From ADN:
Mayor Dan Sullivan on Tuesday vetoed an Assembly-approved city ordinance that made it clear on-duty Anchorage firefighters could ethically take part in an annual charity fundraiser, the Muscular Dystrophy Association of Alaska's fill-the-boot campaign.
In his veto message, Sullivan said the ordinance results in an expectation that the Assembly or mayor will give permission to use municipal resources to one group but not another.
"It will create a competitive, pressure environment where private parties, including charitable nonprofits, will feel compelled to lobby Assembly member and the mayor," he said, and that raises questions about fairness.
Sullivan also referred to the ethics ordinance passed while he was an Assembly member, in 2007, saying the Assembly at that time decided the best policy was to prohibit use of on-duty personnel and equipment from being used for private purposes.
"As public officials we have an obligation to ensure that taxpayer dollars are only used for legitimate government purposes," he said.
The mayor said his administration will make its own revisions to clarify the ethics ordinance. He said use of city resources for events such as parades and festivals would still be allowed in most circumstances.
Assembly member Elvi Gray- Jackson, a main backer of allowing on-duty firefighters to continue with their traditional fundraising effort, said she would try to get the Assembly to override the veto. But that takes eight votes, and she's not sure eight of the 11 Assembly members will go along.
She noted Sullivan has used his veto power regularly, and said, "I can't believe he's continuing with his power trip."
Assembly chairman Dick Traini said he supports a veto override. "The public needs to have this, the kids who suffer from muscular dystrophy need this."
Okay a couple of things. Firstly this is a very popular and effective method of gathering donations for MDA. I have seen the firefighters running around at stoplights for years while holding out a boot for people to put money into, and watched as delighted commuters dug deep and handed over the cash with big smiles on their faces. The only concern I have ever heard voiced is that one of the firemen might get hit by a car accidentally. In 55 years it has never happened, but hey if it did they have plenty of trained emergency responders only a few feet away.
Secondly though these guys are technically on duty, the fundraising does NOT interfere with their ability to respond to an emergency. They are suited up and ready to roll, probably even faster than if they were just sitting around the fire station cleaning their hoses.
Thirdly, if Sullivan's veto holds that will mean that Anchorage will be just about the only city in Alaska NOT participating this year. How does that make us look to the rest of our community?
Fourthly, this has NOTHING to do with saving tax money,or showing fairness, and EVERYTHING to do with vindictiveness. Sullivan is still pissed that the Firefighters Union did not endorse his candidacy and, just like his mentor Sarah Palin, he holds a grudge and punishes those who dare to slight him.
Of course like the coward that he is, that means Sullivan will target the children suffering with a debilitating disease to teach the firefighters a lesson.
This guy is some piece of work isn't he? I certainly hope that the citizens of Anchorage have learned their lesson and will use much better judgement in the future when we elect out city leaders. Because, honestly, this is fucking embarrassing!
You poor Alaskans really are cursed.
ReplyDelete"As public officials we have an obligation to ensure that taxpayer dollars are only used for legitimate government purposes," he said.
ReplyDeleteLike his dad's "life insurance" payout.
When will Mayor Sullivan's term be up? Is there anyone opposed to his policies with more intelligence and compassion available to run against him?
ReplyDeleteNo offense intended and I'm quite appalled by Dan Sullivan, but various cities in the Pacific NW discontinued the Boot fundraiser in busy traffic areas a number of years ago.
ReplyDeleteNot only would Anchorage be the only city in Alaska not participating, they would be the only city in the entire United States not doing so. This is something the firefighters look forward to and plan for all year long. They take great pride in participating in this fund raiser and this is their favorite national charity. I have an ex-husband, four brothers-in-law, five nephews and a son who are all firefighters and they would all drag themselves off their death-beds to be part of this annual event. This poor excuse for a man and a Mayor should be greatly ashamed of himself. Fortunately for him, the firefighters will still respond if his home should ever be on fire. What a doofus...
ReplyDeleteIf you can't find a cure after, what, 55 years, I don't think that there is going to be one. I think that the MDA telethon is a scam. How much of the money that is raised actually goes to research? This organization needs to be investigated. Think about it. . . it's a cash cow for someone. I have sympathy for those with the disease but raising money after 55 years is just not getting anything accomplished.
ReplyDeleteAny news on the investigation into the insurance policy payout Sullivan received? And also the one that costs $50K to ensure the budget was honest that Begich passed on to him.
ReplyDelete(BTW, I miss his party girl antics!)
Alaska you have my condolences...you definitely aren't in Kansas anymore!
According to wikipedia the MDA telethon has been broadcasted nationally since 1966. It has raised over 1.46 billion dollars since its inception. Why hasn't there been a cure yet for this disease? In 2008, $65 million was raised, which was the year with the largest amount raised.
ReplyDeleteIt probably goes psychological deeper than that. Sully may be jealous that women think firefighters are hot. :-)
ReplyDeleteGryphen, I agree with everything you said. I will miss seeing the firemen; this was one of the highlights of what a fine city we are. I'm glad I didn't vote for this man. I met him a few weeks prior to the election, and I didn't like the way he was checking me out. What a slime.
what ever became of Dan Sullivan and his little affair. He may have weathered and waited this one out
ReplyDeleteSullivan must have learned from Palin that, if you don't have to donate to charity openly, you don't have to donate at all!
ReplyDeleteAnonymous at 6:16 and 6:43 -
ReplyDeleteThere are many, many different forms of MD and related neuro-muscular diseases which makes it that much harder to find a 'cure'. I am sure that the families who are dealing with this horrible disease wish that a cure could have been found years ago, but medical research of this type takes more time than any of us would like. Sadly, many forms of MD affect children and young adults who have only begun their lives.
I know - make that KNEW - numerous children who lost their lives to this disease and I am quite sure that their families would not support your willingness to just give up since a cure has not been found yet. This disease often runs in families so, once a child has been diagnosed, it is not uncommon for a sibling to be diagnosed as well. Then the younger child must watch their older brother or sister grow progressively weaker and eventually die, knowing that they're looking at their own future. I know of at least three families who have experienced this very thing and I cannot imagine the agony it must cause.
Great progress has been made but, unfortunately, a cure is still a long way off. Yes, it takes vast quantities of money and time, but if your child was facing an inevitable, excruciating death, I certainly hope you would not be so flippant about raising money to fight this killer.
I don't like panhandlers coming to my car.
ReplyDeleteI see both sides to this. No easy solutions.
ReplyDeleteone person wrote that over $1.46B has been donated over the years and wants to know why no cure yet. Hell, we spend a billion a day still in Afghanistan and still no cure. See it isn't always money that is the cure. Time is the culprit when it comes to medical. It's always the biggest problem. Diseases take time to isolate. With DNA testing now, maybe it will come sooner. But the damn wars keep going on with no end in site. I'd rather spend money on medicine than wars.
ReplyDeleteTo the Anon who said there has been no cure in 55 years... MDA is not a scam. First, there is no ONE muscular dystrophy. There are about 50 muscular dystrophies and peripheral neuropathies under the "umbrella." Some are more obvious than others, and because so many people are affected by these diseases chances are you know someone who is affected. They might not take advantage of the services MDA has to offer, but all will benefit from the ultimate "cures."
ReplyDeleteI first saw an MDA doctor when I was 9 year old in Southern CA. Many years later my son saw the same doctor in Northern California. Though we are blessed in that our condition is less severe than others, MDA services are much needed and cover a gap in our gold standard insurance (pre-existing condition.) My kids and I have had leg orthotics made that our insurance would not cover and that we could not afford. They have done neuro-testing to see how far the disease is progressing. My kids, when old enough to go to an away camp, will be able to spend a week around other kids like them. They'll feel NORMAL for once. MDA has provided annual check-ups and letters for my kiddos' schools to explain their conditions and make sure the PE programs are adapted to meet their needs. These are just some things off the top of my head. Oh, and they were the ones who caught that I had a disc herniation compressing my spinal cord when all other doctors for 18 months had said it was my neuromuscular disease. The doctor was visibly upset, excused himself from the room, got on the phone with my GP, and I could hear him from down the hall. I had an MRI scheduled by my GP and aproved by my insurane *the next day.* LOL
They have Neurologists, Occupational Therapists, Physical Therapists, Therapists and Social Workers for yearly visits or more often for those without insurance or with greater need.
MDA has the best scientists working on these diseases, and the "best hope" so far is gene recombinant therapy. Essentially you isolate the genes that cause the disease and substitute unaltered gene sequences (healthy ones) in their place. I'd have to look up how the reconfigured DNA is replicated within the body. They have made HUGE strides with this.
Consider also gene therapy is only one facet of their research. Because of MDA people who suffer from a multitude of muscular dystrophies have had their life expectacies increased and their quality of life improved. I speak from personal experience.
So no, its not a scam, and is a program you can feel happy donating your spare change to.
My community also discontinued the "roadblock" type filling the boot several years ago. There was an uproar at the time, but now our firefighters set up outside several local grocery stores. They do just as well and have the added benefit of not worrying about staying safe in the traffic. Good trade-off, I think.
ReplyDeletePeople who don't like panhandlers coming to their car...do you like firefighters coming to your house when it's on fire?
ReplyDeleteNobody is going to attack you if you haven't got any change.
That's Danny "$193K" Sullivan to you, buddy!
ReplyDeleteYeah, and to those morons who say after 55 years there's no cure: Have you ever watched the telethon? They announce a lot of the accomplishments of the research.
Is Mr. Sullivan's picture one of those preppy mug shots?
ReplyDeleteWhat's to stop us (the citizens of Anchorage) from dropping by our local fire station and donating to MDA? Maybe with enough support, we can really show the mayor and the FD where the people of Anchorage stand.
ReplyDeleteMDA gives 16 cents on the dollar for research. That is a pretty poor rating for a charitable organization.
ReplyDelete"Organizational Efficiency
Program Expenses 78.2%
Administrative Expenses 7.5%
Fundraising Expenses 14.1%
Fundraising Efficiency $0.16 "
Give your money to someone else. You can get ratings for charitable organizations online at http://www.charitynavigator.org/
from a real Alaskan who gives money to those who help others
I do feel sorry for you Alaskans, but please...
ReplyDeletekeep the likes of Sullivan and Palin up there in your state, instead of exporting them down here. We have enough problems without idiots like them.
Thank you.