Previous surveys we've reported on, including one from the Southern Poverty Law Center, also found increases in school bullying related to overheated political rhetoric.
The UCLA survey, unlike those, relies on a nationally representative sample: 1,535 teachers at schools whose demographics reflect those of U.S. schools as a whole, rather than pulling from self-selecting volunteers. Also, the survey was conducted after President Trump took office. Along with the survey, researchers at the UCLA Institute for Democracy, Education and Access conducted 35 follow-up interviews by phone.
Here are some of the key findings:
- 79 percent of teachers reported that students have expressed concerns for their well-being or the well-being of their families because of what is in the news. Most commonly mentioned was immigration, but the list also included the much-publicized travel ban, restrictions on LGBTQ rights, threats to the Affordable Care Act and threats to the environment.
- 51 percent of teachers reported more students experiencing "high levels of stress and anxiety."
- 44 percent of teachers reported that students' concerns were affecting learning. In interviews, they spoke about students who seemed stressed, distracted and who were contributing less to class discussion for fear of drawing attention to themselves.
- 41 percent of teachers reported that students were more likely than in previous years to introduce unfounded claims in class discussions, such as from Facebook or talk radio.
- 27 percent of teachers reported an increase in students making derogatory remarks about other groups during class discussions. This included sexist as well as racist and anti-Muslim comments.
- 20 percent of teachers reported heightened polarization on campus and incivility in their classrooms.
These last two figures were higher for teachers at predominantly white schools, says John Rogers, lead author of the report and a professor at UCLA's graduate school of education. He noted that teachers in eight states used the word "emboldened" to describe some white students' increasingly racist and offensive behavior.
The report is not comprehensive, and there's no easy way to compare its results with those during any previous administration. But it speaks to an ongoing national discussion about civil discourse and civic engagement inside and outside the classroom.
When I say in the headline that teachers are on the "front line" I mean that literally as they are often the ones who first recognize shifts in how young people respond to the mood of a country, or how attitudes are evolving concerning racism, sexism, or tolerance of "the other."
During the Obama Administration it seemed that the country was moving rapidly toward more progressive attitudes, hope for the future, and acceptance of others.
But now with Trump in the White House it appears that we returned to intolerance and divisiveness almost overnight.
… it appears that we returned to intolerance and divisiveness almost overnight.
ReplyDeleteIt is, after all, what Trump preaches.
A friend of ours, an excellent middle school teacher, is concerned in particular about one of her classes because the students come in frenzied and remain so, making the start of a meaningful class almost impossible. She brought the subject up after a talk by a poet who said that he practices zen meditation. I'm wondering now if starting the class with a few minutes of silence and eventually stillness wouldn't help. It might even be a good way to start every school day. Not a period of religious silence, as the Quakers practice, but just a quiet time to focus for the day ahead.
ReplyDeleteBeaglemom
They tried that here. Mindfulness. One Fundamentalist didn’t want his daughter doing it because it might welcome the devil into her body. So the principal said he’d stand with her in the hallways and agitate her so that the devil wouldn’t get inside.
DeleteReligious crazies. They’re everywhere.
And some nutjob is going to claim religious indoctrination of some kind. Probably the exact same ones indoctrinating their little bullies to hate and prejudice.
Student attacked for sitting for Pledge of Allegiance by mouth-breather wearing a flag t-shirt who interrupts the pledge to attack a student sitting quietly: https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2017/10/27/1710274/-Student-Attacked-for-Sitting-during-Pledge-of-Allegiance
ReplyDeleteWhen I was in grade school during the sixties, there were two or three kids in every class who sat for the Pledge because their families were Jehovah's Witnesses.
DeleteThey were treated with respect by the teachers and never had any problems at all with the other students.
All the way back in the sixties!! Of course, this was New York.
Incivility unless of course it is coming from republicans,then it is they were just joking.
ReplyDeleteSo, when parents see their children behave like Trump (presidential), is that what this country wants? Or do only Trump fans, including duly elected GOP representatives and senators wish this on their own children and the children of their constituents?
ReplyDeleteLord have mercy on us all.
dowl
Who do you think they get it from? They get it from their parents. If not from intentional teaching than at least from observation and imitation. These parents aren’t going to do squat. They don’t even recognize that what their kids are doing is detrimental.
Delete~IT~ was over night...Nov 8th to the 9th 2016.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.newsweek.com/americans-scream-helplessly-sky-donald-trump-election-anniversary-690889
Gee... I wonder if Democrats will get out and VOTE next time?
ReplyDeleteNope.
DeleteAnd the Deplorables will continue to vote Republican.