Thursday, July 17, 2014

Here's a shocker, recent study shows that purity pledges do not work. Or at least not for long.


Courtesy of Salon:  

Great/horrible news for proponents of comprehensive sex education: virginity pledges don’t work, according to science. That is, they don’t work unless signers are truly and deeply religious, in which case abstinence pledges are likely to delay sexual activity a few years — but usually not until marriage. A recent study published in the Journal of Child and Family Studies has found that the efficacy of virginity pledges is not only associated directly with signers’ religiosity, but also poses serious risks to young adults who go back on their word. 

To evaluate what role religious commitment played in young adults’ adherence to virginity pledges, researchers polled 1,380 college students aged 18-24 who attended a “large, public, Southeastern state university,” asking participants whether they had previously signed a virginity pledge, their virginity status and how many past or present intercourse and oral sex partners they had. Researchers also asked students to rate their religious commitment, based on how religion or spirituality influence their daily lives, how often they seek spiritual comfort and how frequently they participate in religious events. 

More than a quarter of respondents had previously made a virginity agreement, either in writing or verbally, which is consistent with national averages; according to a 2008 study of pledge signers, 23.8 percent of adolescents aged 12-17 had agreed to remain abstinent. A majority of signers, however, were — wait for it — no longer virgins at the time of the study. 65 percent of respondents who had signed a virginity pledge reported having had sexual intercourse, and a whopping 77 percent of signers had engaged in oral sex. 

For the most part, though, those who were having oral sex or full-on coitus were also the people with lower rates of religious commitment, indicating that sincere religious belief does play a role in a person’s dedication to remaining abstinent. The researchers differentiated between “religious commitment” and “religious participation” to control for those who might have been immersed in a spiritual lifestyle without being true believers themselves; sure enough, people who were solely “religious participants” exhibited more sexual behavior than committed believers.

Okay that last part might be true, or it might simply be that those who self identify as "religiously committed" are more likely to lie about their sexual activities.

Ya think?

In my experience the girls that were the most religious and goody two shoes were the ones that went the wildest in college. That is unless the college they attended was also super religious and oppressive and they continued to be browbeaten into submission until they graduated and THEN they went wild.

In my opinion losing your virginity should not have such a stigma attached to it, because then what happens is that the focus on its importance almost invariably makes the first time full of stress and more often than not incredibly disappointing.

Yes there are great love stories out in the world concerning high school sweethearts who waited to get married, were each others first and only, and who have marriages that have endured the test of time.

However those stories are few and far between these days.

Teaching young ladies that sexuality is perfectly normal, and that taking precautions to prevent disease and unwanted pregnancy, while choosing their partners wisely seems to me the best approach.

But then again I also do not believe I will burn in the eternal fires of hell for thinking impure thoughts or for coveting my neighbor's wife, so perhaps my perspective is little skewed from that of somebody who thinks that fumbling around with an inexperienced girl to take her virginity is a "gift."

Now hot sweaty, clothes rending, wild monkey sex with an experienced woman? Now THAT'S a gift.

11 comments:

  1. Anonymous2:57 PM

    Years ago, I was bored and channel surfed across a Maury show focusing on girls who vowed to remain virgins and they were doing everything under the sun BUT. It's the biggest drive there is and, quite frankly, making that pledge to your father is downright creepy if not offensive. It's none of his business, and what's next? Telling you who you can and cannot marry? All I see is a catalyst for future controlling behavior, perhaps lifelong. Married or not.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Gryphen, you can't post photos if your sweaty, be-muscled self and then talk about things like wild monkey sex. You're making ME think impure thoughts! (How many Hail Marys for Thinking Impure Thoughts About Alaskan Blogger? Zero? Good. I can handle that.)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous4:06 PM

      Nyah, if you watch "Sarah Palin: You Betcha!" on YT, you can feast your eyes on him and, believe you me, he's VERY easy on the eyes!

      Delete
  3. Anonymous3:52 PM

    Todd gave one of those to Bristol. Joey likes that she wears it as a nipple ring.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Seriously- back in the day when I was in high school, anybody who made a promise like that- supposing that he or she was stupid enough to make the matter known- that person would have been a TOTAL TARGET.

    I really don't care who is having sex or not. I don't think most people do. But advertising your status in that goody-two-shoes way? You're just asking to be set up.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Randall4:49 PM

    I think I'm probably going to Heck
    because I don't believe in Gosh
    or
    Cheese and crackers got all muddy.

    Ramen

    ReplyDelete
  6. Anonymous5:25 PM

    when i was a teen, the guy's i hung with at high school, we only dated and laid the chicks from the catholic all girls school, they were so easy i still love those little uniforms they wore

    ReplyDelete
  7. Anita Winecooler5:46 PM

    This entire concept gives me the "creep" factor. The girls get all dressed up, the fathers wear their sunday best. and expect their daughters to "pledge" they won't have sex. Sounds like an excuse for envelopes with money in them or quasi marrying your own dad.

    Well, this study proves what my mother told us when we were teens. "Virginity is like a bubble, one prick and it's all over". And I was a "good" catholic girl and waited for marriage. "Hey, someone, somewhere's getting married, right"?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous6:05 PM

      For Bristol, the money came later. Mommie Dearest's grand entrance into international fame. How's that workin' for 'em?

      Delete
  8. Anonymous5:52 PM

    Apparently they did not ask about anal sex. Other studies have shown that girls who took the virginity pledge often engaged in anal sex because it was not really "sex." Since their knowledge of sex was so limited, they often ended up with anal STDs and other problems. Ignorance is never good.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Anonymous9:03 AM

    My husband and I did not have intercourse in the seven years we dated before we married, but we did almost everything BUT. I think I passed a fertilized egg on month during my period (heavens, Todd Akin will arrest me for murder!!) and that scared the crap out of me...I was finishing college and was no way ready to parent. Instead of forcing girls to feel guilty (young men will never stop pressing them for sex anyway!) why not teach them safe ways to express their feelings? I knew nothing. My big teaching moment was when my mom said, "If you come home pregnant, I'll kick you out." Nothing about how to avoid pregnancy, nothing. And this from a woman who had me, an 8 and a half pound baby, a mere 8 3/4 months after she and my dad married. She's fortunate that only one of us six actually did have to get married due to a pregnancy. Between us, there are four divorces (two by one sister,) 10 grandkids, and seven great-grands so far. Three of us have been married more than thirty years. And only two of us were dragged to church by our grandma.

    ReplyDelete

Don't feed the trolls!
It just goes directly to their thighs.