Sunday, November 23, 2014

Indianapolis Star runs racially insensitive comic, responds to criticism by removing character's mustache, before finally pulling the entire comic and apologizing for it.

Courtesy of Raw Story:  

Responding to criticism that a cartoon depicting undocumented immigrants coming through a window to share Thanksgiving dinner with a white family was racist, an Indiana newspaper edited out the stereotyped housebreaker’s mustache, ostensibly to make the cartoon seem less racist. 

The Indianapolis Star ran the cartoon by editorial cartoonist Gary Varvel showing a family coming in through the window to share in the holiday meal, with the house owner announcing to his family and guests, “Thanks to the president’s immigration order we’ll be having extra guests this Thanksgiving.”

In the original version up above the male character has a ball cap over his eyes and a rather prominent mustache, which suggest to many a Hispanic stereotype. After being mocked on Twitter the newspaper decided the best course was to remove the offending mustache.

See? All better.

Yeah, except it WASN'T all better and the outrage continued until the executive editor responded with this: 

On Friday, we posted a Gary Varvel cartoon at indystar.com that offended a wide group of readers. 

Many of them labeled it as racist. Gary did not intend to be racially insensitive in his attempt to express his strong views about President Barack Obama's decision to temporarily prevent the deportation of millions of immigrants living and working illegally in the United States. 

But we erred in publishing it.

Gee, ya think?

My favorite part of this story is that they really believed that the mustache was the problem, and not the showing of dark haired, clearly Hispanic, people invading the home of white people uninvited.

Which of course is exactly the kind of thing that fans the flames of racial hatred in this country.

19 comments:

  1. Anonymous6:45 AM

    If cartoonists and satirists start depicting Republicans with a KKK hood plopped on their heads would it be too insensitive? How about if we just take the KKK off the cap?

    Mildred

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anonymous7:31 AM

    What he depicted wasn't just racist, but it got to the heart of the matter, which is that some conservatives, who wear the cross necklaces and christian bling, don't necessarily emulate the Good Samaritan. They would have the rest of the world believe that they're nice white down-to-earth moral values folks who just love on the rest of the world enough to send troops and weapons to save the oil nations, but when it comes down to 'sharing' the good earth that they have over here, well..........what's mine is mine, and what's yours is mine, and go away, we're being thankful - leave us alone!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anonymous7:37 AM

    Every time that there is a post about immigration, we should remember Sarah Palin's rants about how those illegals are going to go stealing our jobs and taking advantage of our welfare system. Then, please remember Sarah's own biography where she described the Heath family sneaking across the border between Alaska and Canada in order to take advantage of Canada's free health care. Yes, when Sarah was a girl, taking something for nothing from another country was OK, especially since they sneaked back to the US.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous8:14 AM

      "Stealing jobs and taking advantage of our welfare system".

      Yes. They cover by reciting "give a man a fish and you feed him for a day; teach a man to fish and you feed him for a lifetime"

      Sounds good, right? Why is it all they want to do is send people packing without ever getting the chance to learn to fish? It's more like "I've got mine, now get out."

      Mildred

      Delete
    2. Anonymous8:28 AM

      I love it when dumbass reflexively racist and bigotted conservaturds like Sarah Palin inadvertently expose their massive hypocrisy for all to see. Way to go, Sarah!

      Delete
  4. Anonymous7:44 AM

    A better cartoon would have been pilgrims climbing into native American homes from back during the first Thanksgiving...
    Stupid twit of a racist. Sometimes I really hate Indiana (and I live here, ugh).

    ReplyDelete
  5. Randall8:12 AM

    Yes, yes indeed... THAT'S what the problem with immigration is:
    poor people are going to come and take YOUR stuff.

    The problem ISN'T that your boss insists YOU work harder and harder and longer hours with less and less vacation so that HE and THE SHAREHOLDERS can make more money.

    Oh no - that's the way it is SUPPOSED to be:
    the plantation owners reap the benefits of everyone else's labor. And if more scared, hungry, desperate people show up on the plantation well...
    They sure as hell aren't going to get any of THE MASTER's stuff. Oh NO! HIS money is sacrosanct.
    No... the tired, the poor, the huddled masses are going to steal part of YOUR share of the scraps that fall from THE MASTER's table.

    Don't believe it?

    Then just watch Fox News - where millionaires tell you all day long that it's other poor people that are the threat.

    OR read right-leaning newspapers that run comix that show Mexicans crawling through your window on Thanksgiving...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous8:29 AM

      What a great comment! I'm not really firing on all cylinders today, so I'll just say...

      ^ ^ ^ ^ THIS!

      Delete
    2. Anonymous9:57 AM

      The more they're able to focus attention on the poor, immigrants, LGBT people, minorities, etc, the less time anyone has to pay attention to them and how they're destroying this country.

      "Hey, look over there at those dirty, infected immigrants coming to steal all your stuff!!!

      Don't look at us taking all the corporate welfare your tax money is paying for and buying mansions, yachts and private islands!

      Don't pay any attention to us taking your low-wage jobs and sending them to other countries!

      Don't listen to anyone tell you how we're buying Congress and making them pass laws to benefit only us!

      It's all those immigrants who are causing the problems!!! Nothing to see here...honest! "

      Delete
  6. President Obama gave a beautiful and powerful address which laid out the case for immigration reform in terms which can not be contested by thoughtful persons.

    It was wonderful for our President to remind us, again, of the ideals of the United States.

    And now we're back to rascism as usual.

    I was criticized for saying I'm ashamed of my country.

    But I'll repeat it: I'm ashamed of my country.

    And no, I don't wish to leave. I wish to work fervently for the equality and justice and yes, compassion, we are founded on.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous8:24 AM

      Liz I,
      My sentiments exactly. Especially your last sentence.
      Thanks.

      Delete
    2. Yes, many of us have been ashamed for a long time, what a pity...I worked as an activist for many, many years, mainly for Nader, I could tell you stories you wouldn't believe, literally, it's a broken system, thats being kind

      Delete
    3. Anonymous10:08 AM

      I understand your shame and felt it deeply myself following this last election, but I ask that you remember that it's only a small - albeit very loud - minority who are so heartless, greedy and cruel. Unfortunately, they also seem to get the most media coverage.

      Even this last election showed that, while far too many people voted for the GOP candidates against their own interests, most supported the basic policies of the Democrats.

      There is much greater support for LGBT rights than ever before, and radical religious bills that take away women's rights are failing in even the most conservative states.

      While we all may be stinging from this most recent battle, there is hope that the hate-filled people who currently receive all the attention are slowly dying out and will continue to lose power and influence.

      Never as a child did I imagine seeing an African-American man in the White House. Now, as a 54-year-old, I can boast of voting for one, not once, but twice, AND watching him win.

      Delete
  7. Anonymous8:32 AM

    For his next cartoon, may I suggest an illustration of healthy Native Americans going about their business on both the east and west coasts of America when a ship full of diseased, starving Puritans people pulls into the east coast and a ship full of Conquistadors pulls into the west.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I live in Texas...I served with Hispanics, my neighbors are Hispanic, my co-workers and friends are Hispanic....so yes I have a thought and concern over this....Ted "Mr. Chinese Lawyer Traitor" Cruz is a dick. That simple, he is a dick, and a ferret face...never, ever, trust a ferret face

    ReplyDelete
  9. Anonymous8:54 AM

    I hear comments about Sarah's sharing of her family going to Canada for healthcare, in her book. It's implied the Heaths went there and got free health-care.

    I don't know if this is what she implied. But, it doesn't check out, because the Medicare system only treated taxpaying Canadian citizens. Others had to pay. Even myself, as a Canadian living in the U.S., having returned to Canada, had a 3-month waiting period.

    I know that our hospitals and clinics do charge non-Canadians for services. So, I don't know how the Heaths could have received free care coming in from Alaska. That just is not possible. Unless they lied about who they were and had fake ID's.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Boscoe10:25 AM

    Someone should doctor this cartoon so that the white family having dinner are Native Americans and Pilgrims are the ones coming in through the window...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Balzafiar11:19 AM

      Why? That's racist also. I don't buy the story that the artist didn't intend to offend anyone. Far better that the damned cartoon had never been drawn.

      Delete

Don't feed the trolls!
It just goes directly to their thighs.