Monday, May 13, 2013

New census data shows that the demographic shifts may soon make the Republicans obsolete as a national party.

Courtesy of the New Republic:  

Today, the Census released the November 2012 Current Population Survey (CPS) Voting and Registration Supplement, which is based on interviews with hundreds of thousands of residents. The CPS asks Americans whether they participated in the last election. The CPS is imperfect like any survey, but it is considered the gold standard for analyzing turnout. It demonstrates that, in the debate about the GOP’s future in an increasingly diverse America, both sides are right, to a certain extent. On the one hand, Obama’s historic candidacy led to historic black turnout. On the other hand, the Obama coalition is the product of irreversible demographic changes. If Republicans hope to win presidential elections, they will need to broaden their appeal—not just count on lower minority turnout in the post-Obama era. 

Unsurprisingly, the CPS found that the 2012 electorate was more diverse than any in history. Whites represented just 73.7 percent of the electorate, down from 76.3 in 2008 and 79.2 percent in 2004. In comparison, the exit polls found that whites represented 72 percent of the electorate in 2012, compared to 74 percent in 2008 and 77 percent in 2004. For the first time, the CPS found that black turnout rates exceed white turnout rates, with 66.2 percent of voting age blacks turning out, compared to 64.1 percent of whites. Many expected that black turnout would decline in 2012, but the CPS actually found that black turnout was even higher in 2012 than it was in 2008, increasing from 64.7 to 66.2 percent. 

But the problem for Republicans is that the white share of the voting eligible population is likely to decline even further over the next four years. What’s causing the decline? Today’s 15-18 year olds are only about 58 percent white. As they enter the electorate and older whites depart, the non-white share of the voting eligible population rises. This prediction is not subject to great uncertainty. These 15-18 year olds are alive, they’re counted in the Census, and, unless they die, they’re going to be eligible to vote in 2016. If the non-white share of the voting eligible population declines by another 2 points, as expected, then the 2016 electorate will about as diverse as it was in 2012, even if turnout rates return to 2004 levels. The Obama coalition is not going away, even if elevated minority turnout rates are gone for good. 

The biggest mistake that Republicans made in 2012 was assuming that 2008 was a special, one-time product of a historic candidate. That was superficially appealing and maybe even “felt” right, but the CPS said that the 2008 turnout wasn’t as unique as the huge crowds and palpable enthusiasm made it seem. The GOP should not delude itself into believing that taking Obama off of the ballot will return them to the White House, even if black turnout rates should be expected to decline in 2016. Demographic change, not turnout, is the primary force driving the declining white share of the electorate, and the GOP will need to adapt.

Nothing that the GOP is currently doing indicates that they have learned ANYTHING from their recent defeats in the last two presidential elections. So I think that the White House may be out of their reach for the foreseeable future, barring any huge scandal for the Democrats that is.

However on the local level the GOP still has a very strong machine in place, not to mention control over those damn voting machines, which means that unless the Democrats find a way to outlaw voting machines that leave no paper trail, or increase their turnout to such a degree that elections cannot be stolen, they will have to wait until the people finally get completely fed up with the Republican party or until the demographics change to such a degree that even in smaller elections the minority becomes the majority.

Personally I don't think our country can survive waiting for the latter.

7 comments:

  1. Anonymous4:16 AM

    Virginia just made voting laws real simple ...

    To be able to vote, you must show your white penis ...no other ID needed.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous5:42 AM

      Oops, that means Todd can't vote.

      Delete
  2. Anonymous4:37 AM

    While the NRA claims 2nd amendment rights to ensure that no government can control the populace, is it possible that the hidden agenda is more on the lines of a desire to keep control of the government.

    It is obvious to the most ill-informed that citizen's weapons are no match for the US military, however in a civil uprising it seems to me the overwhelmingly well-armed segment of society would probably identify as white Republican.

    If you can't keep control of a government through fair elections, you can try and manipulate the outcomes by lying, cheating, redistricting, stacking the Supreme Court in your favor, fixing voting machines, disenfranchising your opponents, suppressing the vote for your opponents, cancelling recounts, "misplacing" votes likely to be in favor of your opponents, tricking your opponents into missing the voting day or place, and probably other dirty tricks I haven't listed.

    If all that fails, isn't the last desperate attempt to retain control to be better armed than your opponents? I fear that despite not wanting to believe the reality of changing demographics, the Republicans know deep down that they can't retain control peacefully and are willing to resort to bloody violence if all else fails.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anonymous5:44 AM

    Pat Rovertson has the answer. His new "Evil Southern Strategy" (his words) calls for the GOP to pit white voters against the evil illegals (or, anyone not white) and demonize Hispanics. Voila. More paranoid whites come out to vote (only they won't) and the GOP regains control of the US.
    yeah, Pat, good luck. And happy afterlife. You aren't headed up.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous7:35 AM

    If the increasingly democratic voters aren't sufficiently present (and voting) in republican gerrymandered districts, we'll still have an ideological house, and ideological governors with ideological state houses writing voter suppression laws.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Anita Winecooler1:01 PM

    Good to hear! I doubt the wailing and gnashing of teeth over Benghazi and the evil IRS that's pervasive right now can hold up until the next election, but even if it does, the numbers don't lie. And add to this poll the hispanic vote turnout, and the constant obstruction... And it seems the GOP has a real problem ahead.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think they will do everything they can to stay in power, especially on the State level, where their influence on public law has been so virulently devastating. It will take a concerted effort to up root them.

    ReplyDelete

Don't feed the trolls!
It just goes directly to their thighs.