Palin (l. in Sept; r. Monday) and her body could be changing due to increased muscle or increased eating - or both. (D'Amico, Larkey/ABC) |
Bristol Palin has surprised judges and viewers alike with her improvement on "Dancing with the Stars," but the single mom has also sparked one particular question.
How the heck is she not losing weight on this show?
Ah ha! Now finally reporters are going to ask the obvious questions and will undoubtedly reach to the obvious conclusions. Or am I expecting too much?
The ABC reality competition requires contestants to dance for hours on an almost daily basis if they want to last as long as Palin has. "DWTS" alum Kelly Osbourne credits her stint on the show as a catalyst for her 50-pound weight loss. And as fellow competitor Kyle Massey has demonstrated, the intense exercise can cause pounds to seemingly melt away.
But not always.
Last month, Palin herself acknowledged that she hadn't shed any weight while on the show.
"I haven't really noticed a change in [my body]," she told "Access Hollywood." "I think most people lose weight [on the show] because they're too stressed out to eat. I haven't had that problem!"
"Anyone who participates in any type of vigorous, regular physical activity could potentially gain weight," says Elisa Zied, a registered dietician and author of "Nutrition at Your Fingertips."
"Even if you're doing vigorous activity like dancing, pressures could lead you to over-consume calories if you're seeking comfort in food," Zied says, "and this is a girl who is definitely under the microscope in many ways."
WTF? Has this guy SEEN a picture of Bristol's weight gain? In order for Bristol to gain THAT much extra weight, she would literally have to be eating thousands of calories more than her increased metabolic rate from all this exercise was capable of burning. It is not just that Bristol is NOT losing weight, it is that she is GAINING weight!
I have spent years as a personal trainer so let me see if I can break this down so it is easy to understand.
When you exercise you increase your body's need for fuel to burn for energy, and nutrients to build stronger muscles to handle the increased stress. Your body will seek that nutrition by processing the foods you eat, which will leave less available for your body to store as fat. If that is not sufficient it will feed off the fat reserves and muscle tissue in your body to find the nutrients it needs to give your body the fuel required to keep up with the increased demand.
However if you are constantly working out and using your muscles THEY are going to demand nutrients to help them grow and to deal with increased workload as well. Which means unless you have dramatically bumped up your caloric intake, your body would be forced to burn the fat reserves to satisfy that need.
That is how people lose body fat through exercise.
It is not uncommon for people to exercise very hard and STILL remain the same weight, or in some cases even gain weight. And there is nothing wrong with that.
When you engage in resistance type exercise your muscles will increase in their size, which means when you step on the scale it might seem that you have not lost any fat, but in fact you have.
I have literally had female clients come up to me crying because they have gained a pound or two and want to just quit the gym and go home to eat a cheesecake. So what I do is measure their hips, waist, legs, arms, and chest. Invariably they will see a dramatic change in those areas DESPITE not losing any weight according to the scale. And that is because muscle is LEAN, and therefore has much less volume than does fat.
However THOSE results usually come from doing anaerobic exercise, such as weight training, rather than from aerobic exercise, like running or dancing.. Bristol's dance training is almost exclusively aerobic, and not anaerobic, which means her increase in muscle density should NOT offset her loss of fat.
However having said all of that IT DOES NOT MAKE ANY DIFFERENCE! Bristol is NOT simply maintaining, or gaining, weight. She is gaining SIZE.
There is absolutely no way that she could be sitting in her room and stuffing enough calories in her body to account for the dramatic increase in the size of her waist. No way!
Either the girl is pregnant, which is the theory I am currently subscribing to, or she has something terribly wrong with her metabolism which is causing a seemingly unnatural weight gain. In other words rather than being on television the young woman should, either be visiting her obstetrician on a regular basis, or under the care of a specialist to determine what has gone haywire with her body.
But instead, for reasons that I simply cannot fathom, she is out in the public arena ballooning up in size, while Palin-bots and public relations people try desperately to divert our attention away from noticing, or commenting, on what is right there is front of our faces.
Update: I still cannot get an embed but Gawker has both her horrible cage dance and the judges overly complimentary comments afterward.
And she is bigger than ever tonight.
ReplyDeleteOMG LOL! I flipped over to DWTS Plus a No Talent just when Bristol the Pistol was saying something about HATERS! This girl is on the wrong show. She should be on The Bad Girls Club. She'd fit right in with that foul mouth. Where were her heels? Flat shoes? And a 27 score? I resisted saying it but now I agree. A cow being pushed around the floor! This show is pathetic.
ReplyDeleteOhiovoter
It could be a simple, "she's been poked."
ReplyDeleteOf course, another Palin supporter trying to disguise the truth with BS "logic".
ReplyDeleteWhy would any "journalist" bother to even address this issue?
Due to increased muscle?? No muscle in those chipmunk cheeks, kiddo.
ReplyDeleteI had a thyroid problem that caused me to gain 30 pounds. Problem fixed and now have a problem losing the weight, because my metabolism is more efficient now.
ReplyDeleteI gained the weight over a couple of years. It is slowly coming off.
But I'm not as big as Bristol, and I'm not 20 (I'm 57).
Could be thyroid, but I'm a doubter.
There goes Mark's lucrative hopes of producing a weight loss exercise video after they are voted off, or even better, win the mirrored ball that competes with the size of her midsection.
ReplyDeleteAt this point I would start encouraging everyone to vote for her just to see how much weight she will gain with all this exercise. Lets try to keep her going another 3 or 4 months. Maybe she will drop the kid on national tv. It could spawn a whole new genre of reality shows.
ReplyDeleteClassic deconstruction of a LSM spun story to offset obvious questions Gryphen. Don't let em go, in this case, your expertise is unquestionable as opposed to Sarah's expertise in journalism, communications and poli-sci.
ReplyDeleteLOL, next thing they'll be saying swamp gas fumes or weather balloons were responsible for Gristle's weighted appearance.
Welcome to "reality", circa 2010, America. Good times (if you're into stupidity).
ReplyDeleteFrom my past dancing work, I just don't buy their explanations. I have no idea if she is pregnant or not, but even if you get more muscle from dance, it's long, lean muscle. It doesn't make you look stocky, like she does. And I could never, ever eat enough food to gain weight - not when we were doing a lot of shows and heavy rehearsal. I mean I ate like a pig because I was always hungry, but I never gained. Maybe some people do, but for me and other dancers I've worked with, that just didn't happen.
ReplyDeleteSee the picture - need I say more?
ReplyDeletehttp://www.tmz.com/2010/11/21/bristol-palin-dancing-with-the-stars-white-talcum-powder-evacuated-studio/
Is the September photo from a magazine? It's shocking to see such a differance, and I am wondering if they photoshopped her within an inch of her life. Think about what they do with fashion models. In any event, she is starting to look like a middle aged woman. How can she be bigger tonight? What the...? It's crazy.
ReplyDeleteI've had enough. See, this liberal family owns four computers (2 laptops, two desktops, 3 cell phones, two home lines, and we have 11 email addresses in our family...I have 5 of my own 2 for work, and three personal.
ReplyDeleteI texted, called, and used all our email address to vote for Kyle and Jennifer.
BTW, Butterball did a cage dance for her freestyle. She looked like a stripper on the 2 pm shift if you know what I mean.
She looked VERY pregnant in that first dance tonight. VERY pregnant.
ReplyDeleteNo high heels...WTF...how can she be in a professional dance show in flats
ReplyDeleteThanks for educating everyone. When people start working out, they should avoid the scale and use the tape. Muscle is heavier than fat. You really present a valid case for bringing the doctors in. To add that much bulk while doing strenuous aerobic exercise daily requires a tremendous amount of carbs. If what Bristol says is true, she's in the process of becoming a diabetic.
ReplyDeleteThe girl enjoys eating. Simple as that.
ReplyDeleteI typically just lurk but after watching DWTS, I can honestly say, that Bristol Palin is the most petulant whiner I’ve ever heard. “Haters,” “haters,” “haters,” her vocabulary is as limited as her mother’s.
ReplyDeleteyeh!..her fat back and underarms, yeh, thats all muscle! ri-ight!
ReplyDeleteHer chin(S)...big muscle there!
OMG, this dress she wears 2nite?...she looks SO STUFFED IN. Another one that covers her torso..she looks HUGE.
Please check on Mercede's site. I can't get on it, and I am suspicious that there is something afoot!
ReplyDeletehttp://www.mercedejohnston.com/
If Bristol is not pregnant and is not overeating, she needs to see a physician. How she treats her body now will determine how it will treat her later.
ReplyDeleteYou'd think that would be Sarah's number one priority. Todd needs to step in as ask Bristol what's going on and insist she see a doctor.
A good mother or father would notice and take action, counseling their child, regardless of how young or old that child is.
my god here waist is enormo.
ReplyDeleteoh there will be plenty of good shots from this one.
ReplyDeleteIf she loses, will the Palins cry foul? If she loses, will she graciously congratulate the winners and then withdraw without further comment?
ReplyDeleteMuch will depend upon how she responds to winning or losing. One's character is always on display at times such as this.
Does she really have it in her to be lady at the moment of decision? More importantly, will she behave like one in the days and weeks afterwards? By "lady," I mean civilized, courteous and gracious.
As the daughter acts, so, too, will we know her parents.
The deal is she has toned up her legs, but the rest of her has gotten bigger. In fact I would say she has both toned and slimmed down in the legs which does make her weight gain else where more obvious.
ReplyDeleteI really didn't want to believe she might be pregnant. I've resisted that idea all along. But the last couple weeks it is hard to believe she is just an emotional eater.
The weight gain and the little chair dance she did makes me wonder if she was afraid Ballas would drop her so they used the chair to prevent her getting dropped. A pregnant person would be worried about that where as anyone else would take the chance and allow the dance to be what it should have been.
Bristol is the William Hung of Dancing with the Stars.
ReplyDeleteWhat was that movie?
ReplyDeleteFat girl walking?
BRISTOL SUCKS!
Hey, Gryphen, it's easy to figure out---Bristol is going to be the next celebrity on Jenny Craig.
ReplyDeleteHowever, the real question is... how many times has she been pregnant?
ReplyDeleteIn 2007, with a child that she had to give up (possibly the original FAS Trig).
In 2008, with Tripp.
Earlier this year, likely Barber's child... almost certainly aborted, that she still mourns.
Now with another child, that she intends to keep.
With each pregnancy, birth is usually quicker. If Bristol goes on tour (as the winner, she will be obligated to tour), the odds increase that the live audience will get to witness a live birth... much like people at an auto race vie for places next to the track. How exciting!
What a whiner! Just like her mom.
ReplyDeleteYou can still see Mercede's cache
ReplyDeletehttp://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache%3Ahttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.mercedejohnston.com%2F2010%2F11%2F22%2Fits-monday-and-time-to-answer-more-of-your-questions%2F&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&aq=t&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a
It was actually the SECOND dance where she looked very pregnant. Looks like she lost a few pounds in her hips and thighs but her stomach was still huge which made her look very pregnant. We'll know pretty soon.
ReplyDeleteWhy is she wearing an engagement ring tonight? Soon, it will be announced that she was to be married all along. Have we not already seen this script before?
ReplyDeleteBristol looks so OLD in that second photo. Hard living will do that to you.
ReplyDeleteThe Palin's would have jumped on a legitimate medical condition to explain the dramatic weight gain and exploited it.
ReplyDeleteBristol didn't think she would last this long on DWTS. She had no idea how quickly the weight comes on during your second pregnancy. or your third, hmmmmmm?
If Bristol wins, she will try to pretend she deserved it. If she loses, she will be relieved, and give a bitchy "SEE, WE DIDN"T CHEAT, HATERS!"
ReplyDeleteA lose, lose for trashy Palins.
Voted fine the last few weeks, but tonight could not even get into my facebook account. Lost the phone vote due to busy signal.
ReplyDeleteEven dancing twice a week in a college class causes freshmen to shed pounds. Ms. Abstinence and Revirgined is full of BS.
ReplyDeleteHas there been one 'interview' with this meat-head where she did not bitch and whine and express her persecution complex?
ReplyDeleteWow.
What an ungracious little shit.
All along I thought she was pregnant, but she looked really trim tonight. Can Spanx hold a baby in that tight and is it safe???
ReplyDeleteBeing a "hater" I must add that Sarah has no clue how to dress. She looks like a country gal tonight.
Oh and is anyone who disagrees with Sarah, a " hater?" How Presidential is that?? And would she continue to be a bitch and make fun of liberals or anyone who thinks differently. Great for her base but not for a leader.
I'm going to throw some possible theorys into the mix. As a woman who was a bodybuilder when I was young I know what happens to the female body when muscle tissue is built. I weighed about five to eight pounds more than the charts said I should due to being a mesomorph. I always looked like I weighed twenty pounds less than I did, I fooled all the weight guessers at fairs. Muscle weighs more than fat, but takes up a lot less volume, I gained weight while getting smaller. She is not a bodybuilder, she is doing mostly aerobic-type activity. She should be dumping weight and getting long and lean (like Kelly Osborn did). She apparently eats crap which is contributing to the problem, McDonalds is poison. The secretion of stress hormones could also contribute to some weight gain, but not as fast as has happened with her. Alcohol could contribute to the puffy face and weight gain. She could have some kind of inflammatory medical problem (rheumatoid arthritis, lupus, etc.)and be on prednisone or some other steroid (not the bodybuilding type)which would not only make her hungry(24 hrs a day), but cause water retention type weight gain (Catabolic steroids cause large amounts of adipose tissue to be deposited in the gut area), so she would look pregnant. She could also be on some kind of psychotropic medication that causes weight gain(which could be for pain or a psych problem), this is a common problem, especially with women. Bristol is not a mesomorph, her face, gut and neck areas indicate adipose tissue, not muscle tissue. Her legs do look fabulous without a lot of adipose tissue which BTW is one of the side effects of catabolic steroids. A person with a painful inflammatory condition would go on higher dose steroids to get through the process of this show. If she is taking them she should get off them ASAP or her bones will become brittle and she will be high risk for diabetes. Imagine what would happen to her without all of this exercise. The other factor to consider is Bristol has aged, exercise should make her look young, healthy and vital. This indicates ingestion of toxic chemicals, severe stress, or a medical issue(or combination). A steady diet of junk food can also contribute to this. Pregnancy would not make her look older, but could be co-occurring with another issue that does.
ReplyDeleteLook at this one:
ReplyDeletehttp://x17online.com/gallery/view_gallery.php?gallery=BPalin112010_X17&index=14
Bristol's got more ass than 20-Mule Team Borax!!!
Hey Palinbots, how does Bristol's slutty dance tonight square with those family values of yours?
ReplyDeleteI subscribe to major stress eating, and let's forget, she doesn't move THAT much while dancing. In her package for tonights show, her belly is on full view and that is NOT a pregnant belly. It's lumpy and like the video of her and sarah out anf about in LA. I think she just hasnt found a way to lose weight and maintain it and her body keeps saying, nope, im going back to being bloated and fat
ReplyDelete"Please check on Mercede's site. I can't get on it, and I am suspicious that there is something afoot!
ReplyDeletehttp://www.mercedejohnston.com/"
I couldn't access it @ 9:07 CST
The other issue with Bristol's weight gain is that it is not in her legs, which bear the major bone and muscle stress of dancing, it is in her abdomen and upper arms.
ReplyDeleteAs a heavy boned heavy muscled woman, when I exercise, I did gain weight, health reason have made me stop but I ran, walked and biked for 20 years. I did not gain dress size though.
One of the areas that actually does get more exercise than you imagine is the abdominal muscles. When you exercise you breath with the abdominal muscles. When you do high impact exercise your abdominal muscles keep you guts from falling out every time your foot hits the ground.
Therefore: Bristol should not be gaining around the waist, as her abdominal muscles are getting quite a work out.
Unless of course she is going back to the hotel each night and porking out.
layers.
ReplyDeleteSomebody wrote that Mark has a contract starting at the end of November running for several months in a traveling show called "Burn the Floor." Does he know something that we won't find out until tomorrow night? Bristol can't go on tour without the guy who has been holding her up and dragging her around the floor.
ReplyDeletei tried to vote by calling and using the website and every time i try i am not allowed to vote. something is screwy. this is only the second time i've voted on the show (or tried, rather) as i would like to see the deserving contestants (grey and massey)place first and second.
ReplyDeleteIf she isn't preggers, she's a binge eater. Not all binge eaters purge, btw. And it's very very possible that she is sitting home at night downing a couple pizzas, a bag of burgers and a quart of ice cream at one sitting. She may be so emotionally disturbed because of her crazy competitive mamma, that she's medicating herself with food. That's just this arm chair psychologist's theory. Or she could be pregnant.
ReplyDeleteum...'he had it coming'???
ReplyDeleteWTF.
Now Gryphen, dancing may be good for a pregnant mother. It might not be conventional wisdom tho. Hah!
ReplyDeleteOn a trip, running a boat to Alaska in the 80's, we were weathered in at Ketchikan. We went up to a local bar (the Marine Bar if I remember correctly) to have a beer and shoot pool and it happened to have topless dancers doing their thing. A gal came out, who was very obviously pregnant, and did a couple dances. When she was finished, my friend and I invited her over to visit as we were intrigued that she was engaging in this activity at what we found out was 6 months PG. She said her doctor was fine with it as it was good exercise for her as long as she didn't strain herself. We congratulated her on her moxie and wished her and her baby well.
Maybe Bristol has the same Dr.
Rick
As someone with some experience in athletic training and weight management- What a load of BS.
ReplyDeleteShe is either pregnant, building muscle and putting on lots of fat at the same time, or something else is wrong with her body causing water retention or body fat accumulation.
More than one of these might be going on, but building muscle and putting on fat at the same time is most unlikely. I'll check some anatomy books to see what those under the chin and around the ankle muscles are .
Unless the physical regime during DWTS is significantly less active than her normal routine, then it is most unusual to be putting on the weight in such a visible fashion. As pointed out muscle weight gain is much less visible pound for pound gained, and fat converting to muscle does not require creative costuming to conceal.
The true test of course comes down to This question-do you believe that this girl is proof of how the Palins are significantly biologically different than everyone else or do you believe there is more Palin deception and media worship going on.
An author selling a book is happy to provide some excuses- for some book publicity. Except look what she is actually saying.
Is "Elisa Zied registered dietician" diagnosing an eating disorder caused by behavioral or psychological issues?
Jennifer and Derek made mark/bristle look like clod hoppers.
ReplyDeleteThey made mark, even look bad.
An interesting article at the Fairbanks Daily Newsminer online today.
ReplyDeleteFormer Fairbanks midwife delivers baby on trans-Pacific flight at 37,000 feet
Read the details about this and think about the 'Wild Ride' claims. And the airlines do make active efforts to prevent this type of thing, obviously subverted if the 'Wild Ride' story is true.
Kyle & Lacie constantly talked of his pizza eating. He's a food lover. Yet look at him. I read a week ago he's lost 8 inches from his waste.
ReplyDeleteHere is a pic of Bristol sitting in an interview October 7th - 6 1/2 weeks ago. Look at the face. It is oval elongated. I don't notice those extra chins either that she has been sporting. Whereas the pic in the black dance dress totally round.
http://media.photobucket.com/image/bristol%20palin/WestCorrespondent/Bristol%20Palin/PalinBristolFargoND101007b-1.jpg?o=84
I changed channels & passed ABC as
ReplyDeletethe show was ending & decided to call
(a first). I got the numbers from ABC's
site & called, and called, and called, and
only got through a few times. I switched
back & forth, from Kyle's number, to
Jennifer's, and only managed to get through
on Kyle's. It was always busy, or else it
would say my call didn't go through.
Finally I got a message I'd reached my
limit on my phone. I didn't get through
no 300 like some of the P-Bots are saying
they did, and I'm not wasting cell phone
minutes on it. I am hoping Kyle wins--that
would be a hoot, having another black
man beating a Palin. :^)
During the election, when her "sambo/bitch"
comment came out, I remember thinking
that sambo was going to beat another
bitch & he did.
As an experienced binge eater I feel very qualified to state this....
ReplyDeleteThere is no way --- NONE --- that Bristol Palin could possibly be binging enough to put on all that weight in such a short space of time, unless she eats 24/7.
And if she *is* eating 24/7, she would be unable to dance very much at all. Overeating has consequences other than weight gain. Bristol would feel nauseous and stuffed and bloated and constantly uncomfortable if she was nonstop binging the way that her quickly expanding midsection indicates that she would have to be.
Of course she'd feel that way if she was pregnant too. So either way I don't know how she is getting out there and dancing.
But the only thing that could put that much weight on her so fast, given that she can't practice dancing AND eat simultaneously (plus she has to sleep sometime, too)... and there must be some limit on her food intake so that she is physically able to perform at all without puking all over the stage... is pregnancy.
anyone have a link to the picture of levi with a hospital bracelet on holding a baby?
ReplyDeleteThis pic you can see she is wearing Spanx too so she's wearing layers to hold it in.
ReplyDeletehttp://tinyurl.com/29f9hjs
The picture before this one on the site is closer and shows the spanx line too.
Bristol next appearing on Celebrity Fit Club!! LOL
ReplyDeleteI'm sorry I know those are both Bristol pictured, but it does not look like the same person. One looks young and the other like the older maiden aunt trying to get lucky.
ReplyDeleteAs a person who has battled the lbs. nearly all my life, whenever I got into an exercise and/or diet mode, where I was beginning to see results, I would feel so good that I would double my efforts to be even more successful. (The old "success breeds success" thing.) It can become kind of addictive and is a HUGE self-esteem booster.
ReplyDeleteSo wouldn't you think that since DWTS is a COMPETITION, that she would just naturally lay off the junk food, in order to be more fit and able to dance better...thus feeling better about herself. And that any success that she has (particularly since everyone - including her - knows she shouldn't have gotten this far) would just increase her desire to be the best that she can be.
Also, the "gaining muscle weight" is a valid argument, but not in this case. Whoever heard of anyone gaining muscle around their middle? Are men - or women - with 6-pack abs as round as she is?
Let's face it, she's knocked up again.
Watched Beyonce on the View today. In the interview they were discussing the wind machines she uses on tour. She explained that they started out for the fact to keep her and dancers cool as that on stage she wore 4 pairs of tights -- so nothing moved.
ReplyDeleteShe also said they wore Spanx. They gave the audience the tip that women pull the spanx and tuck it up under your bra, or pin it to your bra.
Her doing that much dancing and being in the industry, it would be common for that to be done on DWTS
So tomorrow on the show, all the contestants are dancing EXCEPT Brandy. They say they haven't had enough time to practice????? I feel for her. I'm sure she's depressed
ReplyDeleteI think the only dance move she really knows is how to stand in one spot and shake her tatas.
ReplyDeleteNot to be too conspiratorial but so far the You Tube videos for tonight's DWTS are not available. There are some, but when you click on them they say they have been removed for copyright reasons.
ReplyDeleteThis is the very FIRST time that has happened this season.
Interesting, no?
Wow, OMG, she looks like she gained 25 pounds since last week. Mark is having a hard time pulling her weight around.
ReplyDeleteHere is side by side comparison pic of Bristol in 2008 and a few weeks ago on DWTS.
ReplyDeleteThe 2008 pic is where she was I believe 5 months pregnant when they had just announced the VP pic.
In the DWTS pic, you can see that she must be wearing body spanz in that from under bust down to waist, it's a tubular look -- being restrained in. Then there is the same tummy paunch in both.
http://media.photobucket.com/image/bristol%20palin/dsmyre/ANI/5117718481_550cdf4816.jpg?o=93
anon @ 5:21 pm sez:
ReplyDelete"As the daughter acts, so, too, will we know her parents."
right on, so true. will she carry on with the mindset that her family is the best and no one else will ever be as good or successful? or will bristol break away from that manufactured shit?
Gryphen, maybe because of such a dustup about voting, they are waiting for all time zones to view and vote. I say this as I have no idea what time it is in Hawaii
ReplyDeleteSarah, Todd and Gristle, see what you all make us speculate on, with your constant desiring perhaps to progress the Palin Americana iconography?
ReplyDeleteTheories about voting blocs, eating disorders, pregnancies, wite-out, maturity and intelligence called into question?
We know Sarah can't help herself, but JFC, think of your children in this vicious arena.
Gryphen, the first dance is on Gawker: http://tv.gawker.com/5696788/bristol-palin-sucks-for-the-final-time-on-dancing-with-the-stars
ReplyDeleteEven if her weight gain was due to muscle gain, I would ask where??? Her arms look worse than mine and I am 50 years old. She has no muscle tone anywhere on her body, except maybe her calves. Tonight was the last night that I will ever watch DWTS again. I cannot believe what I saw and heard from the judges after she did her first dance AND as much as I love Tom B. I am disgusted at what he said about don't whine if you don't vote. ABC you have lost a lifetime viewer forever. I hate that you tolerate Elizabeth H, you ruined DWTS and you did not promote Cuomo to the head position on GMA. Bristol is going to win and it will be egg on her face, but she won't get it. ABC has contributed to the ill of the teaparty and now they are no better than faux news.
ReplyDeleteToday we saw more of Bristol the victim. She put n her pouty face and acted like she really did not understand WHY people are upset.
ReplyDeleteThe people who are upset that she is still on the show are not "haters." They are people who embrace the idea that the people who deserve to win, actually do win.
And Bristol's first dance was not even remotely good enough to stand up against the performances delivered by Kyle and Jennifer.
FWIW, the rumor the last two weeks has been that there will be no DWTS Winter Tour this year.
ReplyDeleteDiscuss among yourselves (hee!)
The ABC web site is not responding - guess the Pee-tards are out in force tonight. Or maybe, it's all of us "haters?"
ReplyDeleteI am one of those people who believes I have been watching a young woman become progressively more with child over the length of this show's season. I have said all along that one cannot underestimate this industry's ability to hide or contain a pregnant woman's torso. They are the best of the best at this, with every possible tool at their disposal.
ReplyDeleteTonight proves this, indisputably. I feel Bristol has lost weight to help them in their efforts, and it has made enough of a difference that she is able to feel confident wearing something like that black number she wore for the lame Chicago dance. The corset contraption (God knows what it is made of) is probably the very same one she wore when she was in a black dress last week or the week before. The episode where she wore a black dress and then a long pink dress, I believe. This corset doesn't mess around. It not only pushes her stomach/abdomen down and in, it also bring the sides of her waist in - like flippin' Scarlett O'Hara!
BUT - the giveaway this week is a moment in the rehearsal footage where for an unbelievable 30 seconds to a minute, her pregnancy is visible for all to see. It's amazing they let this go on the air. I need to see the tape to post the time. She is wearing a black top and I think some sort of black over-sweater layer.
THAT is how Bristol Palin's body really looks, how things really stand at the moment, and no it's not simple weight gain. It's what she looks like when she is not literally being bound in order to hide the truth. Talk about being in a cage...literally and figuratively.
D'ya notice they made sure to do one shot where Sarah was just to the right of Tom Bergeron? She could barely summon a sincere smile, and the same goes for Bristol tonight.
Gryphen, I think youtube booted codebear3 because they posted full segments of the shows. Bristol's performances are still available from other people who uploaded them
ReplyDeleteThat jive was a snoozefest. It was like watching a dance in slow motion with no content. I can't believe what the judges said and the MARKS - You're friggin' kidding.
ReplyDeleteThese old bones could move faster than that and I haven't had the benefit of 4 months of daily dance reheasal.
I will say this, so far I cannot find the rehearsal footage that shows Bristol's true torso shape. All the tapes on youtube are either of just the dance, or they don't include the part that shows her belly. Weird. It will turn up eventually.
ReplyDeleteHere's a close side view Bristol pic from October 29th taken backstage.
ReplyDeleteHere's one positive thing about Bristol doing a number from broadway: she is far better than Katie Holmes will ever be onstage. There, something positive. In other news, I really want KYLE to win
ReplyDeleteShe looks like Dorian Grey in reverse. ThecPalins must have a portrait of a young lithe girl in the attic of the Wasilla compound. These 8 weeks have not been kind to Bristle.
ReplyDeleteIn the "practice" video, it is apparent that Bristol is trying to hide something as she kept pulling down her sweatshirt. But, there were a couple of times that the long tee and the sweatshirt rode up, revealing a nice round belly that certainly looked like a baby bump. And never having heard of "Chicago?" Just how ignorant is this girl? (I know. She's an idjit.)
ReplyDeleteWatched DWTS tonight - steeled myself for Bristol's whining. However, I was saddened, not upset. She said she's never seen a Broadway show. WTH? Didn't see "Chicago" earlier this year in Anchorage? Didn't see "The Lion King" last fall? Didn't even see "Spamalot"? At least she could have rented "Mamma Mia."
ReplyDeleteIm waiting for her to come out and say, as she did in HomerAK...Cant you see, Im dancing for Amerika!
ReplyDeleteNo pun intended, she really is fulla herself.
paylin saturation, this is hilarious! I want some toilet paper!!
While I hate to see better dancers go home too early, the show is designed like the way it is for a reason. It's the producers fault for enlisting a polticians daughter. I have to ask, what is Brisol and Mark supposed to do? Mark has loyal fans. Bristol has loyal fans and they have been near the top in the audience's votes since the beginning. The producer's have proven there's no conspiracy. People vote for whom they like. To me, all the contestants have had their annoying moments. ok except Kyle. and surprise, I feel Kyle should win.
ReplyDeleteIn all seriousness, if Mark had pulled out to keep it fair (I don't know what that means on a show with 50/50 voting), his fans would have been pissed. This whole debacle can be blamed on the fact that people do not have the ability to separate politics from entertainment and THAT is the true travesty of this season.
Just a thought...should Bristol actually win, it would give her bragging rights over Sarah. Sarah LOST her pageant.
ReplyDeleteI wouldn't want to be around for that cat fight!
HeeHee! Bristol really should us did not she! Clever little Girl!
ReplyDeleteHilarious!
Sexual domination - the pregnant woman's revenge.
No Bristol - you have a choice. You can just say no.
Oh, that's right your are a spokes person for abstenance.
My only guess is that no one ever told you what that meant did they?
This is one of those little things that you learn when you get a public education. but since you missed that, let me help you.
There are these books called "dictionaries." Yes, they are very boring even for people that read. A dictionary is just a bunch of words, where these words came from and what these words mean. You can even find dictionsries on the internet! yOU NEVER HAVE TO TOUCH A REAL BOOK.
According to one of those big books known as dictionaries, abstenence :
The act or practice of refraining from indulging an appetite or desire.
Bristol; this means that you don't have screw some guy just because you need to feel loved or just drunk .
ttp://www.answers.com/topic/abstinence#ixzz164xQMZEY
Pretty sure that she is with child. Wouldn't be surprised if we hear after the show that she is engaged or secretly married to someone, anyone, all of them.
ReplyDeleteMuscle weighs more than fat but, it also takes up less space so,you can lose a lot of inches without losing a lot of weight. Bristol has done neither. THAT is NOT muscle weight. I guess the troll will believe anything.
ReplyDeleteWTF was Brisket's second dance about. Stands in a cage for a while taking up precious time as usual then plays tug of war to burn up more time and then she gets 9's?
ReplyDeleteAnother dance designed for a simpleton.
Kyle was a dancin' and a groovin' and a sweatin'.
ReplyDeleteBrisket well let's face it, she did not fall over.
So I guess Kyle is going home tomorrow.
Somebody please count the actual dance steps that each contestant took. Brisket spends far more time just standing in one place while her partner actually does some dancing.
ReplyDeleteReally liked the lift-spin that Jennifer Grey did. They'd need a frickin' crane to get Brisket to twirl like that.
Gryphen, I think the most telling evidence that she is pregnant lies in the "dances" they have her doing. Part of the reason for the simple steps is undoubtedly that she is a complete klutz. But if she is indeed pregnant, DWTS would need to choreograph around that. And that's what we're seeing--dances designed for a pregnant klutz. She deserved 2s for that cage walk.
ReplyDeleteHer dances are very simple and don't require a lot of energy, so I'm not surprised she's getting fat. She simply is not exercising very hard. If Bristol thinks this is "hard work", she obviously hasn't worked very hard in her life.
ReplyDeleteI thought she was fat when the show started. Now she's a whale. All those chins! I think she's pregnant, overeating, AND not dancing very much.
I would like to explain something to Brisol, Sarah and their ardent followers. "Hater" is not a good word to use. People can criticize Bristol's dancing and still like her. Learn to separate the performance from the personality.
ReplyDeleteWe can look at Sarah's book and decide if she is a skilled writer, a hack, a qualified journalism major or a mean girl venting pent up anger. Whether or not Sarah can write a book, we have to judge her as a political candidate on her ability and intelligence.
That's where Sarah has everybody snookered. She believes that selling her family image as the All American Outdoorsy Family is the same thing as a qualification. She equates celebrity with ability. It ain't so. Even if Bristol wins first, second and third place on Dancing with the Stars, that is no defeat to the Democrats or the Liberals; they weren't in the contest.
Sarah has a way on mixing up ability and personality. If you actually want to think for yourself and make your own choice, she will bully you into choosing her. It's her way or the highway!
There was not enough dance content in both dances that if you put them together into one -- it would still be incomplete.
ReplyDeleteThe jive was in slow motion. ZZZZZZ
The 2nd dance - Stand in a cage - shake your head -- running on the floor until the ribbon was stretched out - then twirl until you were wrapped up it in together -- then untwirl to get out of it. Then stand at a chair and move a hat around. Wow -- this was a real energetic stretch. LOL
You shouldn't be out of breath for doing either of those dances.
Here's a close side view Bristol pic from October 29th taken backstage. (I missed putting link earlier)
http://twitpic.com/2yuxas
Bristol delivered exactly what I was expecting...dumbed down choreography, walking around and not lifting her feet off the floor. That Freestyle was a joke and her Jive was just as bad. ROFLMAO, she got f=kin' nines for playing tug of war.
ReplyDeleteI haven't been watching the show but I have noticed even from stills that her chest has increased dramatically over the past few weeks. Added inches in the belly area COULD possibly be from overeating (although as someone who studied dance for years, I highly doubt that)but it generally doesn't add to the bust that quickly, especially if you're rehearsing enough to slim and tone your legs.
ReplyDeleteThere IS something, however, that makes your bust increase substantially in a short period of time. And it's NOT McDonald's.
I am done with DWTS also. Tuned in tonight to do my part with voting. Switched channels and did not let one minute of Skating With The Stars into my House. Judges did a terrible job with Bristol's Jive. Not one flick, lick or anything close!
ReplyDeleteThe ABC servers are just a total meltdown. It took a long time, but managed to vote for myself, spouse, dog, and two cats (deceased). I know they would have wanted Jennifer Grey to win.
ReplyDeleteBut with all this computer trouble, the Peebots will scream "CONSPIRACY" when Bristle loses.
MSNBC has a story up - Ouch!
ReplyDeleteThe picture is not going to be filed under 'flattering'! It looks like the 'mean girl' scowl
http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/40326863/ns/today-entertainment/
Brisket's jive was sad with no energy!! I wanted to go out and move her feet and legs for her!! She needs a dance makeover!! She has been on here since the beginning and it feels to me, like she is just starting the first show. And people say she is the most improved?!?! Why do they handle this girl with kid gloves? Is it because her political mommy is in the audience? Why is everyone so afraid to say anything about how bad she really is? Not to mention she is really obnoxious too!!! She never gets into the dance. Never!!!!
ReplyDeleteLove how exited grandmother palin gets when she know the camera is on her.
ReplyDeleteWatched the show tonight and Bristol was covered twice talking about 'the haters' against her. She is so much like her mother (and I use that term loosely) - same victim style there is no doubt.
ReplyDeleteShe and her partner were outdone in their performances as usual. She does not deserve to win.
Completely agree that it is her chest that is giving her away, as well.
ReplyDeleteJive is all about kicks and flicks. Bristol did not do one kick and not one flick. That was no Jive and in the finals for crying out loud. Mark should be mortified he had to choreograph that hot mess!!! Mark is the master at kicks and flicks. Talk about having to dumb down a routine. Sheesh.
ReplyDeleteMetabolic issues that come to mind do include thyroid (hypothyroid or maybe even Hashimoto's thyroiditis which can account for drastic weight gain and weight loss) or PCOS/hyperinsulinemia. If BP did have some thyroid issue, I believe that with as quickly as she's gained weight that she would definitely have other physical afflictions going on at this point.
ReplyDeletePCOS isn't as easy to 'diagnose' as there are a myriad of symptoms, but includes sometimes rapid and inexplicable weight gain (weight loss, even with diet and exercise, can be difficult; much of the issue with PCOS is rooted in over-production of insulin/inability of insulin to penetrate glucose, etc., ad nauseum, et al, ...). As someone afflicted with PCOS for many years now, I don't honestly believe that IS what is going on with Bristol, but wouldn't completely rule out it as a possibility either.
Jennifer Grey should definitely win based on technique and perseverence and I actually voted for her this time. However, I did not know that she and PAtrick Swayze hated each other during DD. I'm glad she chose to honor him and the movie during dwts and only hope her feelings are genuine
ReplyDeleteI can't buy the theory as presented because it doesn't explain the weight gain in her face.
ReplyDeleteMy last pregnancy, I gained a lot of weight right off, without any change in my diet. It was just one of those pregnancies we hear about every now & then. After the 3rd or 4th month, I just gained weight as a 'normal' pregnant woman.
I think she's pregnant, & I wouldn't put it past her to elect to use her right to choice (just to prove to us that she is not).
The metabolism hypothesis doesn't wash very well, because if it is a thyroid disease she would be too weak to dance, or even possibly take care of her child.
ReplyDeleteOvereating is a possibility but she would have to be packing in the calories on a constant basis. I see lots of photos of her, but not stuffing her face by the hour.
I still think she is due for a little bundle of joy in three or four months.
The word salad tonight by $Palin regarding her ability to school others in journalism is evidence of an impending implosion by the grandmother-to-be.
Stress'll do that to ya.
She would have been better to have called the jive in!!
ReplyDeleteIt amazes me that the show continued over the weeks, to allow her to spew 'the haters' at every turn she could.
Mark, in his written journal that I read online, he too refers to "the haters". Professional - not. If he returns, he's lost potential fan base. And just think - if Bristol does not win - he's lost the baggers too. In fact, he better go into a witness protection program!!!
He referred to 'MamaP' in the journal -- ya don't win, it will be more than 'MamaP' after his ass!
As bad as her dancing was, Bristol had an opportunity to show herself. It's been 4 months in front of millions each week and instead she choose to parrot her mother. When asked if the TP was supporting and voting for her, she'd deny. Just say yes, thank them but instead, deny it at every turn and play victim & the haters were out to get her.
Polly wanna a cracker!!!
I will agree that people throw the word hater around too freely, but you all are pissed AT Bristol when it's her fans contining to vote her in. She cannot control that. She could walk onstage and say "please don't vote for me out of pity, politics or just because you relate to me..." and I am 100% certain people would continue to vote for her. If she were to pul herself out of the competition, the show would be rendered pointless, as the point is to take "stars" who suppposedly have no dance background (although in the past thats not been the case) and teach them how to ballroom dance in front of the US. IN ONE WEEK. I'm shocked Bristol physically made it through one week of press and live audience - on top of a foreign way of moving. THAT is why people like her. And the fact that people attacked Mark, Brooke, Tom, Carrie on twitter out of stupid anger does not look good for this country.
ReplyDeleteShe moves like a stump, got high scores nonetheless and STILL bitches.
ReplyDeleteThe little bitch whines, more:
"Sure, Bristol Palin and partner Mark Ballas wound up at the bottom of Dancing With the Stars' finale leaderboard, but Team Pistol is A-OK and has a completely logical explanation for tonight's "bizarre" scoring outcome:
Blame Renée Zellweger!
Actually, blame Renée, Catherine Zeta-Jones, Mya and the entire cast of Chicago (from both Broadway and the big screen)!
"Look, Broadway's never been done in the finals, so I thought we'd take it and add some creativity," Mark explained. "And I was bummed that we didn't get three nines, but the judges weren't satisfied and were comparing us to the movie—it's a multi-million dollar movie! With the best dancers in the world!"
"And Renée Zellweger," added Bristol with a laugh. "It was bizarre because we had only five days to rehearse this on top of another dance. I am bummed about the scores because I thought the routine went so well and I had fun out there. It was definitely risky to do a performance like that, but it was good."
Read more: http://www.eonline.com/uberblog/watch_with_kristin/b212718_backstage_dwts_bristol_palin_explains.html
Watching Mark "dance?" with Bristol is like watching him push a grocery cart around the floor!
ReplyDeleteOur block did not watch the show tonight, nor will they on Tuesday, either. But a friend did say that the Judges were not honest with evaluating both of Bristol's dances, which were way underperformed than her previous two dances last week. The friend said Palin's missed steps were overlooked as usual, and the dead pan facial expressions were the all time worst ever on the show. The Judges' soft criticism rewarded Palin with high scores (3, 9's I believe it was said for the first dance). For the second dance Palin did almost no dancing at all (only inside a cage), except to play with a long scarf. If any of the others used a prop for as long as Palin did, the Judges would have called them out for the cheap stunt. But not one thing was said about it to Palin. Her scores were still way too high for that dance as well. WHY? Just another crooked deal set-up. And they can't blame that on the voters. It was said, too, that Bristol's whining and crying on tonight's show about the people not like her, is just very immature and poor sportsmanship like behavior done far too often as an excuse for sympathy for her very poor dancing skills. The friend went on to say that you did not see that same immature behavior with excuses from Kyle, who took the Judges criticism like a man along with a big smile. It is safe to say that Bristol's performance did not redeem her lack of dancing skills and showed no progression in tonight's final dance show, which only goes to prove that she should never have been in the finals.The Judges and producer put her there, followed by the political crowd. Bristol deserves nothing better than what was given to the earlier contestants and it was Brandy (not my favorite choice), who was cheated of the opportunity to be in the final 3. Don't even think of the lame excuse that she is like us or the only one without prior dance experience, etc., because Rick and Kurt did not as well.We don't teach our children to whine and cry with trite excuses to win over sympathy. Bristol has walked away from this show without learning anything at all including good sportsmanship behavior.
ReplyDeleteDid any one catch the part, before they danced, that showed them practicing. There was one side shot of her that showed without a doubt how big and protruding her stomach is. She usually wears a hoody or over sized sweater, but at this practice she wore a cardigan and it was not big enough to hide the belly. Looked definitely like a pregnant belly. She is huge. I'll try to see if I can find it online. If any one recorded the show, go check out the pre dance practice footage.
ReplyDeleteI'm still trying to figure out why the judges are so lenient with her. She seems like a sweet girl but that has never stopped them before. I think they wanted to keep her on the show and, because of that, much better dancers got the boot. I have lost some of my respect for the show.
ReplyDeleteHow the judges could rate Palin's dud performances anywhere NEAR those of Kyle is Jen is just absolutely ludacris (sp?). 5's and 6's would have been more appropriate and then even that's questionable considering her lack of talent.
ReplyDeleteAnon 10:00
ReplyDeleteI just got a twitter message.
Your rock is looking for you.
10:00, Bristol is disliked because she is a mean-spirited, whiney, hypocrite who lacks grace, talent and self-awareness.
ReplyDeleteIf she really were a nice, sweet, charmer, people wouldn't be as disgusted that her lack-luster performances are keeping her on the show.
And all those "fans" of hers, well, she came by 95% them through her mother. They aren't really looking at her anyway.
That cage dance was just simply awful. Mark even looked bad, and that's a first.
ReplyDeleteThe judges should be hanging their heads in shame for going along with this farce.
Bristol in a cage.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OIwUsulDEDw
Bristol in blue sneakers.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lgxt3VtJSAI
Dial Idol shows Jennifer & Derek with a big lead over Bristol.
http://stars.dialidol.com/asp/predictions/predictions.asp
Bristol popped this week. When you look at the rehearsal footage in the 2nd half of the show, at the beginning of the segment, Palin is wearing all black. The camera catches her from the side, so there is Bristol in all black and then a light colored wall. The baby bump is an obvious baby bump. There is no doubt. She has a pronounced 6 month baby bump.
ReplyDeleteLook at Bristol's chest. She has increased by at least 2 cups sizes. That doesn't happen that quickly from weight gain. That is pregnancy induced.
Some mention that Bristol isn't losing belly weight because she is dancing and losing in the legs and thighs. Dancing is excellent for the core muscles, and should result in significant belly fat loss and toning.
While the show has been good with camouflage, she has been cinched in for weeks now.
I agree that a medical issue could be to blame, but if that were the case, she would be too ill for this competition. She wouldn't have the energy to even show up for rehearsal. Any medical explaination (other than drug side-effect) that would explain this would be accompanied with paralyzing fatigue. The kind of fatigue that keeps people in bed for days and days.
Mercede Johnston's blog is down: mercedejohnston.com
ReplyDeleteWhy? http://shesnohockeymom.blogspot.com/2010/11/mercedes-latest-series-of-posts.html
H/T to Floyd Orr.
I unfortunately agree with the commenter who said she's going to announce after the show that she's been secretly married this whole time. And she will never produce a marriage license, but anytime people ask, she will scream that they are haters.
ReplyDeletePuzzled. Bristol seemed to start out looking bigger than last week (the rehearsal clips) and then ended up on stage looking smaller than last week.
ReplyDeleteThe full clip of the freestyle, rehearsal clips, judging/score
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7KZvmFr42cE
I didn't see Willow in the audience. She may have been in the 2nd row with Todd.
It's called pregnancy. Only the Palins will get away with calling it whatever the heck they want.
ReplyDeleteTo clarify something about muscle and exercise that everyone is misunderstanding here:Dancing does not produce muscle mass increases for the most part (and it also does not produce 'long lean muscle'--it only reduces body fat which makes existing muscle more visible--and appear 'longer, leaner' since it is not covered by as much chunky fat.
ReplyDeleteIt is physiologically impossible to build noticeable and measurable increases in muscle in the first few months of WEIGHT training, forget dancing--especially in women.
The research shows that the average muscle mass gain in women doing SIX months of progressive, HEAVY weight lifting is only 1 to 2 pounds of muscle. The first 6 to 8 weeks of WEIGHT LIFTING does produce increases in strength but they are not due to increased mass (protein in the muscle fibers) but increased muscle contraction efficiency--the motor neurons learn to work better. However, to build muscle--hypertrophy--one has to eat more than their normal daily energy expenditure.
Bristol's normal daily energy needs estimated by height and weight are probably in the realm of 1800 calories per day---if she is dancing, say 3 hours a day--this is low impact, low intensity dancing--not heavy duty working out--then she may need another 1500 calories--MAX. So let's say she needs 3200ish calories per day at the moment, factoring in current weight and dancing practice to stay weight stable.
To gain weight this much this quickly she would be needing to be eating in the realm of 4000-5000 calories per day--or more--something that an endurance athlete training for an ultra marathon might eat--and VERY hard to do--unless you are eating a triple Big Mac, large fries and shake--at every meal. Eating 5000 calories per day is like eating 20 Snickers bar per day. Or say, 10 on top of normal meals. OK, you can do it--but not easy--and would make you sick probably. (This is why endurance athletes have a tough time putting on weight--it's tough to eat as much as you need--especially if you eat healthy stuff.)
So, it's unlikely her weight gain is from overeating as much as she would have needed to eat to gain this much in a couple of months; it's impossible for her weight gain to be due to muscle--while a few people genetically can increase some lean body mass from cardio training--again it's a teeny amount--1-2 pounds and would take 3 months.
This girl has gained AT LEAST 10-15, if not 20-25 pounds in what appears to be 2ish months (how long has this show been on?) Why has noone done a photo comparison from week to week--and especially from say week 1 to 3 to 6 to now (I have no idea what week in the show it is)
Anyway, it's a common myth that people gain from muscle gain from exercise--but this is a myth--something people like to use as an excuse for not losing what they expect. The reality is that not much muscle is gained, and it's hard to do--and you need to do resistance training and eat more to even see anything measurable.
And of course--triple chins, flabby bellies, thick thighs and chunky arms are fat, not muscle. Sure, with any weight gain, a small percentage is muscle (to support the extra weight), but this is not from her exercise regime.
She is either binge drinking (you can get lots of calories in that way), has some hormonal or presription--prozac, etc.-drug related weight gain or is pregnant.
To clarify something about muscle and exercise that everyone is misunderstanding here:Dancing does not produce muscle mass increases for the most part (and it also does not produce 'long lean muscle'--it only reduces body fat which makes existing muscle more visible--and appear 'longer, leaner' since it is not covered by as much chunky fat.
ReplyDeleteIt is physiologically impossible to build noticeable and measurable increases in muscle in the first few months of WEIGHT training, forget dancing--especially in women.
The research shows that the average muscle mass gain in women doing SIX months of progressive, HEAVY weight lifting is only 1 to 2 pounds of muscle. The first 6 to 8 weeks of WEIGHT LIFTING does produce increases in strength but they are not due to increased mass (protein in the muscle fibers) but increased muscle contraction efficiency--the motor neurons learn to work better. However, to build muscle--hypertrophy--one has to eat more than their normal daily energy expenditure.
Bristol's normal daily energy needs estimated by height and weight are probably in the realm of 1800 calories per day---if she is dancing, say 3 hours a day--this is low impact, low intensity dancing--not heavy duty working out--then she may need another 1500 calories--MAX. So let's say she needs 3200ish calories per day at the moment, factoring in current weight and dancing practice to stay weight stable.
To gain weight this much this quickly she would be needing to be eating in the realm of 4000-5000 calories per day--or more--something that an endurance athlete training for an ultra marathon might eat--and VERY hard to do--unless you are eating a triple Big Mac, large fries and shake--at every meal. Eating 5000 calories per day is like eating 20 Snickers bar per day. Or say, 10 on top of normal meals. OK, you can do it--but not easy--and would make you sick probably. (This is why endurance athletes have a tough time putting on weight--it's tough to eat as much as you need--especially if you eat healthy stuff.)
ReplyDeleteSo, it's unlikely her weight gain is from overeating as much as she would have needed to eat to gain this much in a couple of months; it's impossible for her weight gain to be due to muscle--while a few people genetically can increase some lean body mass from cardio training--again it's a teeny amount--1-2 pounds and would take 3 months.
This girl has gained AT LEAST 10-15, if not 20-25 pounds in what appears to be 2ish months (how long has this show been on?) Why has noone done a photo comparison from week to week--and especially from say week 1 to 3 to 6 to now (I have no idea what week in the show it is)
Anyway, it's a common myth that people gain from muscle gain from exercise--but this is a myth--something people like to use as an excuse for not losing what they expect. The reality is that not much muscle is gained, and it's hard to do--and you need to do resistance training and eat more to even see anything measurable.
And of course--triple chins, flabby bellies, thick thighs and chunky arms are fat, not muscle. Sure, with any weight gain, a small percentage is muscle (to support the extra weight), but this is not from her exercise regime.
She is either binge drinking (you can get lots of calories in that way), has some hormonal or presription--prozac, etc.-drug related weight gain or is pregnant.
Jive - Week 5 & Week 10 comparison:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.flickr.com/photos/49830475@N04/5200728367/
Tried to keep the pictures in the same proportions but if different camera lenses were used the comparison couls be off.
From this, it looks to me like the pics show some growth.
MadCity 9:25
ReplyDeleteBristle is way to fertile to have PCOS.
The fact that Bristol is pregnant is probably an open secret on this show. The costume designers deserve Emmys. They are giving her good scores because they know they are watching a pregnant girl trying to dance like she's not. A for effort. My question is, how are they going to announce this without making the people who have been devoting hours voting for Bristol feel duped?
ReplyDeleteHowever it comes out, there will be a fat paycheck attached for at least one Palin, I'm sure.
I've updated my Bristol Palin Photobucket album, for anyone who wants to do a comparison survey of the Bristol shape over the past few months.
ReplyDeletehttp://bit.ly/bk3ToJ
I voted for Jenn and for Kyle online. At ABC.com you can watch the entire episode. FF and watch at 38:14-38:29, she's wearing a black shirt with a grey jacket and, while whining and feeling sorry for herself, she puts her hands up in her hair and she reveals her side profile for once -- her tummy sticks out farther than her chest -- upper tummy, not lower tummy like you'd see with weight gain. She looks preggo in profile to me. Check it out -- maybe someone can do a screen shot. And she's not wearing engagement ring -- it's decorative/stripy/costume jewelry
ReplyDeleteDamn. I just watched the clip on Gawker. She ruined the musical Chicago, and one of the best songs and dances in it.
ReplyDeleteShe's really squeezed into that little black number, isn't she?
How can no one in the MSM just ASK THE FREAKIN' QUESTION? How can the general public NOT ask the question? How is it only blogs are asking?
It boggles my mind.
curiouser's side by side pictures are the best evidence I've seen that she's being padded around the middle under her bustline to cover the belly bump further down. She's not being bound in so much as layered to cover the bump. Cleverly done to try to keep proportion. Thanks for these.
ReplyDeleteyoutube link at 1:23AM, at about :50 to 1:10, in the rehearsal. Big baby bump, right there for anyone to see.
ReplyDeletecuriouser said...
ReplyDeleteJive - Week 5 & Week 10 comparison:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/49830475@N04/5200728367/
Tried to keep the pictures in the same proportions but if different camera lenses were used the comparison could be off.
From this, it looks to me like the pics show some growth.
Holy crap! That's a great comparison. Yes, there's been growth. From then to now there's been a huge growth. I don't even think one could gain that much weight by just eating or having a medical condition. It has to be pregnancy.
I got curious after watching that pathetic second excuse for a jive, and went to youtube to watch videos of Mark's jives with other partners. Watch Melissa Joan Hart's jive- 2nd week, and it was head and shoulders above the dance we saw last night. Ridiculous
ReplyDeleteCuriouser- wk5/wk10 comparison- what I see in those pictures is that her chest has grown- and the belly in the second picture still sticks out farther than her chest!
BTW, they're starting to talk about a pregnancy possibility over on the DWTS MB... finally!
Did we get the tape? I was starting to think there would only be an edited version. Thanks! This to me is the irrefutable proof.
ReplyDeleteThis is the moment I was amazed by -
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MGWGbhULB3M
Starting at 00:45, for about 10 seconds or so.
Here's a link to two screenshots I made from the Youtube video of the rehearsal footage showed last night.
ReplyDeletehttp://oi53.tinypic.com/4fubew.jpg>http://oi53.tinypic.com/4fubew.jpg
So is it the extreme pressure of the tight clothing that she is bound up in what causes her to look like she's been sucking lemons?
ReplyDeleteJust wondering!
Just watched Kyle's freestyle online. It was so fun and young and energetic and happy. He was clearly working hard, but loving it and playing off the crowd's energy. Really great!
ReplyDeleteBristol explained what is going on with her midsection! It's "thick skin!"
ReplyDeletehttp://tinyurl.com/2eal8ok
I just watched the jive. It's probably the most fun I've seen her have. The dance itself wasn't too hard, lots of repeats, shimmies, etc., but it was energetic and bouncy. *shrugs*
ReplyDeleteI don't watch DWTS, but I watch Idol, and I have a great disdain for the "Vote for the Worst" crowd that turns up every season. The world isn't going to stop spinning if Bristol wins, but if I were a regular viewer, I would probably be very annoyed at the interlopers who hijacked this season in some psycho attempt to teach the "liberals a lesson."
For some reason, their efforts remind me of the of the "Overly Competitive Touch Football Player" commercial.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QgnS9bmP_qw
I'd say the Bots still have issues with their girl losing the election. Better dancers on DWTS are just in their way of settling the "score."
Someone asked why the judges are so nice to her. I think the simple reason is that she is pregnant, and they have been brought in on the very poorly kept secret. All the people claiming she could never be doing this much physical activity without the show undertaking horrendous liability don't understand the fact that her doctor probably signed a release as long as they agreed that it wouldn't be that strenuous. I also feel this is the reason why Mark has been so sweet to her.
ReplyDeleteI could just see the Palins turning Bristol's loss tonight into a Palin moment and announce her pregnancy on national television. Sarah won't be able to stand that the Hollywood types will get the attention when Jennifer wins. Sarah will steal the spotlight somehow!
5:07 PM
ReplyDeleteWhat approximately would her calorie intake be? We know she likes cookies, cakes, cupcakes and McD. It would be powerful to see a photo of all the food she would have to pack in for a day to gain weight during alleged strenuous work outs.
That image of Oprah with the wagon of fat really got her point across. In the Tea Bagging advertisement photo in Harper's with all the cakes, how many would she need to eat in a day to keep expanding as she is doing? Just curious.
About the cage dance: True, in Chicago the lead was incarcerated, hence the cage. It was a huge stretch Mark chose to go the road of sexual domination, aggression which was off the mark for Chicago of a conniving female who used her feminine wiles, not S&M dominatrix in leather boots.
ReplyDeleteBefore the freestyle portion people said repeatedly that "lifts" were important. I thought, uh oh Bristol and Mark are at a disadvantage due to their mismatched sizes and Bristol's weight. Why did they not lose points for yet again their basic choreography and cheap tricks like the scarf dominating the dance?
Having seen and been party to many achieving professional dance careers and those who dance as a hobby, Bristol and Mark are competing at a level much lower from the other contestants. The entitlement and vile labeling people who notice as "haters" is offensive and irrational.
It is sad Bristol can not be satisfied with hre personal improvement needing to speak disparagingly of people who do not share her delusional entitlement to win and the Palin vindictiveness possturing as victims.
mark looks real, real, real bad now. i do not see how all the hard work, lies and spin will ever redeem him. only the truth can set him free.
ReplyDeleteRick
ReplyDeleteWas it a non-smoking bar?
Gryphen, I agree with your point, that there are mind games afoot that no one is to notice what the Palin's do not want to be seen i.e. that Bristol has gained an unbelievable amount of weight contrary to her stated intentions of work ethics and hopes to lose weight.
ReplyDeleteThis indeed defies biology and physiology.
I can't resist mocking this situation: Maybe Miss Palin's next gig will be "I Did Not Know I Was Pregnant".
Seriously, there simply just is something very wrong, a problem evidenced by her increasing girth and enormous breast size increase.
It is merely frustrating when persons play mind games, attempt brainwashing and resort to name calling when physical reality is presented and the spinning continues to distract from obvious fact.
Truthfully I would not put it past the Palin's to deny a pregnancy or be so bold to deny what is obvious to others given their past behaviors.
Someone else commented and I agree the costumes have padding so the burdgeoning belly weight is not as noticeable.
Ballas was a good professional dancer but he proved he is no choreographer. I pity his fans and what they now must defend.
ReplyDeleteWhat is up with Willow?
ReplyDeletehttp://www.radaronline.com/exclusives/2010/11/willow-palin-involved-drug-deal-chugging-vodka-peers-tell-magazine
Excellent post, Gryph! Let Chuck Heath's science defend their ridiculous nonsense. They will all run and hide from your facts.
ReplyDeleteShe is either binge drinking (you can get lots of calories in that way), has some hormonal or prescription--Prozac, etc.-drug related weight gain or is pregnant.
ReplyDeleteAll of the above and steroids! The girl is in BIG TROUBLE. As in not healthy.
Nothing says muscle like flabby chins and bloat. They conveniently left out what is happening to that huge face. Now it makes sense why she would be "caught" by the paps at a cheesecake factory right before this article. They make it totally evident that the whole "white powder" incident was another set up for Bristol.
ReplyDeleteWhatever Bristol's big problem is, it is cruel of ABC, Sarah, Ivy, the Tea Baggers and all who are using her this way. No way should she have ever been part of this quasi-political commercial spectacle, she should have been at a Mayo Clinic. ABC and all know that someone with an eating disorder, thyroid, diabetes or the like is in trouble if they neglect it and take on more stressful situations. An eating disorder and pregnant far worse. Of course, she has an excuse now and can bow out and go into hiding. While they will promote how she loves her the new Big is Beautiful Bristol. However, they spin don't let them get by with this. I'd like to know if Kelli Osborne can defend Bristol now. If she could talk turkey about her weight and the show as compared to Bristol. I can't believe with all the trainers and doctors in LA that the media completely leaves out the discussions about what we are witnessing.
It was revealing to see Sarah cheering on this horrible display. As if she enjoys watching her giant caged cub being set up in order to do Dance Sport. What kind of mother would not notice her child's health? The Palins are ghouls. And it is not like Trig, Willow and Piper don't all need more authentic parental care and attention.
The competition Bristol is doing is DANCE SPORT. While this is a dumb TV show and all that, it is also an athletic competition. If this was happening in another sport competition the judges and business industry that promote this would not so easily get by with the hoax. Bristol has ruined the credibility of DANCE SPORT forever. She shrunk a talented pro into a pitiful puppet and made DWTS look like dastardly criminal.
Did anyone notice behind Sarah there was a fellow that looked like Track Palin? Who was that?
Gryph, you are my hero. I watched a morning program and they ARE NOT discussing the pure unvarnished truth about this at all. The controversy was all about is it her mother's Tea Bags or not. Most did think IT is was Mommy Dearest and the fix. No one cares about health and a good sport competition example.
I say about 80% blame is on the idiot judges for fueling the Tea Bagging cookie ladies of WaSilly to get more votes. There are some dumb Democrats that fell for this hoax.
ReplyDeleteThere's a difference between weight and inches.
ReplyDeleteShe might gain weight if she were shedding pounds and gaining muscle.
But she'd still shed inches. She would tighten and tone up and you'd SEE the change.
Now that may be happening if Bristol were attending every rehearsal and working as hard as possible. But if she's slacking off on rehearsals and using downtime to stuff herself with unhealthy junk food, then any progress her body makes (and it would still make *some* progress) might be offset by a type of weight and inches gain that no amount of diet and exercise can control.
They'll blame Levi and that two week engagement window. You just wait and see. Because having the same Father doesn't look so bad. It will be his fault for seducing her. Poor Bristol submitted in a moment of weakness. It was only one time.
And Levi won't even bother with a paternity test. (If he does, he should demand test for both the new baby and Tripp.)
I think eventually the DWTS costume dept. is going to throw her under the bus and let it all hang out. Accentuate it even.
Maybe they're saving that for the last show, when she wins?
http://the-godiva.livejournal.com/195418.html
Watch without the sound, and you will see how uncomplicated her dancing is. Not much to it.
ReplyDeleteShe probably went on birth control pills when she started having an affair with the partner. The "Teen Activist" cannot afford to become preggers again. She has gained weight all over, expecially the thighs. BCP's would also explain the pouty and moody behavior.
ReplyDelete