Courtesy of the Washington Monthly:
I recently wrote a piece suggesting that the Obamas should campaign as a couple, which was picked up by some websites with sizable African-American readerships (e.g. Jack and Jill Politics, The Smithian). In that more Black-dominated part of the web, I saw more unreservedly positive comments about the President than I have read in the past year in all of what I suppose are my typically white Internet reading habits. Gone were the usual jibes that Obama is an “Eisenhower Republican” or “plutocratic sellout”. Indeed, many people referred to him (and his wife) as heroes and inspirational leaders, among a number of other cynicism-free superlatives.
It reminded me of an event I attended last year in the East Room of the White House. As a group of us who had worked on the President’s AIDS strategy awaited Obama’s arrival, an African-American woman asked me to give her my spot near the lectern so that she might shake the President’s hand. She had in her purse a glove which her sister had made her promise to put on immediately after any handshake with Obama. Her sister wanted no one and nothing to touch the hand the President had touched until she herself removed the glove and experienced her hero’s touch, even indirectly. I was so touched by her and her sister’s devotion that I moved myself and a few other people out of the way to give her a chance (she got her precious handshake, and left the White House joyfully gloved).
I can hear a few white liberal noses curling at this account of shameless President-love: how fulsome, how unsophisticated, how jejune. But I would say how human, how bravely committed and how encouraging to a President who needs more than truculent, nose-holding liberal voters behind him to accomplish great things.
Though some may simply want to explain this away as ethnic pride that one of their own has finally made it, if not TO the mountain top at least right next to the mountain top.
However could it be that it is not the black voters whose expectations are too low, but in fact the white voters whose expectations are far too high?
I cringe at the white, alleged liberals who call on Obama to acknowledge that his is a failed presidency. They want the first Black President in history to, effectively, announce that he is a bumbling affirmative action baby, apologize for being so uppity as to have ever assumed otherwise and resign in disgrace so that Hillary Clinton or some other qualified (i.e. white) person can lead the party. Would that such white “progressives” were required to focus group their proposal in a locked room with a random sample of 20 African-American women. Fortunately, the President has ignored their call to set back race relations a generation and crush the optimism he has generated among people of color nationally. These attacks on the President, like others, generally go nowhere with African-Americans; indeed they may even strengthen their commitment to him.
But all that said, my own question of why Blacks so love Obama elides the broader reality evidenced by their very high approval ratings of a white Democratic President, Bill Clinton. Blacks have a special place in the hearts for Barack Obama, but fundamentally, if you are a Democratic President, Black people in this country have your back.
I made a promise to myself, and to my President when I filled in that oval next to his name. Just like he made promises to me which convinced me to choose him above all others.
While not making all of my dreams come true, Obama has done a pretty admirable job of keeping his promises.
And me? Well I simply do NOT break a promise.
In other words, regardless of my ethnicity, I ALSO have our President's back. And for that, I make no apologies.
Amen to that . . .
ReplyDeleteNo apology needed.
High-5 more years!
%^)
Hey Gryph - I just want to say thank you for your posts regarding our President. So many people are trying to cut him down and I just don't get why....so I'm asking people to help me out here with a slight memory problem.
ReplyDeleteI don't recall, during the 2008 cycle, Candidate Obama ever calling himself the messiah.
I don't recall him ever calling himself a radical progressive.
I don't recall him saying he could perform miracles, in fact I seem to recall him saying that it was going to take a great deal of hard work form BOTH sides of the aisle to get things even close to turning around.
I don't recall Candidate Obama saying he had a magic fix for everything that ails our country at this time.
This is what I do remember:
I remember Candidate Obama promising to do the best job that he could for us.
I remember him stating that he would be there for ALL the people in this country - not just the democratic party.
I remember watching him and saying to myself that here was an intelligent, compassionate man that I could put my faith in and, while not perfect, he was a breath of fresh air from the previous administration.
Now, I might not agree with everything that he (and the House and Senate) have done, but I do believe that he has done an outstanding job considering the obstacles that have been thrown in his way since before he even took the oath of office.
Is my memory failing me? Have I gotten anything completely wrong?
Just tossing this question out there.
Off the soapbox for now.
Thanks
KerryAnn
EXCELLENT article, Jesse, thank you for posting it, and I am with you 100%. I have my personal view of what I would have liked to see President Obama do differently, but that doesn't necessarily translate into disappointment at all. I have very strong feelings that his second term will be much more his own and not so much about cleaning up his predecessor's messes, trying to 'prove' himself and just plain getting used to a new job. He doesn't have anything to prove anymore to the loud mouths that questioned him during the campaign in 2008, he has more than proven his intelligence, strength, honor, political acumen, deft negotiations and so much more. I am proud to support him now and for 2012 and look forward to how he will lead into the future.
ReplyDeleteAnd, by the way, I am a white female who never got involved in politics until I came to hear Barack Obama and when I did, I knew that I was listening to an amazing human being and that I would do all I could to help elect him president. And I will again.
Me, too, Gryphen, me, too. I will stand with this President. I am so grateful and so proud that our country is represented and led by President Obama.
ReplyDeleteI am a youngish senior white woman, just so you know. I do not understand some of my age group who cower under the Tea Party or GOP banners.
But then, I have always had a progressive heart, and had parents who sacrificed for me so I could have a good education, and I made sure I absorbed everything I could because I knew how important an education was to them and would be for me.
I stand by this President and will join you and others in protecting his back. He has done this country proud, and I am proud to say I voted for him and will do so again.
- ks sunflower
Quite right, Jesse. I don't break my promises either.
ReplyDeletei dont explain it away at all.
ReplyDeleteyou see the same mindless devotion from the palin supporters.
who with any integrity would deny they are the same?
the reality is much much different sad to say.
and anyone not aware of who and what obama is has chosen to remain ignorant.
it really is not a question of right versus left or wrong, but of what moves your heart towards fairness and justice for people (and yes even the planet)less fortunate and engaged in struggle just to survive.
educate yourselves to that reality and even your unconscience choices will be in the best interests of your fellow man.
This piece made me SICK the first time I read about.
ReplyDeleteMy dissatisfaction has Obama has absolutely NOTHING to do with his race.
It's simply using the race card to suggest otherwise, and to use it in this way is pathetic and desperate in a way that I should expect from Republicans, not Democrats.
I am fucking COLORBLIND. I hold all politicians to the exact same standards, period. I may be a registered Democrat, but I value adhering to and promoting Democratic IDEALS, not Democratic POLITICIANS.
This piece simply increases my already negative opinion of Obama and his Republican-copying and appeasing ways.
I am a white 62 year old woman and I feel the same way about President Obama as the African American woman in this article. I am so proud of our very intelligent, very kind, and very hard working president. He has done wonders!
ReplyDeleteI'm with you 100%.
ReplyDeleteThank you. I think President Obama is doing a very good job, myself, especially in the face of the Do-Nothing Congress, whose spoken goal is to prevent his effectiveness.
ReplyDeleteI might not be African-American, but I feel exactly the same as the woman who shook his hand.
In political campaigns, there are always a mountain of promises. Can we expect them all to be fulfilled -- NO. That's being unrealistic in that he cannot sit and put pen to paper and pass the laws/policies on his own.
ReplyDeleteI've felt that with every President that has been sworn in.
A bit different feeling from Gryphen - it's not because the 'promise' of a vote - it's because IMO he's done a good job in a sea of circumstances that would not normally have been on his platter to deal with. The majority of Presidents in office have not experienced what he has in office and hopefully no others will. Well, maybe there are a few things I wish upon some!!!
Some issues of importance to me have been addressed; some not but I don't expect my personal agenda to be fulfilled. Others are still in the dialogue. Other issues he's responded to, I consider bonuses as they were not on my short list but am delighted they were addressed. A reason why I/we want a President who is smarter than I/us and that he is.
I don't agree with my parents 100% nor they with me and that's only a party of totalling 3. How can I expect the President to with a party/nation of millions who all have different ideas and wishes. His job is to look after the interests of all. In my book - he's doing that!!
I am not of the same ethnic background. Ethnicity - he's different than me?? Really - Oh my. Someone forgot to tell me!!! Who cares!! Not I.
Contrary to popular belief, the President of the United States does have little other than that of guiding, cajoling and, in the final analysis, VETO.
ReplyDeleteYes, he is the Commander in Chief, but when one looks at it all closely, the Executive Branch is effectively bound by a less than "Loyal Opposition" in Congress.
The Electoral College is another anachronism which served the country when there was little communication between the original states and the vast hinterland.
I could go on.
In this age of instant communication, we need to look to the future as did the Founders in their time, but the obstructionists in this nation want none of it.
The young generation needs to step forward an take the banner as those who (for better, for worse) have the guts to give up their comforts and "Occupy".
They have my admiration.
Appears the troll alert should be sounded at 1:28. The two following quotes appear to be clues IMO.
ReplyDelete"I may be a registered Democrat" (When you have to say it, majority of time you aren't)
"his Republican-copying and appeasing ways."
I love when conservatives come up with the idea that blacks only voted for Obama because he was black. That number was only eclipsed by the number of people who DIDN'T vote for him because he was black.
ReplyDeletePersonally I voted for him cause he's so dang cute! and smart, and aware, and thoughtful and dedicated to making the U.S. a better place for ALL of its citizens rather than just those in his party. I'm voting for him in 2012 and will vote for him again in 2016 even knowing he can't run again. (Unless Elizabeth Warren runs that is. Wouldn't want to short her any votes !!)
And just to add, he and his family have conducted themselves with the utmost dignity and grace. We don't see that much anymore in public figures. I think he has been a rousing success by any standard and when you consider what he is up against, his success is tenfold.
ReplyDeleteIt is amazing to me that a certain percentage of white liberals are expecting this man to work miracles that no human could perform and conservatives are mocking him for not working more miracles than he has.
Apparently they all regard him as superman because they have never held anyone else up to such a standard.
From about a month into his Presidency, Obama has been criticized for not undoing all the enormous SHIT that the previous eight years brought about.
ReplyDeleteEven by those who had voted for Bush, but wouldn't admit it by that time.
I kept wanting to say that, HEY, we didn't elect a KING or a DICTATOR...can't anyone remember back to high school civics? The office is essentially that of a cheerleader, rooting Congress to enact effective laws.
Then it dawned on me: the whole thing was a set up...a way of making the new black guy the BOOGEYMAN who was out to destroy the U.S., not save it.
I had to laugh when I read earlier today that Republicans are being warned by their trainers, to hold off on the personal attacks of Obama, because its gone on for so long, now, that most thinking people are no longer falling for such bullshit.
I just love it when something comes along showing Americans are getting SMARTER, as it so often seems they keep getting dumber by the freaking MINUTE.
O/T - I am boycotting Katy Perry's appearance on SNL tonight because of this: http://indiancountrytodaymedianetwork.com/2011/11/17/englishman-russell-brand-and-others-play-indian-for-katy-perrys-birthday-63520
ReplyDeleteI love his smile! The exact one in this picture. And guess what? That smile will be around forever, because we're going to make history again baby. Four more years!!!! Oh yes we will. You're the man Mr. President; you are, our man.
ReplyDeleteI've been a registered republican since 1977. I voted for Reagan twice (sorry!) and Daddy Bush once. The second time he ran, I just couldn't bring myself to vote for him so I sat that election out because I didn't want to betray my "party". Then came Clinton. I didn't vote for him the first time but by the second time he ran, I felt he had earned my vote and I crossed over to the Dem side for first time in my life.
ReplyDeleteThen there was Bush the sequel. I sat that one out too as I had supported McCain in the primary and I hated what Rove had done to McCain.
In 2008, I planned to support McCain until he picked Palin. That lost him my vote. I looked over the Dem candidate and decided I could cast a vote for either one. So...I voted for Obama when he won the nomination.
It pains me to see such partisan sniping on the part of my lifelong party. Obama may not have had experience when he took office but then neither did McCain. No one has experience as a President until they are a President.
When I see such vitriol directed at the man who from all accounts has done a pretty good job with what he has had to work with, I cannot help but think his race plays a role in the malice.
I still occasionally vote republican but they have to be moderates. I will not vote for their presidential candidate this coming election year as they have gone too far to the right. I will cast my vote again for Obama. He has earned my vote by being the adult in a room full of two year olds.
And that folks is what is called putting your COUNTRY first!
Anon @ 1:02 -
ReplyDeleteI agree with you but want to add that many second-term Presidents are able to accomplish much more because they not only have an experienced staff structure in place from day one, but they also don't have the threat of a reelection campaign ahead of them.
Although PO has accomplished an enormous amount of legislation despite the entire GOP working against him, every move and every word is influenced by the upcoming campaign. Once that's over, he can push for the more difficult or controversial legislation that, nevertheless, needs to be passed.
I'm planning to do my best to give him a second term because he's still got a lot of work left to do!
Bismarck said, "Politics is the art of the possible". For anyone disappointed with President Obama's performance, please explain what he could have accomplished that was possible that he did not.
ReplyDeleteI am a white southerner who came of age during the Kennedy era and believe this president is the finest, smartest, most graceful, most caring, most honest, most moral president of my lifetime.
I am an African-American who voted for Barack Obama in 2008,and will vote for him again in 2012. He stands head and shoulders about the cretins who make up the majority of those running for the GOP nomination. Those who are not batshit crazy are ethically challenged and lack empathy for everyday Americans. By contrast, this president has good instincts and has produced plans helpful to the 99%. Unfortunately, because of the do-nothings in Congress who block his bills, he has not been able to do as much as he could. In addition, I don't agree with everything he has done or proposed. I don't look at him as a "Messiah," and I view the big picture, which means I'm aware we need another Congress. I sincerely hope Americans are smart enough now to know that Congressional members of the Party of No are blocking his bills in an effort to make him a "failed" president. I can only wonder what makes those who want Hillary Clinton for president think it would be any different for her.
ReplyDeleteBig High-Five + To Kerry @ 12:58 PM --
ReplyDeleteA very big 'Thank You' back atcha!! This is one of the best comments and I really enjoyed it. ♥
I also do not recall any/all of those statements being said and/or promised by 'Candidate Obama' -- Only that . . . "I seem to recall him saying that it was going to take a great deal of hard work form BOTH sides of the aisle to get things even close to turning around."
"I remember Candidate Obama promising to do the best job that he could for us."
"I remember him stating that he would be there for ALL the people in this country - not just the democratic party."
"I remember watching him and saying to myself that here was an intelligent, compassionate man that I could put my faith in and, while not perfect, he was a breath of fresh air from the previous administration."
Thanks again for the very positive, well-written comments. And, another big Thank You to Gryphen for sharing this post with us, plus all else he does here, for us.
I get so sick and tired of the Republicans constantly saying negative things about our wonderful President Obama. I truly think they are going to get kicked in their behinds at the upcoming election. It is known nationwide they are NOT listening to the American people! They have done nothing but obstruct President Obama since he took the oath of office. It is truly amazing what he has been able to have the accomplishments he has since they block everything! The Repubs no more represent their base than the man in the moon!
ReplyDeletePresident Obama has my vote AGAIN! People throughout the US need to talk positively about him by spreading their/our words to friends and family as well as encouraging everyone to get out and vote. His accomplishments can be obtained online, so that you have specifics to share.
The Republicans certainly are not able to find someone of President Obama's quality. I don't understand how Rick Perry ever was elected as gov of TX as he has proven himself to be such an idiot. Much like Sarah Palin of AK did! Gingrich is a horrid joke due to his background/history and assuredly does not represent family values. The man actually frightens me - he physically appears evil when he presents himself on national TV. Mitt leaves me w/many questions and concerns too.
Best wishes to President Obama, his beautiful wife and darling daughters.
White expectations aren't too high, as you write. They are too stupid, concocted in a culture that is virtually clueless about many aspects of human life. The whining that comes from them graphically portrays the distance they are from normal human experiences of difficulty and disaster.
ReplyDeleteI'm white, an old-time liberal Democrat and I love President Obama. I think he has done a superb job having been given the most recalcitrant opposition imaginable. I completely support his re-election.
ReplyDeleteAnon 1:28
ReplyDeleteNo one is colorblind. If they say they are they are lying. You are screaming bullshit. If you ignore someone's skin you ignore their history and all the things that came before them. You do not have to be colorblind--you just don't have to be racist.
Just as it is not ok to be homophobic -- to acknowledge that someone is gay is a statement of fact and acknowledges all that they have been through and or suffered.
Now. . . .
When we find your people--you know, the screaming asshole tribe -- we hope that you run across the ditches and gullies to connect with them.
I am a white female 63 years old, and I feel about President Obama the same way the African American lady does. I was a registered republican during the 2008 election but I voted for Obama and will do so again. I didn't trust McCain to start with, and his pick of Palin for VP clinched the deal. I would have voted for Hillary had she been the nominee, but I don't believe she could have accomplished any more that President Obama has. I just can't understand these democrats that constantly complain and find fault with the president. He has had a constant battle since the day he was sworn in. I have never seen the likes of it in my lifetime.
ReplyDeleteThere are blogs that I had always read, that I no longer frequent because of so called democrats that demean the president on a regular basis. Are there things that I had hoped for that haven't happened? Yes. Do I totally agree with President Obama on everything? No. In my opinion he is our very best hope of regaining what we once had in this county.
I am no longer registered as a republican, but have changed to the democratic party, and have no intention of ever going back.
Grypen, I appreciate your support of our president, and have stayed with this blog in part because of it. Your blog is extremely entertaining also, so keep up the good work.
Sue in Kansas
I am just so glad he is our President and I am determined to do my civil part to give him four more years and we all need to give him a Congress he can work with.
ReplyDeleteM. from MD
I am pushing 70 next year (can hardly believe it!) - voted for President Obama the first time and will again.
ReplyDeleteHe is a wonderful person there is no doubt. The Republicans they have moving through the primary process do not begin to have his qualities, kindness or smarts! President Obama will be elected AGAIN!
Thank God McCain and Palin were put in the shitter!! (Sorry to be so crass, but cannot help myself!)
Loving the side-by-side photo!
ReplyDeleteCompare a man who can barely manage an umbrella to one who smiles in the rain- nope, no comparison!
W.T.
@ 1:28pm,
ReplyDeleteYour "appeasement" meme is known for what it is, a dog-whistle to the right-wing bigots who have used it in many ways for many years.
But, as President Obama explained in the simplest terms possible to "people of your ilk," ask Osaba bin Laden, and three-quarters of the rest of AlQueda leaders who have been terminated, about his appeasments.
I think the Republican Party is about to find out just how much this President will not be appeasing your ilk, anymore.
Don't think for a minute that you weren't told.
.
Worth a read:
ReplyDeleteThe Republicans' Farcical Candidates: A Club of Liars, Demagogues and Ignoramuses -
SPIEGEL ONLINE -
http://spon.de/adwu6
Let me preface this by saying that the point of this post written by an african american woman is that race had little to do with Obama becoming President. Although race WAS an issue, because he was the first person of color to become the Leader of the Free World.
ReplyDeleteI'm a white woman in her mid fifties, and it could have been me writing what she said.
Racism, Bigorty and Hate always existed and always will, but it wasn't just the black vote that got Obama Elected.
What got President Obama elected was his grace, character, humility, wisdom, education and his grasp on social issues.
I DO think of President Obama and The First Lady as equals and a team. Something I've never seen in my lifetime.
I voted him President, not Miracle Worker/Jesus/American Idol. And he's delivered most of what he promised.
Four More Years! And if Michelle Obama doesn't run, then Liz Warren is next.
President Obama has my support and my vote next year...not because he's black but because he is the best man for the job which he has proven for the last 3 1/2 years.
ReplyDeleteThe Republiclowns are so fucked up even they know their chances are slim to none for winning this election unless they steal it. I pray that the "Democratic Machine"(H/T to Gov Dirty)is aware of what the Republiclowns are planning and that they are ready for these clowns...
The thought of any of the current jokers running could win the election next year is enough to make sure all my family's passports are ready for the big getaway!
And to both commenters at 1:28PM....blah blah blah...can't you guys come up with some new shit!
I support this president. I will vote for him next year.
ReplyDeleteI do not expect any president to make my dreams come true.
I do not rely on a president's decisions to determine my mood on a day to day basis -- that's my responsibility.
The president has other responsibilities.
So well said that I am going to post this again. Only difference is I am not African-American.
ReplyDelete"I am an African-American who voted for Barack Obama in 2008,and will vote for him again in 2012. He stands head and shoulders about the cretins who make up the majority of those running for the GOP nomination. Those who are not batshit crazy are ethically challenged and lack empathy for everyday Americans. By contrast, this president has good instincts and has produced plans helpful to the 99%. Unfortunately, because of the do-nothings in Congress who block his bills, he has not been able to do as much as he could. In addition, I don't agree with everything he has done or proposed. I don't look at him as a "Messiah," and I view the big picture, which means I'm aware we need another Congress. I sincerely hope Americans are smart enough now to know that Congressional members of the Party of No are blocking his bills in an effort to make him a "failed" president. I can only wonder what makes those who want Hillary Clinton for president think it would be any different for her."
3:40
Obama 2012
ReplyDelete(Love the photo! Thanks, Gryphen))
Good writing.
ReplyDeleteGood take on things also.
But as kindly as I can say, the word "TOO" should still be spelled "TO."
Capitalize and make it bold sure, but spell it correctly also. :)
I love the rain photo. Plus it's the right thing to do -- give the speech in the rain!
ReplyDeleteI am for Obama in 2012. No Repub candidate comes up to Obama's little toe. Thank you for these updates, G.
I know of no white liberal who would ever curl their nose at a woman who wanted her glove to touch Barack Obama's hand. I know of no white liberal who wants Obama to admit he's a "bumbling Affirmative Action baby." I do know of a lot of rightwingers who would make similar accusations, though.
ReplyDeleteI think this writer is overlooking that all of the criticism about Barack Obama among progressives runs along the same lines among both his white and African American critics, Dr. Cornel West being a prominent example of the latter. We just don't think the man has lived up to most of our expectations. Whether or not our expectations were too high is not the point; the point is that when African American progressives criticize Barack Obama, their criticism isn't much different than criticism from white or Latino progressives. For example, all of us, no matter our ethnicity, feel that Wall Street got a stunning pass.
I will add to my comments that I fully agree there are some on the left who have gone completely nuts in their criticism of Barack Obama, though. FireDogLake/Jane Hamsher come to mind.
ReplyDeleteI just think summing up progressive criticism of Obama under the category of white liberal snobbiness is equally extreme.
I agree with this post.
ReplyDeleteI never thought of the President as the "Messiah" or the "Chosen One", or the "Anointed One."
These terms come sneeringly at supporters of the President from both right wing types and leftists.
The right needs to look at their hero worship of a Ronald Reagan who never was.
As for the far left, their condescending rants seem to indicate that if anyone was expecting the President to be a Messiah, an Anointed One, the Chosen One who would fix everything, it was them.
He is a man. I don't agree with everything he has done or said, but he has done a superb job considering the foaming at the mouth opposition from both extremes.
As soon as I see someone say that all he has done is "appease" (buzzword of the week) Republicans, or that there is no difference between him and a Republican, or that he is weak, naive, etc., I know that there is no point in pursuing the remiander of the article.
We African Americans have President Obama's back. And don't let anyone tell you differently.
ReplyDeleteI am a Black American. President and Mrs. Obama are an inspiration to me, my family, and my friends.
ReplyDeleteThe Black community loves them. They are resilient, compassionate, they have a great love people. ALL people.
We also know that President Obama is doing a great job, in spite of Repub obstruction, and hate.
I also have his back. Not financially as I was able to do in '08, but personally, by speaking about him and his accomplishments.
ReplyDeleteThe only thing I criticize him for is for hiring Geitner et al. He should NOT have let the fox guard the hen house.
ReplyDeleteAnon 7:35 am: We African Americans have President Obama's back. And don't let anyone tell you differently."
ReplyDeleteYes, the vast majority of African Americans do have his back - and I guarantee you, so will most progressives no matter their race when it comes down to voting for President Obama versus one of the GOP candidates.
But he still has some critics in the progressive African American community. I have listened to some very thoughtful critiques from prominent persons such as Cornel West, KRS-One, to name just two. And what they said spoke to the heart of my own disappointment with Obama: he seems to support a corporatist policy more than I expected...way more.
But he does clearly care about all Americans, so I prefer him to any of the GOP candidates. I still believe, strongly, that he is an extremely decent human being. He's also fought for some policies that have made a directly positive impact on my own family.
And I would never condescend to him in any way, much less racially. For one thing, the man is one of the most intelligent presidents we've had in modern history.
I'm with you 100% on that Gryph. Cheers to our President.
ReplyDelete~physicsmom