Courtesy of Salon:
A federal judge on Tuesday denied Glenn Beck’s request to dismiss a libel lawsuit that accuses the conservative talking head of defaming a Saudi man Beck falsely accused of funding the Boston Marathon bombing last year.
As Josh Gerstein explains, Beck sought to have the lawsuit tossed out on the grounds that Abdulrahman Alharbi, the man who brought the suit, was a public figure because of his presence near the finish line of the marathon, where two bombs exploded, killing three people. As a public figure, Alharbi would have had to clear a difficult hurdle in order for the lawsuit to proceed, proving that Beck intentionally lied or acted with malice in making the accusations.
But in ruling that the lawsuit could move forward, U.S. District Judge Patti Saris rejected the argument that the mere act of attending the event made Alharbi a public figure.
“Choosing to attend a sporting event as one of thousands of spectators is not the kind of conduct that a reasonable person would expect to result in publicity,” she wrote. “Quite to the contrary, a spectator at an event like the Boston Marathon would reasonably expect to disappear into the throngs of others, never attracting notice by the press. Because he did not ‘assume the risk of publicity,’ Alharbi does not meet the definition of an involuntary public figure.”
Of course the argument could also be made that Beck essentially MADE Alharbi a public figure when he plucked him from obscurity and essentially blamed him for the terrorist attack.
For those who may not remember Beck claimed to have information from a government source and proceeded to completely manufacture a relationship between the innocent bystander and the Tsarnaev brothers:
The broadcaster eventually called Alharbi an al-Qaeda “control agent” and the “money man” behind the attacks. “You know who the Saudi is?” Beck asked. “He’s the money man. He’s the guy who paid for it.”
“Is this speculation or are you reporting something?” a co-host asked.
Beck ignored the question. “He’s the money man.”
I hope this Alharbi guy takes Beck for millions.
I so agree! I hope he cleans Beck's clock financially. Also, wish it would happen to Rush Limbaugh and Sarah Palin for all the crap and lies they have put out there regarding fellow Americans over the years!
ReplyDeleteI am sure Alharbi will win a large settlement. What Beck said about him was a big lie and indefensible.
ReplyDeleteI'm thinking this may be one of the reasons Beck was pushing the "I'm certifiably crazy" meme.
ReplyDeleteHell---all of the RWNJs are crazy. Now one of them has to eat his words.
That's exactly what I was going to post, about the brain problem he claims to have. Anyway, he should pick on someone from, say, Haiti, instead of from $$audi Arabia, lol.
Deletehttp://mediamatters.org/blog/2010/05/28/glenn-beck-smears-obamas-11-year-old-daughter/165466
DeleteMy guess is Beck will settle out of court for a lot of money ... and it will be wrapped in a confidentiality agreement.
ReplyDeleteHope the kid gets a few million.
the mentally ill who pray on dimwits. Hell has a special place for these asswipes. they'll have plenty of company.
ReplyDeleteIf I was the plaintiff, I would not settle out of court. I would want restitution to include a public on-air apology with a clear admittance that what Beck said, in its entirety was a lie. I'd ask for his job on a platter. AND I'd financially ruin him.
ReplyDeleteYes! Beck needs to PUBLICLY say that he lied about this poor man and that his assumptions were not based on facts, except the man "looks" like a "terrorist."
DeleteYep, I'd dig my heels in. No out of court, no gag order on anything, on air apology too.
DeleteEarthymama/Chicago
I like how you think!
DeleteThis plaintiff is not only fighting for the damage done to his own reputation, but he represents many other people who have been hurt by Beck who do not have the means or the evidence to sue him.
DeleteI wish him the best of luck and I hope the success of this case compensates him in some small measure for what he's been through, AND takes Beck out of the public eye for good.
Maybe it will make the other rightwingnuts pause a moment before spreading lies about innocent people.
Greatly looking forward to the many new 'weeping Glenn' pictures on Google Images after this
ReplyDeleteYou had your way,
now you must pay
I'm glad that you're sorry now.
http://youtu.be/APYeKa_WL_Q
I took a new path, turned right on a new road to the future. Sometimes new roads are good. May sit in on a R meetin. May turn MSNbc off due to loud mouth scars and meeka sounding like drunks. May just watch, listen and witness. Since mid term was zero and r is happy, gas is down, corp is giddy, tea is stale and all is calm. Pay attention folks, and get ready for 2016.
ReplyDeleteWait, What? Did I fall down the rabbit hole and it's christmas morning? Now we're going to hear "Beckghazi" for the next few months and beyond. The ONLY thing I hope is the kid gets a huge chunk of money and does something good for his education and life.
ReplyDeleteI know "it's been awhile", but once again, the Palin Curse raises it's ugly head with a "monster" energy drink in each hand.
life is good!
This contrition act(of late),is a setup vis-a-vis his defence team.........mark my words.......
ReplyDelete