest accusation, attributing it to “hyperbole”. Because yes, hyperbole and hysteria and not watching your words and launching rhetorical grenades at people just because you disagree with them is totally leadership material. Or it is exactly how a teenager behaves when a parent explains that the garbage must be taken out or else it accumulates.

    From the Hill:

    http://www.politicususa.com/2015/06/01/republicans-happy-rand-paul-treating-treat-president-obama.html

    ReplyDelete
  8. Anita Winecooler5:30 PM

    Rand is, once again, taking credit for doing nothing. It's a campaigning ploy, no more, no less.
    OT Has anyone seen or heard Ann Coulter in the media lately? seems to have dropped off the edge of the earth. Just curious.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous6:12 PM

      Anita, she's been promoting her new anti immigration book:

      ...Coulter, who is currently out publicizing her new anti-immigration book, the subtly titled Adios, America: The Left’s Plan to Turn Our Country into a Third World Hellhole, got straight to the point.

      “Of course, this is a result of immigration,” she explained. “Liberals haven’t changed anyone’s mind. They couldn’t win elections with Americans, so they brought in ringers.”

      Plugging her book, Coulter offered up a solution to stop the conservative slide, “It’s in my book, the answer is obvious: Stop all immigration now. Take 10 or 20 years to assimilate the immigrants already here. Deport lawbreakers.”

      http://www.rawstory.com/2015/06/michele-bachmann-is-upset-we-cant-indoctrinate-immigrants-into-americas-predominant-christian-religion/

      Delete
    2. Anita Winecooler4:34 PM

      Thanks for the info. I'm sure it'll be a NYT bestseller under "fiction", but the followers of Breitbart, Fox, Druge and others will put it on their shelf to feel validated.

      Delete
  9. physicsmom8:22 PM

    I'm glad that these revisions to the UPA have been passed. They killed the bulk collection of all Americans' data, but made a couple of exceptions. I think the "roving wiretap" makes sense.If you have the proper evidence to tap Individual A, and he starts using burner phones. It makes no sense to enjoin the Feds to seek a new court order for each new phone the subject uses.

    I'm less certain about the investigation of suspected "lone wolf" actors. If the Bureau has sufficient evidence to obtain a wiretap on Individual B, then It's in our best interest to keep an eye on him. I think we all agree that domestic terrorism is more likely than foreign terrorists breaching our border again. I'm willing to be persuaded on this point, however.

    ReplyDelete

Don't feed the trolls!
It just goes directly to their thighs.