Americans who live abroad -- more than six million of us worldwide (not counting those who work for the U.S. government) -- often face hard questions about our country from people we live among. Europeans, Asians, and Africans ask us to explain everything that baffles them about the increasingly odd and troubling conduct of the United States. Polite people, normally reluctant to risk offending a guest, complain that America’s trigger-happiness, cutthroat free-marketeering, and “exceptionality” have gone on for too long to be considered just an adolescent phase. Which means that we Americans abroad are regularly asked to account for the behavior of our rebranded “homeland,” now conspicuously in decline and increasingly out of step with the rest of the world.
In my long nomadic life, I’ve had the good fortune to live, work, or travel in all but a handful of countries on this planet. I’ve been to both poles and a great many places in between, and nosy as I am, I’ve talked with people all along the way. I still remember a time when to be an American was to be envied. The country where I grew up after World War II seemed to be respected and admired around the world for way too many reasons to go into here.
That’s changed, of course. Even after the invasion of Iraq in 2003, I still met people -- in the Middle East, no less -- willing to withhold judgment on the U.S. Many thought that the Supreme Court’s installation of George W. Bush as president was a blunder American voters would correct in the election of 2004. His return to office truly spelled the end of America as the world had known it. Bush had started a war, opposed by the entire world, because he wanted to and he could. A majority of Americans supported him. And that was when all the uncomfortable questions really began.
Yeah you know after the election of 2004 I too thought that we must be crazy.
Here are a few of the questions that the author, Ann Jones, has been asked over the years:
- Why can’t you Americans stop interfering with women’s health care?
- Why can’t you understand science?
- How can you still be so blind to the reality of climate change?
- How can you speak of the rule of law when your presidents break international laws to make war whenever they want?
- How can you hand over the power to blow up the planet to one lone, ordinary man?
- How can you throw away the Geneva Conventions and your principles to advocate torture?
- Why do you Americans like guns so much? Why do you kill each other at such a rate?
- To many, the most baffling and important question of all is: Why do you send your military all over the world to stir up more and more trouble for all of us?
You know in our defense I would like to suggest that America is not so much crazy, as it is schizophrenic. In many ways we are quite a reasonable, intelligent, progressive nation.
However sometimes we hear voices whispering in the dark. And those voices are not quite as reasonable, intelligent, nor progressive.
I call those voices "Republicans," and it seems to be that more and more these days they act like the Joker in "The Dark Knight" movie. And by that I mean, as Alfred Pennyworth explains, some men just want to watch the world burn.
So is America crazy?
Not always. But sometimes, yes most definitely.
Oh Gryphen-"I call those voices "Republicans," and it seems to be that more and more they act like the Joker in "The Dark Knight." And by that I mean some men just want to watch the world burn. " I fear you are right.
ReplyDeleteThe problem with America is that it's a primarily a for profit country. Human welfare is not paramount. Corporate welfare (in both senses of the word) is. Add to the latter the opportunistic Christianist tune that all Republican politicians and too many Democratic politicians dance to, and it's a total recipe for disaster.
ReplyDeleteWord. You nailed it. I hate it, but you nailed it.
DeleteCrazy as the US is, it is still the best country in the world in my book. Yeah we got some problems. But we are one election away from solving a lot of those problems if the Dems come out to vote in 2016.
ReplyDeleteCaroll, TROTW (The Rest Of The World) surely hopes you're right.
Delete(Signed) your next-door neighbour
Like we were in 2008?
DeleteI have thought that every election since gwb (sic) got selected by the SCOTUS. And each election, I get disappointed. (Not with our President, but with the rest of the elected officials.)
DeleteI am troubled by the people who do not vote. Most folks that vote R come out and vote, but not people who would vote D. The poor, minorities, young people and people who feel disenfranchised think that their vote won't make a difference. What they fail to realize is that their vote will make ALL the difference in the world.
DeleteIf everyone who was eligible voted, our country would look a whole lot better than it does today.
Carroll are you implying that the D's own the votes of all poor, minorities, and young people? Those groups don't get a choice of who to vote for?
DeleteI disagree, 3:06 PM. As a Permanent Resident in this country, I was transfered here when Clinton was president. At that time it was quite nice, but I would not call it the greatest country in the world.
DeleteAnd now it's just sad. As someone with two citizenships (not US) I have options regarding where I work and therefore where I live. However, my partner, a wonderful person and an American, does not. So we will wait until we retire (or it becomes so bad that we MUST leave) before moving to another country. Seeing what the US has become, I cannot wait to leave.
Why do people complain about this country? If you're responsible, independent minded, and resourceful, there is ZERO reason you can't make a great living and do what you've dreamed of.
ReplyDeleteWHINEY babies
Didn't you read the graphic at the top?
DeleteThe issues at hand on this post are not about "making a great living"
It's easy for someone with a reasonable degree of drive, decent health, and a few brains to get ahead, no doubt about that. I am grateful to live here in the USA, and have been able to benefit a lot. That's not the whole story though.
The foundation of our country's monetary system is capitalism, and the inequity and wealth gap is utterly startling, and thousands live in unimaginable luxury, while others literally die in the street from lack of health care.
There is a REASON that we make incisive criticisms of America, and elect people we hope will make changes, and that's because not everyone is born able to take advantage of the great life that some of us have here.
Yes, we have all the liberties that the Constitution affords us, but we also have many problems.
Denying that is like $arah Palin claiming how we are so exceptional because god.
Did you ever hear this famous Quote?
"There’s absolutely no evidence to support the statement that we’re the greatest country in the world.
We’re 7th in literacy, 27th in math, 22nd in science
We're 49th in life expectancy, 178th in infant mortality, 3rd in median household income, number 4 in labor force and number 4 in exports.
We lead the world in only three categories: number of incarcerated citizens per capita, number of adults who believe angels are real and defense spending, where we spend more than the next 26 countries combined, 25 of whom are allies.
Ponder how the "greatest" nation on earth could have be 7th in literacy, 27th in math, 22nd in science
Ponder how we could have higher infant mortality than
Greece, Cuba, or Croatia.
https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2091rank.html
For the complete read, check out
(Source for 1st quote)
https://www.goodreads.com/work/quotes/23633463-the-newsroom-script-episode-1
What a dishonest, self-serving post. Claims like yours are so easy to make when you are a member of the power group, which you, with your elitist, non-empathetic attitude, so clearly are. Try being born, raised, and educated in poverty with a brown or black skin, say a town like Ferguson, MO, then come back and tell us how far being responsible, resourceful, and open-minded get you.
Delete1% er...
DeleteYou know it is funny.... 3:17 writes a positive post about this country and the fact that there is great opportunity here for those willing to put in the effort, and you all can't handle it. Doesn't fit the agenda apparently. Energy spent complaining and whining rather than spent on working towards success.
DeleteBravo 3:17.
4:29
DeleteYou just outed yourself as a simpleton. Bravo!
Oh and that is why Cambridge picked Sarah they want to see the KKKRAzY in person!
DeleteKeep yappin' 4:52. It is easier than working for personal pride and success eh? Blame others!
Delete4:52 PM, 5:20 PM, you both just exemplified something that is really wrong with the US. People can no longer see gray. Everything must be black and white. Some one must be wrong and someone must be right. "You're either for us or against us." There is no dialogue, no nuance, no introspection, no openess to other ideas. Just two sides shouting at each other only hearing what reinforces their own bias.
Delete6:36 how is believing that every individual has opportunity to be successfull in any way 'for us or against us'? It is a positive notion, and it applies to anyone that strives for it.
DeleteAnonymous7:04 PM, my comment was referring to the REACTION to each others' comments not the original comment. That's why I called out the two timepoints I did, and did not disagree with 4:29.
DeleteSo, Rosie Odonnell says exactly what Sarah said basically and she is ignored, yet Sarah is an obama hater
ReplyDeleteAll Sarah did with that fb post was post a link and comment on it, what you all do on a daily basis .Except YOU lie
Are you lost? This post isn't about Sarah or Rosie or…oh just go take your meds.
DeleteRosie O'Donnell isn't a reflexive Obama hater. When she offers criticism, it's well-reasoned and informed. Sarah Palin OTOH is a reflexive Obama hater. Had he gone to Paris and participated in that farce of a leaders' march, Palin would have ripped him for THAT. That's all Palin does. Crack on Obama. No matter what it is that he does. No reasoning is ever performed by Palin. It's just a total knee-jerk, unthinking reaction.
DeleteWe know it. You know it too.
NEXT!
Gryphen is a lot of things 3:18, but a liar is not one of them. And what has Rosie O'Donnell got to do with this post anyway.
DeleteHave another drink and forget all about it.
All Sarah did with that fb post was post a link and comment on it, what you all do on a daily basis .Except YOU lie
Delete-----
Whiner! "You LIE" are you fucking two years old?
Put down the methpipe!
Anonymous3:33 PM,
DeleteIt seems it's OK to post off topic on thse commentsas long as it bashes Palin.
Anonymous5:02 PM
DeleteJudging by your reaction to a comment, it seems you're quite familiar with the methpipe!
ot
ReplyDeleteWhat a tear jerking sad story. Fox may be more victim than Kween Esther
Fox News Plays Victim Card, Accuses Dish Network Of ‘Censoring’ Them (VIDEO)
http://www.addictinginfo.org/2015/01/12/fox-news-plays-victim-card-accuses-dish-network-of-censoring-them-video/
No offence to my fellow readers, but I would argue that in the face of its self-professed "greatness," such inconvenient and contravening facts depict America for what it is at this juncture in history. That is, as one of the most fucked-up and self-delusional countries on the face of the planet.
ReplyDelete+1!
DeleteCongratulations, you won the internet today! Thanks for playing!
DeleteIs the U.S. government crazy? That's putting it mildly.
ReplyDeleteorlin sellers
Are they reptiles from another realm orlin? Do you stockpile 'survival seeds'?
DeleteAnonymous3:41 PM
DeleteIs the U.S. government crazy? That's putting it mildly.
orlin sellers
____
Yes especially the baggers/Repub Congress & Senate!
Crazy is putting it nicely they are treasonous pices of shit!
I must say that in the last ten years, that question has entered my mind more often than not. America is my adopted country - my home country by choice. However, I am very close to abandon it for a different, much less oppressive, much less beligerent country.
ReplyDeleteI feel this way sometimes and I was born here!
DeleteAnonymous 5:58 PM:
DeleteYou and me both!
DON'T GIVE UP! America may yet be able to prosecute the bad guy criminals and war mongers. Make room for the worst and release the ones that need a helping hand.
ReplyDeleteThe truth about Sarah Palin's combat vet son can be told. It's coming! Sony hack job was nothing.
http://www.mediaite.com/tv/gop-rep-suggests-centcom-hack-committed-by-radical-islamists-within-u-s-military/
I’ve been abroad several times and stayed long enough for most of these questions. The one that is most asked is about our military. We are seen as invaders, not in the best light. And this is among people of all political belief or religion. We have a serious problem in the rest of the world. Our purpose is not seen as “exporting democracy” or bringing freedom to people, we are seen as self-interested invaders in most situations. Since World War II a lot of us have refused to see the world has become more educated, is a lot more aware of other cultures and know a great deal more about other countries' political struggles and history than the typical American knows about its own. We have tolerated a lack of curiosity about the world among our citizens that borders on ignorance. Ignorance and hubris is a volatile mix that will get us in further trouble if we don’t rein it in. I find it terrifying when I listen to people who don’t even have a passport ramble on as if they know what people in other countries “should do."
ReplyDeleteAnonymous4:28 PM
ReplyDeleteGVS from FOX says this? Come on the WH must be pretty stupid then to think its N. Korea?
Crap on a cracker.
Yes tell us about Sarah's warrior Trackmarks!
We've always had the Crazies, the Haters and the Ignorant. The big difference is that, years ago, they were hidden away in embarrassment.
ReplyDeleteToday, they're celebrated, revered, and elected to Congress.