So the book by David Magnusson, called simply "Purity" contains photographs of fathers standing with their daughters in the kind of poses that would make the hair on Chris Hansen's stand straight up, and an explanation from the author about why our perceptions are all wrong.
Here is a taste:
“When I first heard about the Purity Balls I imagined American fathers terrified of anything that might hurt their daughters or their families honor. But as I learnt more, I understood that the fathers, like all parents, simply wanted to protect the ones that they love – in the best way they know how. It was also often the girls themselves that had taken the initiative to attend the balls. They had made their decisions out of their own conviction and faith, in many cases with fathers who didn’t know what a Purity Ball was before first being invited by their daughters.
The more I learned, the more I was surprised that I had been so quick to judge people I knew so little about. I was struck by the idea that what set us apart wasn’t anything more than how we had been influenced by the culture we grew up in and the values it had instilled in us. In Purity I wanted to create portraits so beautiful that the girls and their fathers could be proud of the pictures in the same way they are proud of their decisions – while someone from a different background might see an entirely different story in the very same photographs.
To me, Purity is about how we are shaped by the society in which we grow up and how we interpret the world through the values we incorporate as our own.”
Uh huh. Well I guess you can blame my background but I am not picking up anything sweet, or nurturing from the photos.
And what I am picking up is more about obsessive control and an unnatural interest in a young girl's sexuality. Must be my background.
(H/T to The Godless Place.)
Latent incest personified. Truly, those pictures are just fucking creepy. Bad enough without the desaturation/over-exposed look to make everything look white and "angelic."
ReplyDeleteJesus Christ.
Yes, yes... and Jesus would NOT approve!
DeleteAgree. The photos creep me out. those girls should be in photos with prom dates, not with their pervert fathers.
Deletewell, the palins will never have to attend this kind of gig
DeleteYep. Those photos scream incest and sexual control to me. Really, really scary.
ReplyDeleteWhile not overtly sexual, I do think many of the poses are totally inappropriate. The dads, and some of the daughters, look like they are standing with their older lovers and not their fathers. I know MY husband has never posed like that with either of our beautiful daughters! Sorry, but the ICK factor is clearly there for me.
ReplyDeleteMy dad took me out to dinner when I was 16 at a nice downtown restaurant. Just him and me. I thought it was CREEPY.
ReplyDeleteTurns out it was a ruse for the surprise party that they had waiting at home for me.
But it felt weird, my dad saying he was taking me out as 16 is a milestone, yada yada, People at other tables wondering what the hell was going on with this guy and this young girl.
Some things just do not belong together: Dad and daughter proms are one of them. Especially one focusing on the daughter's ........cherry......gross!!!
I find it sad that you thought going out to dinner with your dad was creepy...that you ascribe negative thoughts about a girl having dinner at a restaurant with her father to other customers who probably weren't paying much if any attention to you at all. To conflate a father/daughter dinner out, with a father/daughter DANCE, IMO indicates that you are the one with the problem.
DeleteFamilies typically do EAT OUT together at restaurants. People do have to eat; it's normal. Families typically DON'T get dressed up and go dancing together where the emphasis is on the daughters' "purity." That's NOT normal.
Although I agree that the purity balls are creepy, YOUR post made me very sad. I had a wonderful close relationship with my dad and had many wonderful times with just him. Nothing anything icky or gross. My own daughter also has a great relationship with her dad. He even took her prom dress shopping. I'm sure you'd find that weird. I found it sweet.
DeleteFrom the time our granddaughter was 7, her grandfather has taken her out to dinner to celebrate her birthday every year. It's a special occasion for just the two of them. They both enjoy it. She's 19 now.
DeleteI find it very creepy that instead of having dinner with Dad you were on a date of some type with him. I would have been creeped out also.
Delete@Pogo
DeleteIs it dinner out with Grandpa or is it a "date" for her? If it is the latter I would suggest calling the local sheriffs.
OP here. Chill out people. My relationship with my dad is fine. It was creepy at 16 to go to an inimate setting for dinner when prior to that we'd been to family dinners or dad and kids at McDonalds. I'm trying to give you a 16 y/o perspective to see if these girls might feel the same way.
Delete12"59 let me explain the setting: a small intimate returant ob a boat on a river. Other table sitters were looking at us, My dad kept telling the waiter I was a daughter out for 16th birthday. I think my dad agreed he chose the wrong restaurant for a dad daughter night out.
I'm sorry people can't appreciate the connection I was trying to make and my feelings as a 16 year old..
6:53 am, I'm sorry, but not all 16 year olds are creeped out by having dinner at a nice restaurant with their Dad. It's not a sexual thing for heavens sakes! It's DINNER.
Delete6:53
DeleteOf course not all are creeped out and where ever did I say all were???
Remember this guy?
ReplyDeletehttp://images.huffingtonpost.com/gen/23725/original.jpg
Just last month the state of Texas seized his 1,600 acre ranch.
wow. No offense, but please give a warning. Not too sure how you would do that, but gosh, I got dry heaves and almost vomited.
DeleteHow about
DeleteWarning-click this link to see a convicted sex pervert and serial molester of children
Those pics were widely shown in the media. Good thing he's serving a life sentence. The pics posted by Gryphen here immediately reminded me of him.
DeleteApril 2014 Polygamist Warren Jeffs' Texas ranch being seized by state officials
Deletehttp://www.cnn.com/2014/04/17/us/texas-yfz-ranch-seizure/
What a creepy photo, those are his wives, and this is one step away from Purity Balls in ick factor.
Delete‘Christian’ Homeschool Dads Get Girl Kicked Out of Prom Because They Can’t Stop Lusting After Her
ReplyDeleteWith all the talk of the ‘Christian’ world’s incredibly creepy purity balls, in which fathers “marry” their daughters in order to take charge of their hymens–which also produce some ‘Why-Don’t-You-Take-A-Seat-Over-There“-caliber photo opportunities–it’s really not surprising that a bunch of old men at a Christian prom just can’t control themselves when confronted with the sweet, sweet booty of a seventeen-year-old attendee.
http://aattp.org/christian-homeschool-dads-get-girl-kicked-out-of-prom-because-they-cant-stop-lusting-after-her/
It also didn't make them happy that she's a pretty blonde and her date was a handsome black boy.
DeleteWow that is just so disgusting and I feel sorry for that girl. Look how easily these dads could turn this into an xtian religion.
DeleteThe only thing these things "protect" is the daughter's behavior -- daddy won't like you if you want to have sex before he allows it. Medieval.
ReplyDeleteNonsense. Studies show that those who have abstinence ed and make pledges like this are just as likely to have premarital sex and just as soon. The only difference is they are likely to have unprotected sex. My guess is they are also more likely to then seek out abortions wherever and however. I also guess the psychological damage is pretty horrific.
DeleteYou clearly did not understand what I wrote.
DeleteAll these photos make me want to do is call Children's Services.
ReplyDeleteThese fear/lie/bribe-based scam that these 'dad's have dreamed give way to a dynamic of modern culture - PIMPIN PAYS BETTER.
ReplyDeleteThe first photo where the father is reaching around and grasping his daughter on the upper left part of her abdomen below the belt line is very troubling indeed. I'd never even think to put my hand there on my daughter or on her in the other photos either.
ReplyDeleteY.U.C.K.
ReplyDeleteGross
ReplyDeleteThese photos suggest that those dear old (loony Xtian) Dads have absolutely NO respect for their daughters...the girls are just objects that exist to validate HIM, whether through "this is mine and you can't have it" to something, uh, a whole lot worse. I've always gotten that "need a shower" feeling when I hear this discussed, especially when I watched the trailer for the documentary. This verges on pedophilia that's "approved" with a wink and a nod, whether consummated (yeesh!) or not.
ReplyDeleteLooks like wedding photos
ReplyDeleteIs it me, or does that last picture with the girl in the blue tulle short dress look kinda pregnant?
ReplyDeleteI was thinking the same thing...
DeleteCreepy, very creepy.
ReplyDeletecreeped out. Thank goodness I had a wonderful Dad.
ReplyDeleteThese photos creep me out. My father, being more like a Frank Barone, would never have gone for that stuff, and I'm glad. There is a name for whatever I'm seeing in these photos, and I'm not sure it exists...........sick/weird/father-daughter obsessed with sex thing. This just does not feel right.
ReplyDeleteIf they were just standing next to each other with big old happy smiles, heading off to the annual school father-daughter dance, it wouldn't be so bad.
ReplyDeleteBut they are posed like lovers, like a boy and his girl heading off to prom. They are not. They are a father and daughter heading off to a dance celebrating the father's involvement in his daughter's sexuality.
Very creepy and unhealthy in my opinion.
Daddy are these the purity balls you told me about?
DeleteWhy yes they are honey, just be gentle like I told you last time.
They're the whitest of the white, aren't they? Like they scurried right back out of that sun after the pictures.
ReplyDeleteWhere does it stop? Does "Dad" want to be right there on the wedding night, directing his new son-in-law's every thrust?
I have a close friend who got custody of his 15-year-old daughter when he got divorced. They are very close and he is very protective, but I can't imagine them ever taking part in an event like this or taking a picture like these.
ReplyDeleteRed flags, warning bells and flashing lights are going off all over the place when I look at these photos.
I thought this article is very fitting with this topic... :/
ReplyDeletehttp://www.rawstory.com/rs/2014/05/13/teen-girl-kicked-out-of-prom-because-dads-said-her-dress-conjured-impure-thoughts/
How come they are only concerned with their "girls" being pure?They don't care about their sons? Isn't this hypocritical?
ReplyDeleteDaddy gets a poke at Suzie and Junior stays home and gets a tug job from Momma. Family Values, Redneck Fundie style.
DeleteThose photos are so creepy. Yes, Daddy, I love you too, very very much.
ReplyDeleteDaddy, is that a pistol in your pocket or are you just excited to be taking me to the prom?
DeleteThose photos are DAMN CREEPY! Ewwwww! They project something very unnatural.
ReplyDeleteYes, mlaiuppa 1:04, my thought exactly!
ReplyDeleteSo is there a male version of purity ball. Where the mom has a hold of her son, who has vowed to not wank off or get into a girls pants?
ReplyDeleteGreat question! Maybe it boils down to that the females are the ones who actually get pregnant. The old double standard. However I cringe thinking of what a mother-son purity ball would be like.
DeleteIt's called the Manhood Ceremony where boys are presented with a sword. Not a gun. The boys are invited to "watch" at the purity ball so by example they can learn how to treat women by seeing how fathers treat their daughters.
http://www.generationsoflight.com/html/boys.html
The Jonas Brothers had purity rings.
DeleteOblivious to ridicule, brothers pledge abstinence
http://www.timesrecordnews.com/news/2008/sep/11/our-opinion-silence-golden/?print=1
Monique Endriss places a purity ring on her son Justin's finger during the Purity Ball ceremony.
DeletePhotos by Donnie Biggs
There is a photo. The original article can't be found but there is a re-print here. The Army's Fort Belvoir hosted Purity Balls in 2002 and 2000. Scroll down the page about 2/3 way titled "True Love Waits".
http://www.thephora.net/forum/showthread.php?t=22033
Mom, Bristool is being a stingy, fat bitch again and won't let me rest my purity balls on her "TeaBaggin' Leno" chin unless I pay her more money.
Delete~ Track "Can't Get Right" Menard
I think the pics would be much better if they showed the chastity belts.
ReplyDeleteDaddy's Little Hymen.
DeleteKeeping it in the family.
DeleteThere is something so sick about this. If my father had behaved this way my mother would’ve encouraged him to seek therapy. Thankfully, he was a wonderful dad who gave all his kids a lot of personal freedom and yet demanded a lot out of us academically. The fathers in these photos just give me the creeps.
ReplyDelete1 ion 5 girls is a victim of sexual abuse. Count the pictures. 'Nuff said.
ReplyDeleteThe photos are simply creepy. And they all seem to be in a desert. And what about "purity balls" for the sons? Do the fathers who escort their young daughters to these "purity balls" have chats with their sons and tell them not to pressure other girls into having sex? Do they teach their kids the facts of life?
ReplyDeleteBeaglemom
Well none of the Palin girls would make the Purity grade. Todd could teach them the "tricks" of his trade.
ReplyDeleteThere is creepy, then there is really creepy, and then there is this. I've got no daughters, just a son, so maybe I'm in no position to pass any kind of assessment on this uh, really really really really fucking creepy shit. Sho nuff creepy.
ReplyDeleteSome lines shouldn't be crossed. These girls are vowing to keep themselves pure under the watchful eyes of their daddies and with their mom's approval. The simple act of asking a girl to get all gussied up, get a ring from daddy, and pledge her purity is emotional abuse and totally uncalled for.
ReplyDeleteThe proper thing to do is to wave your hands on the bottom step and chant "No Boys", right Sarah?
Sex education is key. The girls need to know what's happening to their bodies and those of boys when hormones kick in. They need to know where babies come from and how to avoid becoming pregnant.
What is the punishment for breaking your dad's purity balls? Will he love you less? Force you to have a baby? Where in the Bible are purity balls mentioned?
If these people would invest equal time and attention to promoting their child's intellect and educational growth, there would be no need to worry if "daddy's little girl" will be worthy of some sure to be abusive and misogynistic mate. No surprise should these young ladies become misandrists.
ReplyDeleteSick photos. Very sick. (and I am not inclined to get sick)
ReplyDeleteThis is very disturbing.
ReplyDeleteAt some of the Purity Balls the daughters present their fathers with a pink box containing a key. Do these people understand anything about symbolism? Creep factor very high.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2w5Le0w4pQ8
ReplyDeletesouth park's take on purity rings!
New Jersey 'Mormon Prom' Draws Hundreds Of Teens For Celebration Of Modesty http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/05/14/new-jersey-mormon-prom_n_5317349.html
ReplyDelete