A scheduled movie screening of “American Sniper” at the University of Michigan was abruptly cancelled Tuesday after nearly 300 students and others complained the film perpetuates “negative and misleading stereotypes” against Muslims.
“The movie American Sniper not only tolerates but promotes anti-Muslim … rhetoric and sympathizes with a mass killer,” according to an online letter circulated among the campus community via Google Docs that garnered the signatures.
The signers were mostly students, but also some staff, as well as the Muslim Students’ Association and the president of Students Allied for Freedom and Equality, a Palestinian solidarity group at UMich.
The online memo, titled a “collective letter from Middle Eastern and North African (MENA) and Muslim students on campus,” accused the public university of “tolerating dangerous anti-Muslim and anti-MENA propaganda” by showing the movie, the highest grossing film of 2014.
It follows U.S. Navy SEAL Chris Kyle, who served four combat tours in Operation Iraqi Freedom and was awarded two Silver Stars, five Bronze Stars with Valor, two Navy and Marine Corp Achievement Medals, and one Navy and Marine Corps commendation, according to his official Facebook page. But the protestors see him differently.
“Chris Kyle was a racist who took a disturbing stance on murdering Iraqi civilians,” the collective letter stated. “Middle Eastern characters in the film are not lent an ounce of humanity and watching this movie is provocative and unsafe to MENA and Muslim CollectiveLetter students who are too often reminded of how little the media and world values their lives. … The University of Michigan should not participate in further perpetuating these negative and misleading stereotypes.”
No wonder the Right Wing is always attacking institutions of higher learning, apparently these students are learning empathy and respect for people who are different from them and living in other countries.
How un-American of them.
Update: Well it looks like football trumps empathy at the University of Michigan.
Michigan Football will watch "American Sniper"! Proud of Chris Kyle & Proud to be an American & if that offends anybody then so be it!
— Coach Harbaugh (@CoachJim4UM) April 9, 2015
That tweet was from Michigan's head football coach Jim Harbaugh. And that seems to have changed everything: Shortly after that tweet was posted, the school announced they had backtracked on their original stance and will allow the film to be shown as scheduled.
The school put out a statement at 10:45 Wednesday night announcing the decision.
"The initial decision to cancel the movie was not consistent with the high value the University of Michigan places on freedom of expression and our respect for the right of students to make their own choices in such matters."
Well that is more than a little disappointing.
Updated--it's back on, cuz, uh, football and 'MERICA!!!:
ReplyDeletehttp://tinyurl.com/nl8sot9
Exactly. "Proud to be an American" in the context of this movie? What does that mean, exactly? You're proud to stand behind a psychopath who enjoyed blowing the heads off other human beings in the name of Rill Murica?
DeleteIf that's what American values are, then I'm ashamed to be an American.
I am Anon 7:25, and I wanted to clarify. I am not against the showing of this movie, because I think that is indeed freedom of speech.
DeleteWhat I was objecting to is the gloating way in which this coach expresses himself--I doubt he had any freedom in mind other than the freedom to use the movie's type of "patriotism" to stick it to the librul elite.
It's unbelievable that univeristy football coaches are paid millions of dollars all across the U.S., while university presidents earn (and I mean EARN) less than a tenth of what the coaches take home.
ReplyDeleteAnd how sad that a football coach is able to change a university administration's mind.......
The president of the Univ. of Michigan makes plenty of money as well but you are correct that coaches are indecently overpaid.
DeleteBeaglemom
So, what is the secondary decision consistent with, hmmm U of M?
ReplyDeleteEat a flaming sack of communist Russian dog-poop, Coach Dimwit Dickhead.
Screw the college president, compare the coach's salary with a professor's. Football is clearly much more important than academics. Not surprised the coach makes political decisions for the school.
ReplyDeleteColor me reactionary, but why are we cheering the censoring of stuff at universities? Or do we want to be like other countries and stop films we "don't like" from being shown? Why not burn a few books while we're at it? Maybe we should send some people to re-education camps?
ReplyDeleteYou don't have to like the movie, and you can disagree all day long with how it portrays this person or that, and show up to protest the film when it's shown, but to demand it not be shown is dangerous ground.
Thank you LisaB. My thoughts exactly.
DeleteCompletely agree with you Lisa
DeleteSheesh
It's a simple as - you don't have to watch the movie if you don't want to!!! I've not seen it because I have zero interest in it due to disliking war and killings.
DeleteExactly, Lisa.
DeleteAs a life long liberal and retired college professor, I am equally appalled by the movie and the idea of censoring it.
+1000
DeleteThanks Lisa. We can not censor. Ever! I have not seen the film. I don't care to see it. My husband did watch it. That was HIS right. I didn't throw some big ass fit and threaten to boycott him. He has just as much right to watch it as I did not to. By the way, he said it wasn't that good.
DeleteThink back on ALL of the shit that the fake xtians tried to get banned, stopped from being made or shown or written. Remember NYPD BLUE?
You know, red necks, fake xtians, conservative xtian, right wing republican, straight white Murican males, domestic terrorists, the KKK, the skinheads, etc., etc. need movies, t.v. shows and books (books? okay, maybe that's a stretch) that they like too.
This^^^^^
DeleteRemember, embassies were closed because the Dutch government refused to censor cartoons. Yale buckled under fear and refused to reprint "offensive" cartoons. Death threats are made if someone accidentally throws a Koran in a rubbish bin.
Let them protest outside the movie theater. I assure you the backlash will be an eye opener. It will not work. It has never worked.
Walking on eggshells around all these butt hurt "peaceful Muslims" has grown tiresome.
It's a cartoon. A fucking cartoon. It's a movie. A fucking movie. It's a book. A fucking book.
Get a fucking grip.
The movie offends you don't watch it
ReplyDeleteCollege. Freedom to view -- or not. I would object only if there was a pattern of favoring one worldview over all others.
ReplyDeleteWill I do agree that, in general, the anti-Muslim outlook of this country is a disgrace, still: Freedom!
I have mixed feelings about a movie ban on a campus, but Harbaugh comes across as an ass. I shall be pulling against Michigan football in the future.
ReplyDeleteI've always rooted against Michigan, BillF, and Harbaugh is one of the biggest @ssholes around.
DeleteAs someone with pretty low standards about what is 'watchable', gotta say that "American Sniper" totally sucked as far as movies go.
ReplyDeleteIt was less interesting than an episode of "Storage Wars" or that pawn shop show (Yes, I watch that crap, but even with MY low bar for watchability, that movie blew.).
I thought "The Hurt Locker" sucked too, so I'm not being partisan.
I agree with everything regarding that terrible movie..however, I do not think they should cancel it..if you are offended, don't go..Too many people lose sight of the fact that if you want freedom, so have to be prepared to give same...I worked many issues I had felt were worthy of consideration, even though I wasn't fond of it, but my goal in life is good karma and not being a hypocrite in my ramblings...
ReplyDelete7:02 AM, Unbelievable. It doesn't say much for our standards.
ReplyDeleteOT APRIL 8, 2015
Bristol Palin pregnant for the second time?!
Bristol Palin — former Vice President select Sarah Palin’s daughter — seems to be rushing down the aisle with Metal of Honor recipient Sgt. Dakota Meyer. Following a short 6 month relationship she seems ready to be a blushing bride. Just 4 weeks ago Bristol posted to her Instagram account, “Truly the luckiest girl in the world, cannot wait to marry this man!!!!!” followed by a shot of her gorgeous new bling. The following week she uploaded a photo with the hash tags #wedding prep and #two months. We did the math and this puts her wedding date around May 9th, 2015!
The question still remains…
http://celebthirty.com/2015/04/08/bristol-palin-pregnant-for-the-second-time/
I agree with LisaB and others who say the film should not be censored. But I also commend those who complained and highlighted what was wrong with this film. Intelligent people can make up their own minds, but at least they have the information about why many people are offended by the film.
ReplyDeleteThe disparity between coaches' pay and professors' pay is equally offensive.
I'm surprised to read that G and IM commenters support censorship on a university campus.
ReplyDeleteWhat would happen if it was a right-wing student group protesting the screening of a movie they considered anti-American, anti-military, or anti-christian?
Well I am not sure I buy the censorship argument. After all nobody is suggesting that the DVD of this film not be included in the University library to be checked out by students at their leisure.
DeleteHowever showing this movie on campus, which appears to be a weekly event, is tantamount to the University endorsing its content.
The students who signed the petition clearly felt that this was insulting to certain students on the campus, and insensitive to certain ethnic groups who were portrayed in the film as terrorists. And may have been concerned with an uptick in violence or aggression toward Arab and Muslim students afterward.
If the movie were "Straw Dogs" which graphically depicts the rape of a young wife, who is then shown to be aroused by the incident, before she is brutalized by a second man, I would fully expect many of the female students to write a protest letter and try to get it pulled as well. And I would empathize with their feelings, and support that decision.
Don't forget these movies can inspire or reinforce negative stereotypes which can then cause problems for certain segments of the student population later.
I should also mention that I am perfectly fine with the movie being shown in a classroom, with a discussion period afterward.
DeleteThis is clearly a controversial movie that would inspire a lot of debate and interesting conversation.
I think it is the idea of it being shown as entertainment on a campus that I find so repellent.
Personally I find the old James Bond movies repellent.
Delete"However showing this movie on campus, which appears to be a weekly event, is tantamount to the University endorsing its content. "
DeleteAbsolutely not. And I'd like to point out that this is precisely the argument that Hobby Lobby used to refuse to provide contraceptive coverage. I seem to remember you were on the side of "people should make up their own minds" and "your beliefs shouldn't trump my rights."
Stupid college students and their stupid idealistic petitions. They are trying to what, censor themselves?
DeleteIf you don't like a movie, don't watch it.
ReplyDeleteIf you are against gay marriage, don't marry a gay person.
If you are pro-life, don't have an abortion.
WTH is so hard to understand about EQUAL rights for all?
JJ
JJ...Thank you!
DeleteI don't get what the big deal is about this movie at all, and why people like Gryph are making such hay about it honestly. It is a stupid Hollywood movie with some stupid big name "actors". I usually don't like movies "supposedly" based on real events, esp regarding soldiers, because they are boring.... and probably only 5% even slightly based on reality.
DeleteAlthough many people see the film as an homage to a hero, it doesn't have to be viewed that way. When I saw the movie, I was repelled by the movie character Chris Keil, who bears a lot of similarity to the actual person. It's okay to see movies with unsavoury main characters, fictitious or based on reality.
ReplyDeleteJust curious: Was the Coach proud enough of America to have served?
ReplyDeleteJust curious, is that a requirement to be proud of America, or are you just a stupid liberal?
DeleteI can't believe a Palin can sleep through this. "American Sniper" is her favorite. Her son fought for freedoms. How can she ignore this?
ReplyDeleteThis will wake up old what's her name. She can give one of those talks where she sits in front of her favorite prop and show everyone how up to date and relevant she is.
http://theimmoralminority.blogspot.com/2015/04/president-obama-calls-for-end-to.html
Special place
http://a57.foxnews.com/media2.foxnews.com/2015/04/03/640/360/040315_ff_meyer_640.jpg
Where is Sarah?
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CCH4vRUUgAE_Sjx.jpg:large
I'm one who doesn't buy into censorship, but I highly recommend watching "American Psycho" on DVD instead. I'm juest curious, are they going to have a discussion after the movie? Will it be part of some lesson plan? Or just shown to fill seats/make money/ drum up controversy? I'd rather it be used for educational purposes more than entertainment.
ReplyDeleteWell nobody cares what you would 'rather' have done. It is a stupid Hollywood movie. Why do you need a discussion after a stupid Hollywood movie? Jesus. It is a fucking movie.
DeleteHarbaugh. A new reason to despise U of M.
ReplyDeleteMichigan State all the way - Go GREEN!
Maybe a bit OT, but the US government is the single largest employer of psychologists. The reason? People have to be brainwashed into believe that there are good reasons to kill other people.
ReplyDeleteIt's tempting to think that it's easier to train stupid people to do this, but their fiendishly systematic methods work even on smart people.
And even stupid people can end up being portrayed as heroes.
Fuck this movie and fuck Chris Kyle.
ReplyDelete