Courtesy of Little Green Footballs:
Check out the audio clip of the conversation among state Rep. Steve Toth, R-The Woodlands, state Rep. Bill Zedler, R-Arlington, and state Rep. Donna Howard, D-Austin. The three were speaking just minutes after the House State Affairs Committee approved legislation with extreme abortion restrictions that could cause most of the state’s clinics to close. Rep. Howard was explaining to her colleagues that responsible sex education, including information on birth control, would lower the number of unplanned pregnancies and abortions. Rep. Toth didn’t agree:
“My wife worked at a home for unwed moms, and one of the little kids that was born, his name is David. David came about as a result of his mom and dad, who were just 16 at the time, going to a Planned Parenthood deal where they taught them how to use contraceptives. They were not sexually active at that point. They got into the car, and they were so hot and bothered from this deal, he couldn’t even get the condom on.”
If you listen to the rest of the clip, you’ll hear an exasperated Rep. Howard asking her colleagues to move beyond absurd anecdotes and provide some real data to back up their arguments. Needless to say, they have no data to provide. Rep. Toth and Rep. Zedler, like so many of their colleagues at the Capitol, apparently prefer to legislate by anecdote. But we can point to some real facts on sex education:
A 2012 study found no evidence that formal sex education leads teens to initiate sexual activity earlier or to engage in greater risk taking.
A November 2007 report explained that “two-thirds of the 48 comprehensive programs that supported both abstinence and the use of condoms and contraceptives for sexually active teens had positive behavioral effects.” Many either delayed or reduced sexual activity, reduced the number of sexual partners, or increased condom or contraceptive use. None of the comprehensive programs hastened the initiation of sex or increased the frequency of sex.
Access to effective contraception dramatically reduces unplanned pregnancy and abortion.
Here is the audio tape for those who cannot believe that this level of ignorance exists:
You know I have been to women's clinics a few items in my live, including Planned Parenthood, and I cannot remember ANYTHING in the educational materials which got my engine revving.
And this includes when I was sixteen years old, and I got an erection if a female simply bit her lip. arched her back, or flicked her hair out of her face.
This is just more of these ridiculous attacks against Planned Parenthood which the GOP now sees as the root of all evil. You know that and Obamacare.
Anecdotes are the source material for people with limited knowledge and no statistics. These are brought to you by the Texas Rebublicsns - a group that sought to avoid teaching critical thinking skills in schools.
ReplyDeleteGeorge W. Bush’s Altruistic Visit To Zambia
ReplyDeleteThe former president and his wife, former first lady Laura Bush, are in Zambia to promote the Pink Ribbon Red Ribbon, their cancer-fighting initiative. They also helped renovate a women’s clinic.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/georgewbushcenter/
Poor George. Still trying to reinvent his legacy. How come he doesn't fight for women's clinics in Texas? Laura? You have daughters...do you not care either? And by the way, I'm guessing Zambia is one country where Bush is safe from arrest for war crimes.
DeleteThis guy is a freakin' moron. First, what got the two kids hot and bothered was being 16. Second, it would be in their best interest to lie to this guy's obviously judgmental wife and blame planned parenthood instead of their own hormones.
ReplyDeleteI went to high school in a Georgia suburb just north of Atlanta. We had sex education classes. In order to "cool us down" after seeing all those exciting cartoon and line drawing images explaining how fertilization happens and how contraceptives work, they showed a military film on sexually transmitted diseases with very graphic photos of lesions, etc.
ReplyDeleteBut even that isn't enough to cool off teenagers whose hormone levels are so high a warm breeze will excite them. But those pictures were enough to scare some of us to at least take a few precautions.
I left Georgia over 20 years ago. I see things haven't improved there.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteSo Texas passed their Sharia abortion bill anyway? Well, piss on them, and Scott Walker, North Carolina and Ohio too. Piss on them all.
ReplyDeleteLet's use the Republican war on women to put Democrats in every office with margins large enough to thwart the Diebold flipping. Let's put supermajorities in every state at every level and put this country back on track and remind people WHO is working for them and WHO is punishing them and stealing from them.
Representative Steve Toth: "We should make all national policy decisions, particularly those affecting women, based upon the unverified anecdotal experience of a single horny male teenager – provided, of course, that the teenager is white."
ReplyDeleteTea Party, speaking in unison: "Representative Toth definitely has a big political future awaiting him!!"
Oh, right, every sixteen year old knows when they don't let you in an x rated theater, the next best place for porn is a good old fashioned birth control clinic, Am I right David, er, Mr Toth?!?!?!
ReplyDelete"Oh it's gonna be a great Christmas book, lots of nice festive joyful things within the book, like recipes and traditions of our family that are probably pretty unique, because we are from Alaska, and live near the North Pole, so we have access to Santa Claus and all the good things that come with Christmas."
ReplyDeleteThat's our Sarah. combatting the war on Christmas by assuring everyone that she has 'access' to the most holy of the saints, Santa Claus! And here I thought she was going to learn us how to make Jesus the center of things. Anyway, the full interview is at PoliticalGates, along with the sordid past of Mr. Reed, a crony of Jack Abramoff and Grover Norquist, who also uses God only to collect money from the masses.
Only a Republican could equate sex education with porn.
ReplyDeleteSo what about the hundreds and thousands of teenagers who did NOT get pregnant due to receiving this education? Oh yeah, not important, doesn't fit the narrative, stay focussed on the one horror story.
Morons.
Yea, well thanks alot............OBAMA!
Delete